Where to begin with Thomasin McKenzie? Well, clearly we know how it began (see that story if you haven't already), but in order to bridge the gap between then and this story, I need to quickly sum up her other experiences at the Lodge.
After coming for the first time with Anya Taylor-Joy, lovely Thomasin was, in a word, hooked. Our trio's first experience together was like when you hit it off in a new relationship. Once we hooked up for the first time, the proverbial floodgates were open. Things continued the entirety of the time she and Anya were here, to the point that we rarely left the bedroom at all. That was fine with me, as it was like heaven having Anya's petite frame on one side of me and Thomasin's surprisingly thick one on the other. Yet at the same time, it meant that our first soiree didn't introduce Thomasin to many of the different amenities the Lodge had to offer.
That's when the other trips came into play. I remembered them all vividly. She and Anya came back again, and we would introduce her to the most simple things. Like how we were free to fuck in the hot tub on the deck behind the house. It just took some unwinding on Thomasin's part, and some convincing that no one was going to see her out here. Or a similar story, where Anya and I took Thomasin on one of our hikes through the wooded hills behind the house. Again, Thomasin was game, but was hesitant when Anya and I reached our spot and began to have sex out in the open.
And so it went with Thomasin. Anya would introduce her to something, Thomasin would stutter out a few words of nervous reluctance, Anya would say one thing in reply, and Thomasin would become game for it. And not just for things like fucking in random rooms of the house or outside. Anya tapped into a side of Thomasin that was eager to do anything we were.
Thomasin had never really worn any kind of lingerie for sex, until Anya found her some that fit her perfectly, then Thomasin was strutting around in a corset and a garter belt. Thomasin had never used a strapon, until Anya talked about how hot it would look to see Thomasin thrusting into her, and then next thing I know Thomasin is fucking Anya doggystyle while Anya sucked my cock. Thomasin had never been tied up for sex, until Anya started with a very simple putting her hands behind her back, and then suddenly Thomasin was hog-tied while I fucked her from behind and she ate Anya's pussy. Thomasin had never filmed herself having sex, until Anya busted the camera out, and then later that night the three of us were rewatching our threesome while I played with Thomasin's pussy and Anya sucked my cock. The list goes on.
Then, one night with the three of us, after we were, ahem, 'finished' for the night, Thomasin and Anya were talking. Thomasin was of course in disbelief at what was happening (she was always the slightest bit flustered before, and after), but Anya simply smiled and said how hot it was watching Thomasin do new things. But then, she added,
"And imagine how much fun you'll have teaching all these things to any girls you want to bring up here."
I saw Thomasin become flush once again, smiling nervously as she gave a tiny giggle. She looked away from Anya, and suddenly became preoccupied trying to fix her disheveled hair. Anya looked at me and raised her eyebrows while Thomasin made an awkward stuttering noise as she cleared her throat.
"I can't just...I mean I'm not...eh, I don't really know anyone like that..." Thomasin trailed off.
"Oh, well, maybe someday," Anya winked at Thomasin.
The idea was out there, but at the time I couldn't see Thomasin actually doing it. The way things went at the Lodge was that it required one of the ladies that had been there to use an ever so subtle approach to see if a girl was interested, and then properly explain how it could happen *before* they invited them up. Thomasin was too nervous to make the first move for anything we were doing. More often than not she had to follow Anya's lead just to keep things going.
So color me surprised when Thomasin reached out to me and asked if she could come to visit again. Usually she would ask Anya, and Anya would coordinate it. This time Thomasin had reached out herself, and when I prodded a little harder to get more information, I found out why.
Thomasin was going to bring Elle Fanning with her.
To say I was surprised would be an understatement. I was sure Thomasin was smart enough to realize how things worked up here, so it wasn't that she was bringing a girl up here that didn't know what was going to happen. The question was, how did it get to this point? How in the hell did the conversation swing that direction at all? When I spoke to Thomasin about it, I got a few of the details.
It started, like a lot of these relationships start, with a chance meeting. Thomasin and Elle met at a fashion show, and after sitting next to each other, really hit it off. A fun night of conversation led to staying in touch and getting to know each other on social media, then on phone conversations. Then a mutual crush developed, with neither party knowing that the other reciprocated. But then, the magic word that got their conversation gradually shifting towards what would eventually become an invitation to the Lodge? Just a simple utterance from Elle. A casual mention during one of her talks with Thomasin.
"I'm so horny."
Thomasin told me Elle said those exact words. Imagination of course took over, and I couldn't help but picture Elle saying that with a desperate whine as she rubbed her pussy. That picture led to another picture of Thomasin nervously saying she's never had phone sex before, but starting to play with herself after Elle told her what to do. It was an arousing image, made all the better by me knowing exactly what Thomasin's orgasm face looked like.
Anyway. From there, Thomasin said the conversation had advanced quickly. Thomasin cheekily asked Elle what she liked to do in those situations. Then the conversation shifted from masturbation talk, to when the last time they had both been laid was. Thomasin (using what I later learned was advice from Anya) told Elle that she "knew a guy" who was perfect for the kind of no-strings-attached encounters that could solve such problems. Elle said that sounded perfect. Thomasin said she could arrange a meeting. Elle said she was in.
Even after so long, I sometimes still can't believe it can be that simple.
What I wasn't sure about on the day it happened, was how Thomasin was going to actually react to all this. Normally at the Lodge, the one bringing in someone new is the one kicking things off and taking the lead. So far, Thomasin had not been that. Eager and willing, but only after being prompted by Anya. Would Thomasin be able to show Elle how things worked? Or would Elle be as horny as she claimed and kick things off herself? I really wasn't sure what to expect, and when they both arrived, I still wasn't sure at first.
The two of them arrived together, coming up the front door with Elle excitedly craning her neck upward to look the house up and down. When I opened the door and let them in, Thomasin gave me that dead cute little smile like she does, but passed by without the kind of affectionate greeting I would expect from others that came here. Elle entered as well, introducing herself and shaking my hand, then scanning me up and down. Thomasin introduced me, and we said our hellos, but then Elle went right back to looking in every direction around her. She seemed more interested in the house than in talking.
That was momentarily perplexing, but I maintained the mood (or lack thereof) as Elle wanted to see the house. I quickly took her through the library, dining room, kitchen, gym, etc. It was only when we made our way to the bar area that I was no longer leading. Elle walked past me further into the room, which finally allowed me a moment to stare at the way her amazing ass was sticking straight out of the yoga pants she was wearing. After looking around at the bar and the various couches and armchairs that lined the bar, she turned back and nodded her head, impressed.
"So this is where everyone gets loosened up for what happens next, right?" Elle said as she flashed a smile and giggled.
"Yes it is, right?" I asked as I turned to Thomasin.
