Chapter One Hundred Seventeen: Burn It
"Alright, so...hear me out before you make a judgement, but...I want to burn down the Alienage," Cailan said.
I choked -- on what, I couldn't say -- and began coughing, while Alistair thumped me on the back. Aedan sputtered, face turning an unusual shade of crimson, but Kallian merely raised one eyebrow inquiringly.
Aedan finally managed to get out an entire sentence. "I think you're a lot more sleep-deprived than we thought, Cailan," he ventured.
"Or maybe you had a head injury you didn't tell anyone about during the battle?" I wondered.
Cailan rolled his eyes. "I did ask you to hear me out before you judge," he reminded us.
Alistair waved his arm in a 'go on' sort of gesture, and Cailan nodded at him before turning to Kallian.
"After Denerim was evacuated, it looks like there was a fire started in one of the homes in the Alienage. It burnt a large number of houses, and damaged more. No one was hurt, but it's going to have to be rebuilt. And it gave me an idea.
"Look, I know it's been your home, but the fact is, the Alienage is a mess. It's impossible to keep clean, the houses are falling down, plagues keep spreading there...no one should live like that."
"We've never exactly had much of a choice," Kallian defended.
Cailan threw up his arms excitedly. "No, no, I'm not blaming you. You've done the best you could with what you have. But that's the point, really. You didn't have much to work with, and then once people were living there, it was very difficult to do anything about it, even if someone had tried. We couldn't kick out dozens or hundreds of people while we renovated their homes, and doing it one building at a time was too expensive and time consuming, not to mention the nobility would not have approved the expenditure even if it were possible."
Cailan continued, breathless and enthusiastic, not allowing anyone else to get a word in edgewise, "That's why this is the perfect opportunity. The Alienage is empty, likely for a couple more weeks, and half of it is already destroyed. There's no one to displace. We have a few trustworthy mages available to help us, and the nobility are busy doing other things. If the rest of the Alienage burned while everyone was evacuated, they wouldn't have to approve a motion to rebuild, because I have sole discretion over the budget during an emergency -- and then we could do it right, without a fight. Highever and Amaranthine won't be ready for the stonemasons for a while yet, so those that came from Orzammar are going to be sitting on their thumbs anyway -- and we've already paid for their services. There's a lot of old stone quarries around Denerim that could be reopened.
"We could build multi-story stone buildings, give each family more space, and still have room to spare. We could expand the green space around the Vhenadahl, maybe build a school? It wouldn't even cost that much, especially if the returning residents helped with the construction. The biggest problem will be housing people during the reconstruction, but fortunately it's summer. We could set up temporary camps outside the gates, allow hunting nearby to supplement food stores...we have the army to build camps like we did in the Bannorn. As long as we can keep any rain off, it shouldn't be unbearable until the first buildings are ready, and then people can crowd in and share until everything is finished.
"It gives us an excuse to arm the elves -- they need to protect themselves while living outside of the city, and to hunt. It allows us to improve the Alienage, and even employ some of the elves temporarily as labourers during the building."
He finally stopped, gulping breaths of air rather comically at the end of his hurried speech. He glanced back and forth between Aedan and Kallian, expecting -- correctly -- that the two of them would have the strongest opinions on the subject.
I didn't know what to think. In some ways it made sense -- the Alienage really was a travesty, and burning it to the ground seemed like one of the few ways to recover it, especially if it was as badly damaged as Cailan said -- but where would all those people live during the construction? It would take a lot of time to build as much as he was suggesting, and the evacuees were expected back within weeks at the most. I was also concerned about the likelihood of backlash in the Landsmeet; most nobles' opinions on the city elves seemed to consist of a 'survival of the fittest' mentality. I doubted there was any money left in the Arl of Denerim's estate to cover it either, though it should have been the Arl's responsibility --
if only there was an Arl of Denerim right now -- and not Vaughn or Howe, either.
Aedan shared my concern about the cost, and he and Cailan immediately began debating the viability of the plan from that perspective. Kallian was surprisingly quiet. I expected her to be either enthusiastic at the prospect of making the Alienage livable, or angry at the idea of burning down the rest of her former home, but she just kept her gaze fixed firmly in her lap while Cailan and Aedan brain-stormed the funding aspect. I was barely listening, mind awhirl with possibilities and risks, but it sounded like Aedan thought it was possible.
Finally, when Kallian still hadn't said anything, Cailan addressed her directly. "What do you think?"
She looked up at him, tilting her head slightly. "I think nicer houses won't fix the biggest problem Ferelden -- and the rest of Thedas -- faces with elves." Cailan's face fell, and she held up a hand. "Don't get me wrong -- it would be nice not to worry that the next stiff breeze will blow down someone's home, and to have somewhere for the homeless to go, but without jobs, and income, and the ability to defend ourselves from those who would do us harm, it'll be just a differently-decorated slum. When most humans see us as less worthy of respect than the rodents we end up eating, why bother putting us in prettier houses?"
Cailan looked crestfallen. "I want to improve the elves' lives. I want you to have safe places to sleep and not risk frostbite all winter. I want you to be seen as citizens. It's not going to happen overnight, Maker knows, but can't we at least try? I will do my best to change our culture, a little at a time, but this might be our only opportunity to really address the housing situation. Once everyone is back, as it stands, most of the elves will be homeless, and I think we all know the nobility as a rule will leave them to fend for themselves."
Kallian examined Cailan's earnest face for a long silent moment, and I could almost see the wheels spinning.