Author's note:
If this is the first installment of the story you've opened, I strongly suggest you read the preceding chapters first. This one begins the morning after Miss Devereaux first appeared at the door of 221B Baker Street.
Chapter 4, Watson
Holmes' footsteps on the stairway as he returned from his interview with his brother had awakened me briefly, but curiosity about what Mycroft had to say was insufficient to rouse me from my post-coital torpor. It was only dawn, and the knowledge that Holmes would soon be calling for his breakfast that animated us. The fire in the grate had long since gone out and the morning chill permeated the air. But duty called, and Mrs. Hudson extracted herself from our cozy nest to be up and about her morning routine before the arrival of the maid. She gathered up her scattered clothing without dressing, and was about to dash through the sitting room to the stairs when I laid my hand upon her arm. "Pray wait, while I make sure Holmes has not spent the night brooding in the sitting room upon the clues he unearthed in last night's investigations." So saying, I cracked open the door from my chamber and confirmed that the sitting room was indeed vacant. Thus reassured, I allowed her to retreat to her domicile, reveling in the delightful sight of her jiggling posterior as she crossed to the stairs.
When I returned to the sitting room upon making myself presentable for the day, Holmes also had materialized. He said not a word, but I detected a knowing smirk upon his countenance, leaving no doubt that he had deduced what transpired within my private chamber last evening. For my part, I noted an agitation about him which he typically displays when investigating a case worthy of his powers.
"Does your brother believe that Miss Devereaux has discovered evidence of criminal society acting against the realm's interest?" I inquired.
"Indeed he does. And there is much to be done. I am pondering how best to proceed. The existence of such societies has long been a study of mine. In fact, I have written a brief monograph upon the subject. If Mycroft's information is correct, this particular society is uncommonly well sealed against penetration. The code of silence about their affairs is absolute. No outside agency has ever succeeded in placing a spy in their midst. In spite of that, we must somehow both deduce and thwart their intent."
As we were thus speaking, the maid appeared at our door to announce the presence of Inspector Lestrade from Scotland Yard, followed without further preamble by the inspector himself. "Good morning Holmes. A peculiar case has come to my knowledge overnight that might be of interest to you."
"What about it makes you think thus?"
"The fact that two people have been murdered as a pair. Their mutilated bodies were discovered bound together face to face."
"Tell me no more lest my own investigation be prejudiced by the conclusions you have drawn from your observations. I greatly fear this may be related to matters I just became aware of last evening. Take me to the scene at once. Watson, you must accompany us."
Lestrade conveyed us to an empty apartment fronting on an avenue in a moderately fashionable neighborhood where a constable standing guard at the door allowed our passage through to the interior. Upon the floor lay the two bodies, bound as Lestrade had previously described. Each had been castrated and the excised parts were stuffed in their mouths. Holmes shooed us all out of the room to wait while he conducted his thorough examination of the scene and the victims. Lestrade and I made desultory attempts at small talk for the better part of an hour until he emerged and joined us. "Tell me your impressions Lestrade. How do you think this tableau played itself out?"
"It seems to me fairly simple," replied the inspector. "Someone interrupted this pair of dandies in the course of their unnatural act. Believing the new penal code a mistake, he decided to impose the death penalty as called for in the old statutes. After binding them, he removed their genitalia and let them bleed to death. The presence of their excised parts in their mouths confirms it."
"A reasonable explanation," responded Holmes, "except for the lack of blood. That there is none on the floor around the bodies, together with lack of any sign of struggle, indicates they were murdered elsewhere and moved here. More important, there is no blood at the site of the mutilation, indicating it was done post mortem. Two men conveyed them here in a four-wheeled carriage and carried them inside. One of the men was tall and favored his right leg, another somewhat shorter and rather heavy for his height."
"Regardless," said Lestrade, "my commander is not going to expend any manpower investigating this murder. Buggery disgusts him, and so he will close the case with the simplest of explanations."
"Yours is precisely the conclusion the perpetrator of this crime wants you to reach. We have here a carefully managed scene designed to lead us to an erroneous conclusion. Come Watson, if the authorities prefer to accept the fiction and ignore the facts before their eyes, we have done all we can here. If justice is to be served upon the perpetrator of this outrage, it must come as a result of our efforts."
Holmes summoned a hansom and directed the driver to the Ministry of the Exchequer. "As usual, Lestrade has failed to investigate in detail and by that failure, is forced to settle upon a faulty explanation. I purposely left him to pursue his line because, as I feared, this murder is a direct result of the events of last night. One of the murdered men was Boris, the doorman from Madame DePanne's establishment. The other was none other than Miss Devereaux's client! There is no time to tell you all of what I learned from Mycroft, but I gleaned from Boris the name of the man who vouched for the late client. He is a Mr. Montgomery, a functionary at the Ministry of the Exchequer. I need you to interview him and find out how he is related to our tattooed gentleman. Be judicious in how you approach him. It is possible he plays an innocent role in this little drama. It is equally possible he is intimately involved in it. In either case, he is in danger. For myself, I must pursue a number of leads generated by my inspection of the scene."
The cab dropped me at the Ministry. I sat on a bench outside the building to ponder how to gain the confidence of Mr. Montgomery and convince him to disclose what he knew. Arriving at what I deemed to be a plausible explanation, I presented my card to the receptionist and requested an audience with Mr. Montgomery. The receptionist dispatched a page to convey my request.
After a brief wait, the page returned, leading a rather short, balding man of perhaps forty years who appeared to be of a nervous disposition, wringing his hands and bearing his weight on alternate feet as he consulted with the receptionist. Once I was identified, he walked over and greeted me. "Are you by chance the same Dr. John H. Watson who chronicles the deductive artistry of the incomparable Sherlock Holmes?"
"Indeed I am. Are you a faithful follower of his exploits?"
"I eagerly await each installment. How may I be of service?"
"I am afraid I seek information of a rather delicate nature. Is there a more private place where we can talk?"
He led me to a small consulting room just off the lobby and bade me be seated as he did likewise. "The matter at hand pertains to an incident at the establishment of Madame DePanne," I began. "A foreign gentleman has been involved in an incident, and the doorman has revealed that you were the person who first introduced him to the house. I should like to know your relationship with him."