This is the third story I've written about the Big Bang Theory. The first two are 'The Killer Robot alternative' and 'Penny and Leonard get together'. Whilst there are references to them here, it's unnecessary to read them first in order to understand this story. Although it's always nice to have more views, comments and votes.
Because I loved the show, I tried to keep my characters within arm's length of what the real characters would do. To follow the original storyline as far as possible. I've read other fanfiction about the show which are good, but the ongoing storyline deviates outside of the main plot. With my versions, the overall storyline remains, with sexy interludes.
Shortly after publishing the last one, an anonymous commenter suggested a wild storyline between Penny and Stuart. As it broke my self-imposed rules, I ignored it for several years.
However, the idea of Penny comforting Stuart after the fire at his comic book store stuck with me. The problem for me was it occurred at the end of season 7, just after Penny and Leonard's engagement. So, the idea of Penny and Stuart cheating at that point in their relationship was too alien for the show's arc.
But it continued to niggle at me and the more I thought about it, in the right circumstances; I realised it could be treated as an isolated incident without changing the overall storyline.
A special thanks to RF-Fast for helping to proofread and ensuring the story is in good shape.
Big bang theory - 'The Status Quo Combustion Alternative' Part 01
Chapter 1
Scene: Penny driving her car, she brakes suddenly and slams the heel of her hand down on the steering wheel
"Stupid traffic!" she exclaimed.
The camera switched to an outside shot and pulled back to show her car in a long queue of traffic caused by roadworks.
Cutting back inside the car revealed Penny with her cell phone to her ear.
Scene: Sheldon and Leonard's apartment. Leonard is slipping on a jacket near the door as his cell phone rings.
"Hello?"
The scene splits to show Penny on one side of the screen and Leonard on the other.
"Hey Leonard."
"Hey Penny. What's up?"
"I'm stuck in traffic."
"Oh, that sucks!"
"No, what sucks is me not seeing my boyfriend all week."
"I know, and I'm sorry. But I explained how I could only get to run these experiments at the university overnight."
"I know you explained about your stupid clever experiment in way too much detail. Something about too much vibration during the day. I miss you."
"And I miss you..."
"No, I mean
I miss you
." she emphasised the last words.
"What?" Leonard asked, confused momentarily. Then he understood. Penny was in the mood. "Oh, right."
"Yeah, exactly. You know how I get if we go more than three or four days."
"I know, but I managed years without..." Penny interrupted him.
"Leonard, this isn't a competition, and certainly not one you want to win."
"Sorry."
"I even snuck out of work early to get to see you. Are you still at the apartment?"
"Yeah, but I'm literally just picking up my keys." His actions followed his words.
"Couldn't you hang on for like another 15 minutes? I can probably get there in time for a quickie?"
"Sorry, I want to. I really, really want to, but this experiment is for the military, and they keep track of my comings and goings."
Penny slumped back in her car seat, defeated.
"And how much longer will they take?"
"Another week, sorry!" he added automatically.
"So now what am I going to do? It's Friday night and my boyfriend, no, correct that, fiancé. And has abandoned me?" She knew she was being unfair, but she was frustrated.
When Leonard had first told her about his experiment, his explanation, although delivered with enthusiasm, had been almost incomprehensibly boring. So, she'd missed the fact he told her he would be working throughout the night, and they would not see each other.
"How about I do something to make it up to you? How about a weekend away?" He asked, and Penny looked a little mollified. But didn't want to be bought off so easily.
"With Bernadette and Howard looking after Mrs Wolowitz, Amy and Sheldon on a date night, and Raj seeing Emily, what am I supposed to do?" She asked, realising she sounded a little whiny.
"Why not call one of your old friends? The girls you used to go dancing with?" Leonard asked.
"We all used to dress up kinda slutty, flirt with all the guys, and get hit on a lot? Is that really a good idea?" With how she was feeling at the moment, not a good idea at all. She wasn't entirely sure she could turn down all the advances. The memories of the times she'd made out in one club or another with some hunky guy, floated through her mind.
"How about Stuart?" Leonard suggested, and the name caused her mind to skip the rails. The image of being in Stuart's arms instead of some hunk popped into her head, and she had to shake her head to lose it. Leonard continued.
"Since his comic book shop burned down, he's been really depressed..."
"He's always depressed." Penny countered.
"I know, but this time it's worse. I worry about him; sometimes I think he just needs someone to take care of him. I promised I'd help clean up his shop, but that was before I knew about the lab time. You could go see him, be supportive and help clean up?"
"Really Leonard? You've seen my apartment. I barely clean up after myself, let alone someone else's place."
"Come on, Stuart's a good guy. You'd be doing a good deed, and you even dated him once."
"So, that's your brilliant idea? When you're not available, you send me off to an ex-boyfriend?"
"I didn't mean it like that. I just meant that if I'd not gotten jealous when I saw you two going out, I might not have worked up the courage to ask you out."
"It certainly took you long enough."
"I know, and I know we could talk long and hard about all my shortcomings, but I really have to get to work. I love you."
"And I love you too," Penny replied, hanging up.
Scene: The landing outside Sheldon and Leonard's apartment. Penny appeared on the stairs and let herself into the boy's apartment.
She dropped her purse on the table, threw herself down on the couch, and stared up at the ceiling.
"This sucks! It seems like the second I'm engaged, the sex goes away. I thought that only happened after marriage?" She asked herself.
It was something that had been bothering her about agreeing to Leonard's stream of proposals. Everyone she knew who got married told her their sex lives suffered after the big day. Moreover, she was quite a sexual being, more so than Leonard anyway, more so than most of her boyfriends.
Actually, that was the issue and it was kind of like your tongue poking at a sore tooth. She loved Leonard, she really did, and she knew he adored her. However, since she'd been hanging out with a gang of geniuses, or was it genii? Whatever. She knew she wasn't one. She'd learnt introspection, including the meaning of that word.
Watching Sheldon do nothing but think for a living had caused her to question what she thought about while she worked at the Cheesecake factory. And she had to admit she didn't. Maybe worry about her bills, hopes for her next audition, not long-term things.
She'd always been impulsive, craving instant gratification and heedless of the consequences. As a child that had shown up as tantrums over wanting candy in a store, when she could have all the homemade pie she wanted later. That would always cost her the pie, but it didn't stop her from doing it again.
As she grew older when she was slighted by a girlfriend, or at least thought she was, she might make out with her friend's boyfriend or worse. That would cost her their friendship, but she'd just move on. Perhaps that was one reason she craved being an actor, to assume a role and abandon it once she was finished with it.
The same with relationships. They were disposable, if or when she fucked up. She knew she could walk away. Each time she moved on, it was a clean slate, only she rarely bothered to learn from experience.
The same with boyfriends. She'd choose them on first impressions. That of their looks, and being tall and handsome, didn't mean they were nice people or even good lovers. Often the ability to have a new girl in their arms, or on their cocks at the snap of their fingers meant they never learned.
Unlike people like Leonard, who didn't have the looks and had to learn to be nice, thoughtful of others and their lovers. OK, the first time with Leonard had been disappointing, but he quickly became the most giving lover she'd ever had, sacrificing his pleasure for hers. With practice came confidence, and with that, they became compatible lovers. He'd learned to read her needs as if reading them from a textbook.
There were a few shortcomings, apart from the physical. Sometimes she liked to take charge and at others, she preferred her lover to do so. Probably indoctrination from previous boyfriends, but Leonard still struggled to 'take charge' as often as she'd like. The other issue and the one most pressing now was he didn't notice when she needed it.
Moreover, her problem was that while she knew of these shortcomings, she could guard against them. But she knew it was almost impossible she'd catch herself every time. Getting married was something that she wanted, but something that scared her. If she fucked up, it was permanent.
She needed some safety mechanism, something to reduce the pressure, a safety valve or something. Perhaps she should wear herself out with exercise. Change into her running clothes and put a few miles under her belt. But that seemed like hard work.