I had been seeing Shay Mitchell, the sexy, and some would say, sexiest period, cast member of "Pretty Little Liars", for about six months, and we had just moved in to my place together when I first met Jana Kramer, the actress-turned-country-singer, after one of her concerts.
And ever since then, we had been having an affair for at least half that long behind not only Shay's back, but behind Jana's fiancee's back, as well.
You might think it would be easy to keep the two ladies separated, but I found it thrilling to know that Shay could walk in on Jana and me at any time, which I why I almost always invited Jana over to my place for us to have sex, and not the other way around.
Well, one night when Jana was feeling particularly frisky, I invited her over, thinking Shay was going to be out on the "PLL" set until late, therefore giving us enough time to do what we needed to do and keep everything to ourselves like we had been doing.
It all started out like any other night that Jana and I had gotten together recently, but would wind up getting out of hand pretty quickly.
"Come on in baby," I told Jana as I greeted her at the door and let her into my house, staring at her in her cut-off shorts and little red top that didn't leave a whole lot to the imagination, planting a kiss on her lips as I closed the door behind me.
"I can't stop thinking about you John...I haven't been able to stop thinking about you since that night I met you after my show and you took me out for drinks before we wound up back here fucking," Jana whispered as I kissed her lips again, both of my hands squeezing her ass as I led her toward my couch, "I can't even have sex with my man anymore without wishing or pretending it was you that was fucking me."
"You're all I can think about too, Jana," I told her as I squeezed her ass some more and gave her a long, deep kiss, our hands going on the back of each other's heads as we really started to get into it, "even when I fuck Shay, I find myself pretending you're the one I'm fucking, baby."
"MMM...shouldn't you lock it baby? Wouldn't want Shay to walk in on us would we?" Jana asked me as I laid her on my couch and straddled her, noticing I had failed to lock the door, as I started kissing her neck and making out with her while we tore at each other's clothes.
"She's on set and won't be home for a while," I told her as I started sucking on her tits, lining my dick up with her pussy as I lifted her ass off the couch.
"Good...you don't need that slut anyway John..." Jana whispered, turning me on far more than it should have to hear her call my girlfriend a slut as I slid into her and started to fuck her.
"OHGOD...fuck me John...tell me how much better my pussy is than Shay's baby..." Jana hissed as I started to thrust in and out of her, her walls wrapping tightly around it as she contorted her body in a way that sent my dick all the way up inside of her.
"FUCK YES...so tight Jana...you're much tighter than Shay is baby..." I whispered to her as I placed her long legs on my shoulders and started bottoming out inside of her, her eyes starting to roll back in her head as she worked her hips around my dick, her back arching as she banged her fists into the couch.
"OHGOD...OHGOD...there...fuck me there John...make me cum like the slut I am..." she shouted when my dick slid into her g-spot, her walls tightening up around it as she arched her back and threw her head back, her body going limp as she shot her cum all over it.
"YEAH...you fucking cum on that dick Jana...gonna cum in your slutty pussy soon..." I hissed as I drove myself in and out of her, her eyes rolling back into her head as she pushed her hips into mine as the head of my dick slid past her cervix and into her womb.
"OHGOD...YES...cum inside me John...let's make a baby together...I went off the pill just for you, you know baby..." she hissed as she twisted her hips around my dick, both of us grunting out as I came deep into her baby-making chamber, gobs of my cum sticking to her walls and seeping into her womb as I held myself inside of her.
"WHAT THE FUCK IS GOING ON HERE??!!??" I heard a familiar voice shout from behind us, Shay having walked in on us at some point while I was blowing my load inside of Jana, "WHO THE FUCK IS THIS SKANK JOHN?!? AND WHY ARE YOU LETTING HER COME BETWEEN US?"
"Shay...calm down-" I began, Shay coming over to the couch and balling her fists as I shot a few more loads of cum into Jana and pulled out of her, Jana holding me close to her by the arm.
"NO! I WILL NOT CALM THE FUCK DOWN JOHN! I JUST WALKED IN ON YOU FUCKING "THE OTHER WOMAN" AND HEARD HER PRACTICALLY FUCKING BEGGING YOU TO KNOCK HER UP!" Shay shouted as she pulled me away from Jana and went to slap her face, surprised to find Jana blocking her hand.
"If you would calm the fuck down I can explain Shay," Jana told her, getting up and assuming a fighting stance as I reached for my phone, trying to diffuse the situation the whole time.
"The bitch knows my name and she still has the nerve to wreck our home," Shay sneered, staring a hole through me the whole time as Jana tried to convince her to not get physical.
"I can't help it if I find your man fucking irresistible Shay," Jana told her, flashing her engagement ring in her face to show her that it wasn't just our home she was wrecking, "but just because we're both fucking the same guy doesn't mean we have to hate each other's guts."
"Get the fuck out of my sight you two-timing whore!" Shay shouted at Jana before turning to me and starting to let me have it, just about to tell me we were through when I came up to her and kissed her lips.
"Don't...you know I'm pissed at you...how could you do this to me when you know how much I love you..." she whispered as I kissed her on the lips again, feeling her body start to loosen up as she stumbled over the arm of the couch, falling onto it with me on top of her as I started to kiss her neck.
"OHGOD...I can't...I'm mad at you...FUCK...I forgot how good your lips feel on my neck..." she whimpered, her eyes closing as I sucked on her neck and laid her on the couch, Jana coming around the side of it and sliding Shay's skirt down as I pulled her shirt over her head.
"You can't be that mad at me baby...you're moaning for me like you're all hot and bothered..." I teased her as I slid her panties away and parted her legs, lowering my head between them and running my tongue along her slit as Jana sat on her stomach and started making out with her.
"Let me show you some of the things that made your man fall for me," Jana whispered to her, kissing Shay on the lips and sliding her tongue between Shay's lips as they began to make out.
"UH..." Shay hissed into Jana's mouth as I slid my tongue into her pussy, feeling her cunt lips pull it a little deeper into her as I started to eat her out, Jana kissing her neck and sucking on one of her tits as I sucked on the other one.
"OHGOD...I shouldn't be enjoying this..." Shay hissed as she and Jana swapped spit while I dragged my tongue along her deepest walls, feeling her jerk her hips sharply up in the air when I buried it inside of her.
"Cum for me and I'll fuck you even harder than I fucked Jana," I whispered to her as she threw her head back, her eyes rolling back into her head as she shot her load of cum all over my tongue, Jana sucking on her tits as Shay arched her back and pushed her hands into the back of my head, leaving me there until she rode out her orgasm.
