This is a (long overdue) sequel to The Island. Sorry it's taken me so long to complete this. I'm hoping the gap between Chapter 2 and 3 won't be so long. I recommend reading Chapter 1 first as it sets up the premise for the series.
***
Five Amazons were standing over us.
Circling us, with spears pointing in my direction, were Alexis Knapp, Brittany Snow, Anna Camp, Hana Mae Lee and Anna Kendrick. Each dressed as if they had just walked off the set of Xena.
"Well what the sweet fuck do we have here?" Anna Kendrick pointed at me. "You've got some explaining to do Amanda. Have you been holding out on us? Have you hidden away a man on the island. Are we not enough for you?"
I was still on top of Amanda. She had found me on the beach after my ship crashed onto the island. I had come to rescue her, and hundreds of women like her, but it was I who was rescued. Amanda Seyfried had pulled me from the wreckage. She was a concubine here and begged me to fuck her. I had tried to resist — I was on a mission. But she was so beautiful and so deft and disarming my defences that she left me no choice and soon we were having sex at the top of the beach. Anna Kendrick and her friends had emerged from the forest just as Amanda and I both reached climax.
I began to lift myself off Amanda.
"I should explain," I said. But just as I began to get to my knees, Anna Kendrick used her spear to knock me back to the ground. She placed her foot on my neck.
"Did I speak to you? Men are not welcome here. Men do not speak unless we say they can. Amanda, where did he come from?"
I tried to move Anna's foot from my throat but it wouldn't budge. God, she was strong. She'd obviously been working out during her time on the island. Amanda pointed to the wreckage of my ship. Smoke still billowing from the remains.
"He's from off the island, beyond the shield. He said he's here to rescue us."
Anna moved her foot down to my chest and ground it in harder. I groaned.
"Do we look like we need rescuing? You're pathetic. We've been here forty years and we haven't needed men." She spat the final word.
"Four years." Amanda said. "He said it's only been four years outside the shield. They didn't know."
"Maybe we should let him explain," said Anna Camp. She stepped forward and looked me up and down. Her gaze drifted across my body and lingered around my cock. "He's not a threat but he could prove...useful."
"For fucks sake Anna. You're always thinking with your pussy," said Alexis.
"I can't help it," Camp replied. "She's a predator."
"Okay, that's enough," Kendrick was taking control of the conversation. "You," she said looking me in the eyes. "Explain yourself. And you better make sense. You can feel how strong I am. You know I'll have no problem in spearing you with this." She dragged the tip of the spear along my chest, grazing it but not drawing blood.
I carefully moved the spear away and sat up. I began to explain how I came to be on the island. How I was part of a task force that had been set up following the incident to track down the scientists, bring them to justice for what they'd done to the world and how I'd volunteered for this mission to bring the kidnapped women home.
"And instead you end up fucking the first one you find?" said Kendrick.
"I fucked him," said Amanda. "I didn't give him much choice. It's been so long since I've been with a man. Since any of us have been with a man. Have you forgotten how good it feels?"
Amanda Seyfried moved towards Anna Kendrick and walked around her. She came up behind her, licked her neck and spoke quietly into Anna's ear.
"You know how good I am Anna...but even I can't compete with a good...hard...cock." She stretched out the final words as she brought her hands around Anna's body and up until she cupped Kendrick's breasts. "Don't pretend you haven't been looking. Don't pretend you haven't been thinking about it. It's been years since you've had a man inside you. And now, here one sits, practically begging for you to fuck him."
