This tale leaks all over the map -- a pinball machine, unclassifiable: straight boys and gay sex, exhibitionism and cross-dressing, but predominantly celebrity-prompted, starting and ending with famous actresses, drooling over, emulating and impersonating. So here we go...
*****
All this happened a long time ago, in the legendary year of the 1984 Oscars. Back then in the pre-internet era the Academy Awards represented an amazing, celebratory, singular event, even for the miserable crew of Animal House college boys who shared my dwelling. Dazzling films of remarkable quality were up for awards that year, beauteous actresses on show for display. Escapism, for a night at least, represented a promising activity for us all.
My normal life at university then was unremarkable in many ways. Midwestern US state institution, not even the main campus but a second-tier satellite campus where they had shunted the vet school and the accountancy majors. All of us were blue-collar grunts, trying to make something out of not much.
The following event occurred during my final year, our motley foursome scrum having infested an off-campus house, the condition of which pretty much resembled what you would expect from a bunch of male, ne'er-do-well seniors just about to graduate.
Cheap, run-down house, a mile from campus, in a neighborhood that had hit its prime thirty years ago. We had a shabby couch and patchy walls, but Rod had supplied a television, and the fridge was always stocked with beer, often not much else. At least we each had our own single rooms.
Gary was our Apha-male, although that's not saying much. He was six feet tall with dark curly hair, clean-shaven, with a perpetually dazed look in his eyes, a finance major with visions of grandeur but quite lacking in all but the most primitive communications skills. His main claim to prestige consisted of keeping us furnished with a near-constant supply of Pabst Blue Ribbon beer. We didn't ask his source or contribute to funding, we just were happy to indulge whenever the urge struck.
He was the one who got things started that Sunday night back in '84. The Oscars were on, which back then happened in April, and we all found excuses to absent ourselves from course-work to watch the television and hoot and make rude noises about the actresses in plunging gowns who traipsed across the stage, and what we would do with them had we been their escorts, laughable as that scenario would have been.
We were gathered on the couch or the various chairs about, swilling PBR and grunting out our opinions. Dolly Parton handed out one of the awards that year, and you can imagine she came in for what we regarded as blindingly imaginative commentary.
When the movie Yentl came up for consideration, Daniel announced how much he would enjoy impaling Barbara Streisand with his raging, manly prick. "Up to her eyeballs," he said while humping his hips around, "she'd have spunk coming out of her nose."
Danny was tall, skinny, dumb as a fence-post, with dirty blond hair, but he was raw-boned and a decent guy in a naive, rustic way.
Rod from upstate, crude and abrasive in his flannel shirt and jeans, his dark beard stubble a couple days old, hooted in derision.
"She wouldn't take no uncircumcised cock up her kosher cunt, you dumb fuck."
Danny looked surprised.
"Whattaya mean?"
"She's Jewish, for fuck's sake. Only a circumcised cock is going to work. You think she's not fussy about such things?" Rod gave him a withering look.
"How come you're so sure I'm uncircumcised?" Dan gazed defiantly around the room. "You sneak around the place looking at dicks when nobody's paying attention?"
His expression challenged the others, then he flashed a look at me with a warning "Don't you dare say anything" expression, assuming I was the only one who knew.
Of course I did know something about the surgical status of his penis. I should perhaps have mentioned that my sexual activities back then at university were elastic, confused, fluid, enthusiastic, eclectic, opportunistic, and inclusive. With very few long-term relationships on my record (in truth I wasn't even remotely ready for one) I guess I regarded sex as an "improv" activity. "Any port in a storm," "carpe orgasm," and all that.
At that time I would try almost anything at least once if the opportunity presented itself. I do admit to enjoying the sight of an erect penis, ever since I saw the first one besides my own, and I also didn't mind doing something to one when the occasion arose, so to speak.
I had frigged Danny to completion one memorable Saturday night back in November when we were the only ones at the place, horny and desperate for release, and he was more than a little drunk. His foreskin had slid up and down marvelously over his cock-head before spewing sperm all over my fingers. I cannot precisely recollect how we managed to maneuver ourselves into that particular situation. Dan had enjoyed the attention but neither reciprocated nor said a word about the event later, pretending it never had happened.
I guess I am what they call an enabler or something. I like solving problems. While an erect penis is not a "problem" necessarily, I do not mind contributing solutions. As far as I am concerned, the majority of my own life has been centered about solving my own penis.
But things, of course, are inevitably more complicated than that. I oversimplify.
But while Dan knew I had some knowledge of his prick, he shouldn't have been surprised that others might have had some intelligence on the matter. There had been plenty of comings and goings from the shower and bathroom for us all in our tight quarters and it wouldn't have been remarkable that his organ had gotten glimpsed a time or two. Obviously Rod was in the loop.
Well, the whole argument got out of hand at that point, not the first time that a minor disagreement ran off the tracks for us, especially when we were all well-lubricated with beer. Everyone threw in their two cents, yelling and disputing.
"She wouldn't get past a first kiss with you anyway, with your back-woods beer breath," taunted Gary.
"Or if you're testicles were the size of tennis balls!" added Rod.
"You could try a couple Yiddish words on her, to warm her up," I suggested helpfully, hoping to redirect the conversation a little. "You know any?"
Dan gave me a nasty look. Of course he didn't know any Yiddish, I should have known that. I'm not even sure he even knew what "Yiddish" was.
"Let's see the cock," shouted Rod. "Prove the point! Cut or not-cut? Would Streisand take you or not? She ain't gonna take no penis with a sheath over its business end!"
We all stared at Dan, who stood with his hands on his hips, glaring back at us.
"But a cut cock doesn't automatically prove he's Jewish," pointed out Gary sensibly enough. "Even if it turns out he is cut, that doesn't mean Streisand's gonna go all slut on him."
"Right, but an uncircumcised one means you're Definitely Not Jewish," retorted Rod with impeccable logic, anxious to get his claim settled.
This stellar rhetoric is a fair example of the heights of epistemological excellence our debates often achieved.
"So if you claim you're circumcised, you big stud, prove it," challenged Gary. "Show us the goods."
You could see Dan trying to calculate the odds, whether to fold his hand or bluff his way along.
"So who here's uncut?" said Dan, finally, exasperated.
Dan was the only backwoods guy among us, from rough farm country up by the Canadian border, all the rest of us from the grungy former mill-towns or rusted industrial cities that characterized our state. I could easily have told him that everyone else was circumcised, since that was the norm for the non-rural (at least non-Catholic) middle class in our region at that time. And, of course, I had empirical evidence on everyone else too, one way or another.
It suddenly occurred to me that I was perhaps the only one with this knowledge. So I just sat back with a smile to see how all this would play out, entirely amused at Dan's predicament and how he would try to extricate himself.
So the argument went on for a little while and Dan wouldn't back down, said it was time to verify. He was clearly banking on at least one other uncircumcised penis. He insisted on global proof.
Gary said, "Okay, fair enough, even draw, everyone has to show."
So we all flopped our dicks out. Dan looked a little undone, all these other naked cock-heads out in the air with no scabbards like his.
So then Gary expostulated about how Streisand would slaver her lips over any of the other three manly cocks now out in the open, Jewish-friendly if only in a de facto way, but not Dan's peasant, backwoods organ with its unsightly foreskin and hopeless, non-kosher condition.
I should probably tell you how I knew about the condition of the cocks of Rod and Gary.
Back in January, a nasty cold night, Gary had rented a VHS machine for the weekend and of course we had stocked up on some porn from the rental place. Dan was gone that weekend, which explains why he didn't know about everybody else's cocks.