(Note: all characters are of legal, consenting age)
John is and always will be my besetting weakness.
Even after I had so recently defeated James Moriarty, the greatest criminal mastermind to darken London's streets, who else aside from John could send me rambling around London for almost three months, plucking petals from the metaphorical daisy and bemoaning the infinite tragedy of it all like some mawkish schoolboy?
When I watched him walk slump-shouldered away from the roaring basin of Reichenbach Falls, I wasn't sure that I would prove capable of following through with the plans which were rapidly beginning to coalesce in my mind. By which I mean that I was uncertain I would be capable of living without John as I had so contentedly many years before. When I returned to London three years later with Moran in my sights, I had surrendered the vanity of my independence. I may have proven that I could survive without John, but I had also realized that I simply didn't want to, and that this wanting was laden with romantic rather than platonic attachment.
I was bothered far less by the fact that I had developed such an affection for another man than I was by the fact that I had allowed one to develop at all. I've never had any qualms about inverts, perhaps because I perceive my own lack of passionate interest in either sex to be a similar aberration. I also confess to harboring a deep but secret glee that my feelings for John have quite accidentally and innocently confirmed every accusation of failed manhood which my father had ever levelled at me, and my only regret was that he was no longer alive to learn of it. Therefore it was not my own sense of morality or ideas about my personality that sent me on my agonized wanderings that spring of 1894.
Nor was it, somewhat oddly enough, any substantial concern about rejection. By that point I had become all but certain that John was at least partially inverted, a conclusion I had drawn from innumerable little observations that I'd made over the years, which had been bolstered by John's tendency to talk in his sleep; thus I harbored little anxiety about the potential for violent rejection on the grounds of John's moral disgust or indignation. He is also so endlessly tolerant and forgiving of my peculiarities and oversights that I had no fear of losing John's friendship entirely should the confession of the true nature of my attachment to him not be received in kind.
The two things which caused me so much doubt and self-recrimination and misery that spring were the loss of my independence which I believed an explicitly recognized romantic relationship with John would entail, and my concomitant initiation into the Ritual. While my anxiety about the former was more intense, it was relatively short-lived; it didn't take much consideration for me to realize that I had wandered into the labyrinth of emotional entanglement with John long before I had become conscious of it myself, and I had left no trail of twine in my wake. For good or for ill, I was lost, and bemoaning the fact was only so much crying over spilt milk.
My anxieties about the Ritual were more nebulous but they nagged at me endlessly, as all insoluble problems do when I have taken them up for contemplation. I had at last run up against a puzzle for which my own powers of observation and deduction were useless, and clues to which none of my previously relied upon sources could guide me. Even had my enquiries been about performing the Ritual with a woman, my own library and that of the British Museum could have provided me little guidance outside of anatomical illustrations, physiological descriptions, and the vagueries of 14th-century troubadours. It was absurd to even consider referring to the expertise of colleagues such as Lestrade, most of whom were involved with the law, in one form or another; brother Mycroft had no more interest or experience with the whole circus than I had at the time; and asking advice of the sailors and male prostitutes who would have had firsthand, personal experience with my chosen variant of the Ritual would have been an invitation to a good, sound robbing, at best.
Thus it was that I found myself, a 36-year old man and one whom John has portrayed as the most unerringly brilliant citizen of the Empire since Sir Isaac Newton, splashing through every filthy puddle in London that rain-drenched spring, asking myself such mortifying questions as: How often did a normal couple engage in the Ritual? How often would John expect me to do so? What if I lacked the stamina for a regular expenditure of such vital energy? What if my penis wouldn't become erect? What if the Ritual were unpleasant or even excruciating and I was unable to participate?
The latter was a distinct possibility due to an unusual abnormality with which I am afflicted, one which makes coming into physical contact with other people often intolerable. I know neither the name for this malady, if there is one, nor whether its origins are mental or physiological; I myself suspect that they are both, and that, whatever the abnormality may be, it is something that has plagued me for as long as I can remember. It is an ineffable, varying phenomenon, and one unaccompanied by the type of physical signs and symptoms which lend one's complaints substance and veracity, so that I have difficulty describing it convincingly myself.
Perhaps the most concise explanation would be to simply say that being touched by another person distracts me excessively so that I can think of little else until I am relieved of the stimulus. Depending on where, how, and sometimes by whom I am touched, the degree of distraction varies from mere annoyance to dire, virtually uncontrollable emotional anxiety, and is sometimes accompanied by a sensation of physical discomfort, as if my skin were excessively tender or raw.
It was this aberration of my anatomy that worried me perhaps most of all, specifically my fear that it would prevent me from fully participating in the Ritual and drive John into the arms of someone else for physical satisfaction. This was nearly too upsetting to contemplate. I could vie for John's affection by matching wits with any other man in England, I could at least hold my own in a physical confrontation even with the bulkiest of brutes, but I feared that my tactile abnormality would deter my ability to compete with other men's intimate prowess. Yet I dared not mention the problem to John, since to preclude the possibility of intimate congress would make the change in our relationship from platonic to romantic merely a theoretical one, and then why should I bother bringing it up at all? Not to mention that confessing my difficulties with one of the most fundamental forms of human contact would likely bode ill for my suitability as a mate and lifelong companion.