Lighting up Starlight

Disclaimer: I do not own The Boys. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

*

"So, ready for your big speech?"

Annie January blushed furiously and turned around to see Maggie Sawyer, although she was so shocked, she barely had the presence of mind to use her other name, "Maeve, what are you doing here?"

"Nice to see you too." Maeve smirked, slowly walking further into the otherwise empty tent, while looking the younger woman up and down.

"Homelander's here." Annie warned.

"He just left." Maeve corrected the other Super, "I didn't know why, but he seemed mad. Distracted. Still, who knows how long we have? So, we should make this quick."

As she was talking Maeve stepped into Annie's personal space, making her whimper softly, before she pointed out, "I... I, I have to be on stage in a few minutes."

"Like I said, we should be quick." Maeve grinned.

Maggie very nearly grabbed hold of that beautiful face and pulled it in for a deep, passionate kiss. If it was anyone else, or maybe if Maeve was more drunk, it would have been forceful right from the beginning. However, Annie had been made the victim of a sexual predator on her very first day in The Seven, meaning Maggie always had to be careful not to cross the line from forceful, to forcing.

Because the irony here was that sweet little Starlight was the biggest bottom she'd ever met, who loved being told what to do, and pushed around by her stronger lover. However, she was also supersmart, and certainly not done trying to talk to Queen Maeve after this. So after a few long seconds of allowing Maeve's lips to hover over her own, Annie clearly disappointed both of them by pulling back.

"I can't." Annie said softly, and hesitantly, which gave Maggie hope, even as the younger girl insisted, "I need to get into the right head space for this, not..."

"Sin? Dyke out in the middle of the church event? Make sweet baby Jesus weep?" Maeve offered, knowing that she was being cruel, but unable to help it. Although the look on sweet Starlight's face actually had her apologizing, "I'm sorry, but you know places like this make me mad. They're all hypocrites, you know? Every last one of them."

"Not all of them." Annie said softly.

"Please." Maeve snorted, completely losing her temper, "They preach love, but if someone's different... if someone... wants something different from them, they tell them that they're going to hell. Or lynch them. And they promise to have all the answers, when they don't. Their liars, hypocrites, and everything they say is just bull-shit. I mean, you don't believe this stuff anymore, do you?"

There was a long pause, then Annie softly said, "I... I think if there is a God, he doesn't care if I like girls. And I don't know whether he actually gives a shit about any of us, but I know my faith is not just bull-shit. It has good, important lessons to teach, for those who want to hear it. Do bad people manipulate it to use other people? Yes, but it helps people, like the ones in the audience. That's who I'm here for.

Another pause, and then Maggie admitted, "Fuck, you're way too good for me."

"I know." Annie teased.

"And like, anyone." Maggie continued, "And I'm sorry, I just... I hate these places."

"I know." Annie repeated, a lot less playfully.

"But they got one thing right..." Maggie grinned, looking her girl up and down again, "Putting you back in your classic costume. Ohhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh, mmmmmmmm, that's what I like to see. My very favourite parts of you covered up. But I wonder, what's underneath? Huh? Are you wearing it, like I told you too? Huh? Are you? Show me!"

Annie blushed, and softly began, "I-"

"Now!" Maeve firmly demanded.

There was a long pause, then sweet little Starlight bent over the make-up table in front of her, pushed everything except the mirror in front of her to the side and lifted up her skirt to reveal cute little white panties. She then hesitated a little, before grabbing those panties and pulled them down slowly, revealing the perfect little ass which always made Maeve drool with lust.

More importantly, she caught a glimpse of what she had been hoping to see, and then sweet little Starlight gave her an even better look at it by spreading her cheeks. Oh yes, sweet little Starlight spread her cheeks, revealing there was a butt-plug stretching her ass hole. The butt-plug Maeve had instructed her submissive anal bitch to wear for her during this event.

"Good girl." Maeve purred with another wicked grin, staring lustfully at her prize for a few long seconds, before whispering into Annie's ear, "Mmmmmmmm, such a good, Christian girl, in the middle of Capes For Christ, showing off her ass to it's rightful owner. And you know what? She's going to continue to be good, while her owner gets a nice big cock to stretch out her shit hole."

Poor little Annie January whimpered pathetically, but did as she was told, as Maeve left the tent, collected her strap-on, and made her way back. She did this as slowly as she possibly could, and didn't hide the sex toy, daring someone to say something about it. They were backstage, so this wouldn't upset anyone in the audience, who sweet Annie was apparently here for.

However, there were a few stage assistances who saw what she was carrying, and blushed. But they didn't say anything. Maybe they assumed this was for one of the male speakers? Probably, but honestly, Maeve didn't really care. All she cared about was getting back to her girl, and fucking that perfect little ass of hers.

When she returned, and found that Annie really hadn't moved a muscle, Maeve was just about able to prevent herself from beaming happily, and then praising, "God, such a good girl."

She managed to whisper this softly into Annie's ear again, with the same beautiful response. Namely, soft whimpering, sweet little Starlight clearly incredibly uncomfortable, and yet obeying her top like the hot little bottom she was. Which had Maeve quickly attaching that harness, without removing her superhero costume, and then grabbing hold of that butt-plug.

Fuck, she really wanted to just yank it out, and slam every inch of her big dick straight up that heavenly little ass. Hell, the seemingly innocent Starlight would probably actually enjoy that. However, why rush the best thing she had in her life? So instead, Maggie Sawyer really took her time, savouring every precious moment of having little Annie January as her anal fuck toy.

Annie was deeply embarrassed and humiliated. Mostly by the fact that she loved being treated this way so much. Hell, she kind of wished she got caught just like this, waiting for her top. Maybe by Ashley again? That poor girl had been forced to watch Queen Maeve fuck Starlight's ass to orgasm last time she caught them. Hell, she was probably lucky she was 100% straight, given her reactions.

If she wasn't, Queen Maeve might have insisted that she joined them, and Annie didn't want that. No, she wanted her top's full attention on her, just like it was now, as her childhood hero slid a butt-plug in and out of Starlight's slutty little ass hole, the redhead making it really hard for the blonde to keep quiet. And not because she wanted to beg for mercy, or even beg for help.

In fact, it was very much the opposite. Oh God, Annie had worked so hard on becoming a pure and wholesome superhero that little girls could look up too. Just like she had, ironically with Queen Maeve. But now here she was, bent over and spreading her ass cheeks, to allow her top to get the best possible look of a butt-plug sliding in and out of her back door. And not only was it Queen Maeve who was anally violating her, but Annie was loving every second of it.

Fuck, her childhood hero had turned her into such an anal whore. Or revealed that deep down, she always was one. Either way, the mighty Starlight was struggling not to moan, whimper and cry out too loudly in pleasure. And most importantly, not begging for more too soon, and allowing her top to have her fun stretching out the fuck hole which had once been exit only.

That included switching between pulling the butt-plug all the way out, and other times pulling it out to the widest part of it, and then keeping it there. And on occasion, turning it around inside of her. Even making her suck it. Thanks to the training she had received, Annie loved the taste of her own butt, almost as much as her childhood hero loved feeding it to her.

However, it left her ass feeling empty and unloved, and gave a false hope that this would finally be the time she got that dick up her needy little tailpipe. And yet, cruelly Queen Maeve chose to return that plug to her bottom, even though she was aching for something bigger. Of course, when she finally got it, she wished she had something to muffle her.

Disappointingly, it was only a finger, but it was a step in the right direction, so the seemingly pure and wholesome Starlight moaned with blissful happiness around the butt-plug currently in her mouth, which was covered with her own ass cream. Thankfully, it wasn't long before she received a second finger, which slipped in just as easily as the first. Which again, Annie very much enjoyed. She really did.

She just didn't understand why she was receiving this treatment, when she was already stretched out? Then all of a sudden, a third finger was added, making her nervous that she might have been given a clue where this was going. Something which was seemingly confirmed, when a record fourth finger was added.

"Still sooooooooooo fucking tight!" Maeve moaned dreamily, as she squeezed that fourth finger into her girlfriend's most private hole, "Oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhh, mmmmmmmmm, no matter what I do to this cute little shit hole of yours, it always returns to virgin tightness. Fuck, what would your fans think, if they knew that? Would they still see you as pure and wholesome, if they knew you were the perfect anal whore?"

"Maeve!" Annie whimpered softly, while blushing furiously.

"The perfect anal whore, who's ass was literally made for fucking!" Maeve growled into Annie's ear, "We should be calling you Butt girl, with the power to be the perfect little anal whore. Literally. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssssss, fuck events like this, and all those stupid propaganda films. We should get you into a nice porno. Nothing too fancy, with lines and shit. No, just a nice simple anal gang bang.

But not with porn stars. No, we should just put up a sign, advertising the best piece of ass in the entire world is open for business. You'll see, men and women will be lining up for miles for the chance to fuck this big fat ass! In fact, fuck a movie. we'll give you your own reality show, filming 24/7, of nothing but Butt girl fulfilling her true purpose in life!"

"Maeve!" Annie whimpered softly, squirming as now four fingers were hammering her ass hole at super human speed.

"Yeahhhhhhhhh, that would be the most popular show in America. No, worldwide." Maeve chuckled wickedly, becoming lost in her own idea, "Of course, we'll have to workshop a name. The Adventures of Butt girl, and her Insatiable Fat Ass? Na, too wordy. Anal Annie? Too cutesy. Butt girl's Insatiable Butt? Maybe? Or maybe simply the Butt girl channel.

Hell, here's fun, we can put it right next to one of those Christian networks. That way, when the people in the crowd tonight are flicking through channels, they might stumble across your channel by accident, and recognize you. Won't that be fun? Ooooooooooh, maybe you could read a Bible verse, for every 10th guy who cums in your ass?"

"MAEVE!" Annie snapped.

"Yes, sweetie?" Maeve asked innocently.

"Please..." Annie whimpered desperately, "Fuck me!"

Beaming widely, Maeve shamelessly pushed, "Fuck you how, babe? And where? And with what, exactly? Ohhhhhhhhhhh fuck yeah, I want the pure and wholesome Starlight to tell her girlfriend exactly what she wants her to do to her, in the middle of a Capes For Christ event! Mmmmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, come on, baby. Tell me what you want."

"I, I... I want..." Annie stammered, initially too overwhelmed with embarrassment and desire to form the right words, before she took a deep and calming breath, and forced out, "Fuck me! Fuck me right here, and right now, mmmmmmmmmm, in the middle of a Capes For Christ event. Fuck my slutty little ass. Ooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, fuck it however you want.

With whatever you want. My ass is yours! All yours! Please use it, my Queen. Please, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, I'm your girl. Your Butt girl, who needs it up her Insatiable Butt! Oh my God! Mmmmmmmmmm, fuck me, oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss, please Maeve, AH FUCK! AH FUCK! Oh Shit! FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK!"

Maeve grinned widely and sadistically, as she pushed her entire fist into Annie's slutty little ass. With most people, it may not be possible to go pretty much straight from four fingers to a whole hand. And if it was, there would probably be a lot of pain involved. However, thanks to their superhuman abilities, and the fact that sweet little Starlight was a well-trained anal fuck toy, the cry she let out was pretty much of pure pleasure.

Admittedly, it stopped the little butt whore from begging, in favour of whimpering pathetically. But that just might be because she was savouring this unique experience. God knows Maeve was, given that while she had anally fisted a whore or two before, having her fist being tightly squeezed by Starlight's rectum was like, on a whole other level.

To Maeve's credit, she had pushed forwards while her girl had been telling her what she wanted. Enough to stretch Annie's ass hole wider than ever before, around her knuckles. At which point, she had intended to gently pump her hand back and forth, giving sweet Ms January a chance to get use to this new extreme. But, given she didn't have to hold back with her perfect butt slut, Maeve had just allowed her lust to get the better of her.

For a few long seconds, she regretted it, given that she had wanted to savour every second of this. However, that was fleeting, and she soon started to pump her hand back and forth, just a little bit at first, but gradually pulling out further and further, until she was causing Starlight's shit hole to stretch for her knuckles again.

Which again, should have sweet little Annie January begging for mercy, but instead she was biting down on one of her hands to prevent herself from crying out, gasping or even moaning too loudly, while being anally fisted by her childhood idol and current girlfriend. Fuck, it was so cute. Annie was always cute, but never more so than when she was getting fucked in the ass.

So much so, Maeve actually found herself tearing her eyes away from her favourite sight in the world, that of another girl's butt hole stretching for her. Especially this girl. Her favourite butt girl. The superhero that really should be called Butt girl. Especially as it was so easy to give her an assgasm.

Hell, this time it happened without Annie begging for it, like a good little anal fuck toy should. But in this case, that was forgivable, as Maeve was pushing her girl by randomly giving her a few hard thrusts. However, she got carried away, and gave her one too many, so of course Butt girl, the perfect anal whore, came. Which in turn, just pushed Maeve to brutalize that slutty little shit-pipe with everything she had, effortlessly making the ass slut cum over and over again.

In fact, the older woman almost came too, without any physical stimulation, just as the mental high of this was so incredible. Especially given how the sweet and wholesome Annie January's ass was clenching down on her fist so hard when she came, it felt like that hand would be crushed. And it would have been, if it wasn't for her own superpowers.

"Yeahhhhhhhhh, that's it, butt slut! Cum with my fist up your fucking ass!" Maeve gleefully growled into Annie's ear, as her little anal bitch started cumming for her, "Cum for me, Annie! Oh yes, mmmmmmmm, I love it when Starlight cums for me. Especially when I'm fucking her up the ass, like the nasty little anal whore she is.

Oooooooooh yessssssssss, and I love feeling your slutty little shitter quivering for me. Quivering around my cock, my fingers, ohhhhhhhhhhh, and now my whole fucking fist! God, Capes For Christ, you really are the biggest anal slut I've ever met. And I love it. Oh fuck yeah, take it, Butt girl! Fucking take my fist, take my cock, take it all! Ah fuck!"

Annie was in heaven right now. She thought becoming a real superhero, not just opposer in a pageant, would make her happy, but it didn't. She thought joining The Seven would make her happy, but oh God, it didn't. But when she came like this, all the bad things went away and there was only this heavenly moment. And no one had ever made her cum like her childhood idol, Queen Maeve. And no one ever could.

Even if they could possibly get close, because it seemed that Maeve was 100% right, and ultimately, Annie January was just an anal whore. And more importantly in this moment, her Queen's personal anal whore. Why else would she be cumming this hard and frequently?

She had spent so long trying to make herself into Starlight, the ideal version of herself, which people around the world looked up too. Hell, she had even succeeded, and was now seeing little girls dress up like her on the daily. God, she was letting them, and everybody down. Maybe especially the people here today for Capes For Christ.

They had no idea that Starlight literally had a fist up her ass right now, and was loving every second of it. So much so that she just couldn't stop cumming. Hell, for a second there, Annie thought she was going to pass out with it. Then all of a sudden, Maeve was yanking her fist out of that poor little hole, causing Annie to cry out way too loudly into her hands.

"Keep your mouth busy cleaning this, so you can spread your cheeks for me." Maeve then ordered, while bringing the hand which had just been up Starlight's ass to Starlight's mouth, and then when her girl seemed to hesitate, Maeve pushed. "Come on, girlie. We both know how much you love ass to mouth. Oooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhh, my girl loves being a whore for all things anal. Including ATM.

I guess that makes you ATM girl, as well as Butt girl, huh? Yes, it does, yes it does, ohhhhhhhhhhh yessssssssssssss! Just like that! Clean every drop, you greedy little slut! Clean it while I fuck that pretty little butt. Oh fuck yeah, then you can take it in both ends."

Once again proving just how corrupted she had become, or how twisted she always was deep down, Annie wished Maeve would stop talking about it, and just do it. Re-fill her slutty little ass with her fist, or that cock, hell, anything at this point. Sweet little Starlight just desperately wanted something shoved up her butt. God, it felt like she physically needed it in that moment.

But, she was confident that Maeve would give it to her eventually. Especially given she was currently rubbing her strap-on cock up and down Annie's butt crack. Which was almost an unbearable level of teasing, but Starlight was confident that her Queen would eventually give her what she wanted. In the meantime, she had work to do.

Namely, cleaning that hand. Starting with licking the palm, and then the back, given she was expecting a certain amount of teasing, and she would like to be sucking on one of those fingers when she was once again anally violated. However, for better or for worse, Annie was able to move between each of those fingers as well, and give them a thorough cleaning, while Maeve was busy running her mouth.

Something which would be torturous enough, under normal circumstances, but right now, she should be really ready to go on stage. Hell, they may call her any minute now, and there she was, just waiting for a cock to be shoved up her slutty little butt. For another woman to sodomize her. Oh God, this was so nasty. But she wanted it so bad.