Now both nude, he steered her to the bed, and they got in. He fingered her clitoris expertly. He was almost as good at it as she was when she touched herself. He got Nancy's juices flowing, then sneaked a finger into her vagina. There was a trace of a hymen. He whispered, "Is this your first time?" She could only manage a nod. Yes! A virgin! An honest-to-God virgin, right here in Manhattan!
Joey had harvested three confirmed cherries in high school. Since high school, the availability of virgins dropped every year. Joey had had only one confirmed victory since school. Finding a girl this hot, at this age, with an intact hymen was like finding two unicorns. Joey eagerly wanted to make this moment specialβfor him. He would forego the condom, since Nancy was certainly disease-free.
Joey would, however, avail himself of lubrication. He wanted her to be comfortable, because all that crying was an annoyance at what should be a triumphal momentβfor him. He lubricated his cock, got down to her legs, raised her knees up, and spread them. Now, he needed get the job done in one swift motion, so she couldn't escape.
Joey climbed over her, and put his hands at her sides to support his torso. He quickly placed the tip of his penis at her vaginal opening, and pushed the head in. He was so excited that he struggled to go slowly. He pushed into her. He didn't feel her hymen. She did not object. He had her. He moaned in pleasure at the sensation. She was so warm and soft and tight inside!
Nancy whimpered, but not too loudly. He moaned louder, and landed his groin against hers, in to the hilt. He groaned as he pulled out an inch or so, and re-inserted. The feeling was incredible! He thrust his hips, driving his cock like a piston in a warm, squishy cylinder. He came, pumping in longer strokes and shouting, "Yeah! Yeah! Ugh! Ugh! Ugh!" He bathed her pussy in a generous serving of sperm. He continued to thrust after he came.
Nancy was crying now, but he refused to stop. He had to come again. He stroked in and out, grunting and breathing hard, ignoring Nancy entirely. He was only interested in the hold her vagina had on his schlong. It was magical. After several minutes of pumping, he came again. He threw his head back, grimaced, and pushed his cock as deep as it would go. He fired a few more spurts of seed into her womb.
Joey got out of bed, and walked around the room. He was exultant, triumphant, victorious. However, he knew that if he showed those true feelings, he would never have Nancy again. She was shedding tears, but not vocally crying. Not bad. She covered herself with the sheet. Joey asked, "Are you all right, Nancy?" She did not answer. "Nancy, are you hurt?" She shook her head.
"Do you want me to bring you a beer? It might make you feel better." She nodded weakly. He left, and returned seconds later with beer, which he opened and handed to her. She was bashful about her nudity and his. He put on his pants, saying, "Why don't you get up, and get dressed, and we'll go out in the living room?"
Nancy moved tentatively to the edge of the bed, bringing the sheet with her. She said, "Could you leave?" He did, and she got dressed in private. She emerged from the bedroom looking like hell. Joey was now wearing pants and a shirt, and digging for something to eat in the refrigerator. Nancy picked up her bag and said, "I think I want to go home." Music to Joey's ears.
He said, "Thanks for a great day, Nancy. Bye, bye." He kissed her on the cheek, and closed the door behind her. Now, he danced a jig and clapped his hands in celebration. Nancy was his fifth confirmed virgin. He was an ace! Wait 'til Chandler hears about this!
Chandler was not happy for Joey, "Godammit, Joey, she was a nice girl, and you took advantage of her!"
Joey was surprised by Chandler's reaction, "No, I did not! She consented, she wanted it, she knew what she was doing."
"I don't doubt that, Joey, but just because you can do something doesn't mean you should do something. How do you think Nancy feels about it, now?"
Joey pointed at Chandler, "You would have done it, too, Chandler. Admit it. I let her make her own decision. I didn't talk her into anything. She was ready. It was her choice. I was her choice."