Cindy began cry, and said, "I'm so sorry, Rachel and Ross. I don't know what to say."
Ross, said, soothingly, "It's all right, Cindy. I'll tell you what, why don't we finish dinner? After, if you like, we all go to my place, and just sit around talking. Nothing more. Would that make you more comfortable?"
Cindy blew her nose into a tissue, "Oh, Ross, you are such a sweetheart. That would be good." The remainder of the meal was easier. Cindy settled down. Rachel and Cindy debated whether to indulge in dessert.
Ross said, "Why don't you each pick something to go? You can have it tonight or tomorrow." The girls agreed, and they set off for Ross's apartment in good spirits.
As Rachel showed her around, Cindy raved, "You have an amazing place, Ross! And it's so well decorated. Did you help him decorate, Rachel?"
Rachel admitted, "No, no, I'm no decorator. Ross did this himself. He has excellent taste." Ross arrived with wine. Rachel and Ross sat, with Rachel leaning heavily on Ross. Cindy sat on the other sofa. Cindy drank almost a full glass of wine right away. Rachel cautioned, "Cindy, take it easy. Tell us how you are feeling, and what you're thinking."
Cindy began to tear up, and Rachel set a box of tissue on the coffee table in front of her. Cindy said, "I know I talk a good game, but I'm not as slutty as I say I am. I don't let guys take advantage of me. I am proud to say that, at least. I've never done a threesome, Rachel."
Rachel said, "Well, that's all right, Cindy. You can be selective if you want. That's a good thing, in this day and age. I'm not bi, anyway, Cindy, so it doesn't need to be a threesome."
Ross offered, "Cindy, let's just talk this out, okay? Rachel and I respect your choices, Cindy. We haven't been playing the field, and certainly not when it comes to group sex. That's normal for us, so don't be embarrassed if you live that way, too."
Cindy sniffled, "Oh, Ross, Rachel is so lucky to have you." Rachel smiled and kissed Ross on the cheek. "I wish I could find a guy like you."
Rachel said, "Ross is a great guy, but he's not the only one. Do you know when I started my relationship with Ross? It was after I decided I wanted a real man, a man I could count on, a man brave enough to be sensitive, and a man who wanted a life partner." Ross pursed his lips, and leaned his head against Rachel's.
Cindy was touched, "So sweet! Why would you share him?"
Rachel looked to Ross, he nodded, and she explained, "Well, frankly, Ross was married for years, so I have more experience romantically than he. I think he needs to sow some wild oats, or else he'll be jealous, or wonder if he should have played the field more before settling down. It's that simple. Sharing him is not going to be our lifestyle."
Cindy sat up straight, "Guys, let's do this. Can I have more wine, please?" Ross and Rachel looked at one another again. Cindy was not noticeably drunk yet, so they shrugged. Ross rose, filled her wine glass halfway, and sat down next to her.
Ross asked, "May I touch you, Cindy?"
She said, firmly, "Yes." He reached across her, placed his hand on the space between her breasts, and slid his hand over her breast, under her clothing. She turned her face to his, and he kissed her on the cheek. He rolled her breast around. He couldn't get his large hand completely around it.
Cindy was built unlike any woman Ross had ever been with, which is why Rachel selected her for this event. Cindy purred, and Ross moved her dress aside to expose first one breast, and then the other. She was responsive, so Rachel said, softly, "Let's move this into the bedroom. I'll get the wine."
Rachel picked up their glasses, and carried them to the bedroom, following Cindy and Ross. Rachel set down the wine, and lit some candles, while Cindy and Ross sat on the bed. He tried to unclasp her dress behind her neck, but had difficulty. Cindy and Ross both laughed. He figured it out, and her dress dropped to her waist.
Cindy's breasts were bounteous and beautifully shaped. Ross noted that they were perfectly symmetrical, which was a particular fetish of his. Ross was highly motivated to have this woman, and he would do almost anything to make that happen. He stood, and took Cindy's hand as she stood. Ross stripped while Cindy wriggled out of her dress and removed her shoes and hose.
When Ross dropped his pants and shorts, his cock sprung out of its confinement. It looked as if it should be accompanied by a comical "boingggg!" sound, and all three smiled at the sight. Cindy couldn't take her eyes off it, and impulsively reached for her wine glass and drank it all down. Rachel and Ross exchanged glances. Rachel reassured Cindy, "Ross is very gentle, Cindy, and we have lubricant, plus the condom. It will be nice, I promise. Why don't you get into bed, dear?"
Cindy tentatively climbed onto the bed, and sat at its center, her legs extended to her side and her torso propped up on her arm. She looked sexy. Rachel produced a condom. She and Ross had never used one together. Rachel was accustomed to putting on condoms with her mouth alone. Performing this trick, however, would remind Ross that she had more numerous lovers, all of whom needed to be separated from her by a layer of latex.
Rachel turned to Cindy, "Do you know how to put on a condom with just your mouth?" Much to Rachel's relief, Cindy nodded. Rachel's special talent would remain her secret. Cindy reached out for the condom and scooted to the edge of the bed, in front of Ross. Cindy opened the condom, took it out, placed it carefully on the tip of Ross's penis, and puckered up.
Cindy applied her pucker to the condom, pinched her lips tightly, and moved her head forward slowly. The condom unrolled, propelled by her lips. Ross had heard of this technique, but had never experienced it. He watched Cindy work with intense pleasure. As the condom wound down on his long cock, Cindy's lips lost their purchase. A couple of times, she had to pull back a little and reset her lips.
After the condom was on, Cindy backed away, and lay on her back, down the center of the bed. She arranged a pillow under her head. By silent agreement, Ross and Cindy would start out in the missionary position. This would relieve Cindy of responsibility for handling Ross's cock. Rachel swiped lubricant on Ross. Oil dripped down the condom and over his balls.
Ross lay on the bed beside Cindy. Rachel handed Ross the lube, and he applied some to Cindy's slit. He jiggled her clitoris, which caused her eyes to roll up into her head. She moaned, and gripped the sheets hard in her fists. Ross alternated between her clitoris and her vagina. When he thought she was ready, he returned the lube to Rachel.
Ross climbed between Cindy's legs, smiling greedily. He had rarely been as turned on as he was with this enticingly tentative and bountiful woman. Ross placed the tip of his cock carefully, and entered her. She gasped. He struggled to be patient. He slid into her in a few long strokes. She made anguished sounds, but did not cry out. He remained buried inside her for a few moments, allowing her time to adjust to his size. He watched her face. She relaxed a bit, nodded, and said, breathlessly, "Okay."
Ross was already near climax. He pulled out a couple of inches and slid it back in. Cindy's face, and the sounds she made, told him that she was uncomfortable. He could no longer restrain himself. He pumped his cock in and out of her, with a travel of several inches on each stroke. She groaned at moderate volume. He vocalized, "Ah! Ah! Ah! AH! AH!! AH!!!" Ultimately, he grimaced fiercely and filled the condom to overflowing.
Ross imagined that his cum squeezed out around his cock, and formed a thin ring around the junction of his cock and her vaginal entrance. He delivered many strokes after he finished coming. He was tempted to continue fucking her. Instead, he pulled his cock out, rose up on his knees, and noticed that he was wearing a condom. He had completely forgotten the condom. The condom was full of semen. Some juice leaked out by the rim, much as he had pictured it doing in her vagina.
Ross clamped his hand around the base of his cock to hold the juice inside the condom. He scrambled off the bed. Rachel pulled a sheet over Cindy's nude form. Rachel then pulled the condom off of Ross, using her fingers like a squeegee to contain all the semen inside. She handed Ross a few wet wipes. While he wiped his cock clean, she tied a knot in the condom and dropped it into the wastebasket.
Rachel and Ross turned their attention to Cindy. She was sitting up, holding the sheet over her breasts, and smiling. Rachel passed Cindy a glass of wine, and asked, "How are you, honey?"