I didn't respond as my fingers probed deeper. I'd fingered myself countless times before, but it felt totally different on her. She blinked, waiting for my response. Her green eyes so close to mine. Green eyes. Green like Cole's. And as that thought washed over me, her words pushed themselves through my foggy brain. Suddenly the haze was gone and everything was crystal clear. The implication of what we were doing hit me like a ton of bricks. I pulled my fingers out of her soft, wet cunt, the digits glistening with arousal. I pushed her off of me, sitting up on the bed, panic setting in.
"N-n-n-o-o-o. I'm sorry!" I stammered out. "I can't! I'm sorry Hayley! I just can't do this! I'm not. I like. I'm not a."
The pop-punk starlet looked confused and stunned as I grabbed the towel from off the floor and ran out of my own room. Barely covering myself, I darted into hallway and opened the door to the nearest room. My heart was pounding, I closed the door to the guest room with a snap. My feelings were a confused mess, swirling around like a tornado. What had I just done? What did it mean?
"Jeez! Knock next time!" Cole said, hurriedly trying to cover his own nakedness. "Oh, Swift. It's you."
I'd forgotten he was staying in this particularly room. As I stared up and down his body, my gaze lingered at his poorly concealed crotch, hidden by both hands. I could see the tip of his cock hanging down behind them and his heavy balls drooping behind that. And then suddenly, I needed him. Maybe more than I had ever needed him before. Right here. Right now. I let the towel drop and stepped forward, naked, hair still a tangled mess of wet ropes, mascara like a raccoon. His eyes grew wide, easily visible even in the semi-darkness. I quickly closed the distance between us, pulling him for a kiss, tasting the chlorine on his lips. My hand reached down the hardening crotch, pushing his hands aside and grasping the swelling member.
"I want you Cole. I want this dick. Right now." He stammered something inaudible. "It's my birthday. You aren't going to deny the birthday girl her present, are you?"
I didn't give him a chance to respond, taking my fingers and placing them in his open mouth. Those same fingers that had been inside Hayley only moments before. Closing his mouth, he sucked them clean as I pulled them out and sank down onto my knees. His dick already stiff, the familiar member throbbed as I blew hot air across it. Taking him between my lips, I sucked him down, tasting chlorine yet again.
"Ohhh, Swift." He moaned, throwing his head back as I took him even deeper into my mouth.
One hand found his dangling balls, rolling those juicy cum-filled orbs around the palm of my hand as his cock grew. Precum leaked out onto my tongue as I squeezed him tight with my lips. It tasted delicious, exactly what I needed right now. The primal lust took over and I knew nothing would stop me until I got what I wanted from those heavy, swinging balls and that thick, fat dick. Fondling his nutsack, I could practically feel a sticky, hot concoction of cum brewing. Letting out an uncontrollable groan at the thought, I released his slick member. Pulling it skywards, I lowered my mouth to gobble at his testicles, chowing down and drenching each of them in copious amounts of saliva. Sucking, slurping and licking at them, I simply could not get enough. Taking my tongue, I ran it along the veiny underbelly. Beginning at the base and leaving a trail of wet spittle all the way to the tip, I wrapped my lips around his crown and swallowed him back down. His many inches disappeared as I felt his cockhead press against my throat and still I forced more down. Relaxing my gag reflex, I fit the last few inches in. Throat bulging, nose pressed against his well-maintained pubic area, I gazed up at him. He looked down back at me, his bright green eyes unfocused as if in a daze as if I had sucked the very sense out of him. The same color as Hayley's. I hesitated, opening wide and dislodging him from my gullet, several long strands of sticky saliva still connecting me to the shaft. I threw the image of her out of my head, focusing on the fleshy rod in front of me.
"I love cock." I said before running my lips and tongue along the side of his thick, pulsing member. "I love this cock. Mmmmmhhhhhmm." Kissing with plump lips, my tongue curled around the underside of the girthy shaft. Sliding them from base to tip, I did the same to the other side. "Can't. Get. Enough." I said, peppering every inch with kisses from my puckered lips, speaking a word between kisses. "So. Fucking. Good. I. Need. It."
I had him groaning, moaning and trembling. Putty in my hand. The image of Hayley's shirtless body and her perky hanging tits looming above me flashed before me. I banished it and gave the tip of his cock one final kiss. Standing up, I fell back onto the bed. He bent down, his skilled mouth heading for right between my legs, but I pulled him up. I couldn't wait any longer. I needed him inside of me right now.
"No. Just put in. Get that dick inside me!"
I shuffled further back on the bed as he clambered on top of me. Our lips met, kissing deeply and for a moment it felt like Hayley's lips on mine, our tongues twisting and curling in each other's mouths. I grabbed his head and kissed him harder as his dick slapped against my wet labia. He pushed inside with ease, sliding inch after inch into me. It felt like nothing else in the world. No tongue, fingers, dildos or vibrators could compare to the feeling of a big, stiff cock filling up my twat. I cried out until he came to rest, his balls nestled snuggly against my taint. Our lips clashed as he began thrusting. I wrapped my legs around his waist, feet dangling in the air as I dug my nails into his back. I gripped him in a tight embrace as he penetrated me over and over and over again. Each hard thrust was accompanied by a satisfactory grunt. He buried his face in the crook of my neck, kissing and sucking the flesh as he humped away. Just like Hayley had done. My eyes flew open and I pushed him off.
"What Swift?" He asked. "What's wrong?"
"Ride you. I want to ride you." I said breathlessly.
He laid on his back and I gave his cock one or two quick strokes, squeezing it between my fingers, before straddling him and sinking down on his meaty fuckstick. Moaning his name as he filled me up, his cockhead came to rest right against my g-spot. Slowly I gyrated my hips, staring down at him. He placed on a hand on either side of my hips, big, strong, warm. Nothing like Hayley's. At least, that's what I told myself as I began to bounce up and down on his lap. I placed one hand, splayed on his muscular chest as I rode him. He gripped me tight, thrusting upwards to meet me as together we clapped our genitals. Together the two of us found the perfect rhythm almost instantly despite our infrequent hookups. As I rode harder, I could already feel my orgasm building, my snatch constricting tighter around the fat schlong splitting it.
"Swift! Oh, Swift!" He groaned.
"Keep it up. Just like that. Oh fuck yes! Cole! COLE!" I cried out. Each repeated impaling brought me closer to climax. "I'm gonna cum. That's it. YES! I'm gonna cream all over this fat dick! AHHHHH!!"
"Cum for me Swift. Cum riding this cock. Do it!" He growled.
My voice grew higher and higher in pitch as I felt the warmth blossoming in my nether regions, the pressure building with every passing millisecond. I couldn't breathe. I couldn't think. I could only feel him inside of me. He gave a particularly powerful jab and roared. That set me off.
"C-C-C-CUMMING!!" I screamed to the ceiling, throwing my head back as I dug all ten fingernails even deeper into his chest.
Wet hair slapped against my back as I thrusted my chest out. Entire body shaking, his member throbbed wildly as my twat grabbed hold and refused to let go. My mind was a blank space. Blissful. Peaceful. Tingling goodness rang through every fiber of my being as the orgasm wash over me. I smiled. Cole slowed his thrusts, still harder than a rock inside of me. I slipped off of him and flopped onto the bed, all my troubles gone for the moment.
"You good Swift?"
I opened my eyes. He was staring at me, trying not to look too eager as he fingered his stiff prick. I didn't say a word, spreading my legs wide and lifting them high into the air. He grinned and scooted over into position, sinking back into my pussy as I rested a leg on each of his broad shoulders. Pounding away, his movements were hard and fast.
"SHIT!" I yelled, his steel ramrod hitting deeper than I expected. "God! I fucking love this DICK!"
He laughed and fucked me harder, hands sliding along my smooth legs, lips kissing the toned calf as it bounced on his shoulder. My painted toes curled behind his head as with every thrust, he seemed another inch or two deeper.
"How do you like your present?" He asked between thrusts. "Is it exactly what you wanted?"