When it was clear Dawnie was enjoying this, both from her treacherous body and the fact that she wasn't begging for mercy anymore, I increased the force of the spanking ever so slightly. Not by much, not at the expense of using my full Slayer strength, but it was enough for me to get a few bangs on the wall from the bums living next door to me. Or maybe they just had a problem with little D squealing so loud. Either way I kept spanking her cute little ass until my hand got tired and I worked up a bit of a sweat, both really impressive considering I'm a Slayer, then I pushed Dawnie down so she was laying on my bed on her stomach, the little pipsqueak sobbing into my sheets as she unwittingly wiggled her sexy little ass at me.
I licked my lips and murmured, "It's butt fuckin' time."
Not sure if Dawnie heard me or not but she didn't make a fuss so I concentrated on getting a strap-on from my toy collection and pulling it up my thighs. It was my 8 incher again. Sure, I considered upping the size, but after the butt beating the other brunette just took this was going to hurt enough, and there's a fine line between trying to scare a girl off and literally making sure she never sat down again. Although she probably wouldn't be sitting right for a while, I thought with an evil grin as I tightened the straps and then covered the dildo in lube.
Once my toy was firmly in place I began to advance, staring at that cute little butt like a missile locked onto it's target. Like that missile I wanted to destroy my target, ram my dick in Dawnie's butt hole and ruin it forever. But again, fine line. So instead I crouched down behind her, sitting on her legs so she couldn't squirm away, then I pressed a finger against the bottom of her spine, slid it downwards into her ass crack until it was resting against her cute little rosebud and slowly pushed forwards.
At exactly the same time D and I groaned loudly in mostly pleasure as my well-oiled finger slips inside her back hole, leading me to grin wickedly and tell her, "Damn Dawnie, ya tightened up real nice since last night. Figured after the poundin' I gave ya you'd be loose as fuck, instead you're practically cherry again. Mmmmmm, it's like this cute little butt of yours was made for fuckin'."
Dawnie let out a nervous whimper as I finished burying my finger into the knuckle inside her butt, then she began moaning softly as I began pumping that finger in and out of that tight little hole. She moaned even more when I added a second and then a third finger into her bottom while I continue to be amazed by the tightness of her cute little ass. Sure, I had been mostly teasing her a second ago, but she really had tightened up nicely. If I didn't know any better I may think she was cherry back here, and if I didn't think before I definitely knew innocent little Dawn Summers was made to be butt fucked.
Speaking of which, I was aching to get my strap-on inside this wonderfully tight hole, however just as I was about to remove my fingers I got a wicked idea which would probably help with the pushing her away, and would definitely make butt pounding her easier. So instead of taking away I added, pushing a fourth finger into Dawnie's butt hole and causing the little pipsqueak to cry out in a mixture pain and pleasure, reaching out and grabbing onto the sheet in front of her as she forced herself to relax.
That made me rethink my new plan for a second, but I just shrugged and thought 'fuck it' I'm fisting this bitch. I almost just rammed the rest of my hand into Dawn's butt just to see her reaction, but instead I reached over to grab the lube I brought with me just in case, squirting it over my thumb and the front and back of my palm just like I did my third finger before I added it into the mix. And then returned the anal fingering for a minute or two to make sure she was nice and relaxed, then I slowly eased my thumb into her, making Dawnie tremble as she struggled to adjust to having so much stretching her ass hole.
She then got even more. She cried softly as I added my thumb and squealed like a little bitch as I firmly shoved the rest of my hand inside her. To be fair I went nice and slow. I could have just stuffed her ass no problem with my Slayer strength, but again, fine line. Besides, it was so fucking hot watching her ass hole slowly stretching wide enough to allow my knuckles to slip past that tight anal ring, Dawnie's squeals music to my ears as my fist slipped the rest of the way in.
Once her anal ring closed around my wrist I gave her a few long seconds to relax, during which she whimpered, "Faith... what, what the hell was that?"
"Just a little something to stretch ya out. Don't worry about it." I reassured her, gently rubbing her back to relax her, "Just concentrate on giving me that cute little ass of yours. Mmmmmm yeahhhhhh, that's it. Relax and give me that ass!"
To my delight Dawnie did as she was told, burying her face in the bed sheets and gripping onto them tightly as her little butt hole desperately tried to relax. Which was easier said than done when someone shoves a fist up your ass for the first time. Or at least I imagine it would be. A lot of my former conquests seemed to struggle, but in the next few minutes I could have mistaken Dawnie for a pro if her ass wasn't so tight.
Again proving I'm not a total bitch I started nice and slow, just short little jabs inside Dawnie's butt hole, making the little squirt squirm with every little movement. Shortly after that she started to moan in a mixture of pleasure and pain, and then only pleasure, leading me to increase the force. The result was the same, Dawnie clearly loving it, not just from her moans but from the way that she pushed herself against me, compelling her own obscenely stretched back passage on my fist.
Then she actually lifted her head out of the bed sheets and cried out, "Oh Faith, mmmmmmmm aaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh fuck, give me more! Fuck my ass! Fuck it hard, OH GOD! OOOOOOOH GOOOOOODDDDDD AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!"
Not wanting to disappoint the little brat I rammed harder, treating her butt like it was a vamp's face. Except obviously I was punching Dawn's insides, and little pipsqueak was enjoying it a hell of a lot more than the ugly fuckers I dusted. Even when I start pulling my hand back enough so that D's butt hole began stretching for my palm, and those squeals of pleasure were nothing compared to Dawnie's reaction when I pulled back far enough that her back hole was stretching around my knuckles, a.k.a. the widest Dawn Summers' forbidden hole had ever been stretched.
That resulted in Dawn jumping up onto her hands and knees and starting to push back against me, the two of us quickly working up a rhythm until I could tell she was ready to cum. As her wet little pussy was literally went there for the taking a carefully balanced myself on my knees and then started frantically rubbing her cunt, making sure I got her clit with every single rub. She came nearly on the spot, sadistic joy filling me as I made the little squirt squirt, her entire body seeming to spasm especially her ass hole which nearly crashing my hand from the force of her orgasm. It was fucking awesome.
After, I don't know, maybe half a dozen orgasms for little D I start getting jealous. After all, why should she have all the fun? So in one swift movement I pulled my fist out of her ass and replaced it with my strap-on. That really made her squeal. Mostly because well my dick wasn't quite as wide it was a hell of a lot longer than my hand, and I might have got carried away and used my Slayer strength to shove most of the toy inside her. Oh well, soon as I started pumping away at her tight little ass she soon forgot about any discomfort. Although she did continue squealing until she didn't have any voice left and could only whimper softly.
Given that her reactions were positive I was nowhere near as gentle as I was last night with her, pounding that cute little ass of hers nice and hard right from the get go. Ok, I mostly concentrated on the area loosened by my fist, and I didn't get my dildo all the way into her, but again there's a fine line, and Dawnie's ass is way too fuck-able to literally ruin. Although I gave it a decent shot once I slowly reintroduced the rest of my cock to her back passage and my thighs began smacking off her already bruised butt cheeks nice and loudly, signifying that the real butt pounding could begin.
As I began to really give it to her I grabbed her hair and told her, "Take it! Take it! Fucking take it! Mmmmmmmm, take it you little bitch, ohhhhhhhhh, take it! Take it in your tight lil ass like the whore you are! Ohhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhh, you're my whore now Dawnie! My little anal whore! My butt slut! My bitch! Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhh, you're my bitch Dawnie. What are you?"
"YOUR BITCH! I'M YOUR BITCH!" Dawnie screamed, "I'M YOUR BITCH, YOUR ANAL WHORE, YOUR BUTT SLUT, AAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOODDDDDDDD FAITH, I'M YOURS! ALL YOURS!"
With that I picked it up a notch, slamming her cute little shitter with almost every ounce of my Slayer strength. Which was probably too much for her human ass, but to Dawnie's credit she took it like a little bitch that she was and once again came with a dick in her ass like a total anal whore. Which in turn made me keep up the brutal pace while grinning, laughing and smacking that bruised butt, you know, just generally loving life and the joy that fucking a bottom's bottom could give me.
