An Unexpected Surprise 18

Starring Natalie Portman and Scarlett Johansson

Codes: MF, M+F, orgy, FF, oral, facial

Disclaimer: This is entirely a work of fiction and is not meant to reflect reality in any way. This is a product of imagination and is NOT real. All characters are 18 and is not meant to be read by anyone under the age of 18.

"Do you trust me?" Natalie Portman asked, a big, excited smile on her face.

"Of course I do," Scarlett Johansson replied, before adding a, "But..."

"But nothing," Natalie interrupted. "Put this on and I promise that it's going to be worth it! Please!"

Scarlett didn't fight it off anymore. She knew it was a losing battle because she didn't want to deny Natalie this. Plus she was honestly curious about where all of this was leading. This was an unaccustomed position for her and she kind of liked that. But she wasn't sure about going into this blind...literally.

Still Natalie was her girlfriend and Scarlett trusted her completely. There was no one she would have done this for but her. So she nodded her head and assented to what her lover had planned. That got a little giggle from Natalie and she tied the blindfold around Scarlett's eyes, blocking her field of vision.

"Okay, but you'd better not be about to walk me into a wall," Scarlett teased.

"Would I do that to you?" Natalie laughed in a playful, teasing way. "I promise you're going to enjoy this. It's something special. Something you'd never, ever expect."

Scarlett had to admit that had her extremely intrigued. Natalie had been hyping this up as a surprise she would never have thought of and Scarlett's mind was whirling with possibilities. She had never been in this kind of a position with Natalie before. Usually it was the other way around. She was always the one planning sexy surprises for Natalie and Scarlett's curiosity was growing by the second as she tried to figure out just what it was that her girlfriend had done here.

"What are you planning Nat?" Scarlett asked. "Come on! Give me a little hint! Please?"

"Nah uh," Natalie insisted. "I want you to be totally, completely surprised. I want you to be shocked. I want you to see there's things your Natalie is capable of that not even you are."

That only made Scarlett more curious. As each mysterious second ticked away, Scarlett's desire to know what it was that Natalie was planning for her got more and more intense. What could Natalie be talking about? What surprise could she possibly have put together? Whatever it was, Scarlett knew it would be good and she certainly knew it would be a sexy one considering how they were dressed.

When Natalie had told her to come over and to bring something naughty to wear, Scarlett hadn't thought twice. She always came running whenever Natalie called and if she told her to bring something sexy to wear, so much the better. So Scarlett had come over with a teddy ready to slip on once she'd gotten her clothes off and she didn't think it was boastful at all for her to think that she looked extremely fucking hot in it.

Scarlett was in a Victoria's Secret plunge teddy that she already knew Natalie loved to see her in. It showed off her curves in such a delectable way and Scarlett loved the way it could literally make her girlfriend drool for her. The teddy clung to her shoulders in such a way that it was so easy to imagine just tantalizingly easing each strap off and sliding it down her body to get her naked. It was cut low to show off the abundant cleavage that Scarlett had to offer and Scarlett especially loved the way it made her look from behind.

There was only a small strand of fabric that slid between her ass cheeks. It basically left her butt bare with only that tiny little bit of cover and Scarlett knew Natalie loved that. She knew her girlfriend went gaga over her big tits and thick ass and that Natalie loved to stare at her when she bared her body to her in such provocative lingerie. She had picked this one out on purpose today because she knew Natalie loved it and it was certainly having the desired effect as Natalie hadn't been able to keep her eyes, or her hands, off of Scarlett after she had slipped it on.

And she wasn't the only one who was dressed in a very intimate way. When Scarlett had changed into her lingerie, Natalie had too and she looked so good that part of Scarlett had almost wanted to forget what the surprise was and instead focus entirely on her girlfriend's beautiful body.

Natalie was also in a teddy, one made of black lace that hugged her tight little body, teasingly showing off her round, perky tits in a way that didn't reveal too much and yet made her look so sexual. It was a lovely, tantalizing black lace teddy that no one ever would have expected to see someone like Natalie Portman in. It was both modest and revealing at the same time as it hefted up her beautiful breasts and clung to the cheeks of her ass with the black lace contrasting so nicely with her pink skin.

But as much as the sight of Natalie in such erotic lingerie turned her on, Scarlett was dying to know what it was that Natalie had planned for her. Natalie had never surprised her like this before and Scarlett was racking her brain to try and figure out what it was. She couldn't come up with the solution though and that was exciting her even more.

Not only was she blindfolded and in her most provocative underwear, but Scarlett truly had no idea what was waiting for her. She was going into this situation in a far more vulnerable position than she was used to. She had no idea what was waiting for her and that was not only mysterious, it was also a little dangerous too.

If anyone but Natalie had arranged this, Scarlett would have been more hesitant but her trust for Natalie was too strong for her to have serious doubts. So she let Natalie guide her out of the bedroom where they had changed and Scarlett's curiosity grew as she realized they were leaving the room.

She had assumed they were going to end up in the bed like always but Natalie clearly had different plans.

"Where are we going?" Scarlett asked, taking slow steps in her blindfolded state as Natalie held her hand and guided her. And at least Natalie gave her an answer to that.

"Guest bedroom," Natalie replied, which intrigued Scarlett even more since they never used that room. It had always been for friends or family. Whenever they had anyone over for a threesome or a foursome (or even sometimes for a more-some) they used Natalie's bedroom. The guest bedroom was for the people who stayed over that they weren't fucking.

Whatever this was, it was something different and Scarlett could not imagine what it could possibly be.

As she guided Scarlett by the hand, Natalie turned her head around and smiled when she saw the confusion all over her lover's face. She loved seeing that. She loved being the one to spring the surprise this time and she couldn't wait to see the shock in Scarlett's eyes when she found out what she had planned.

Natalie couldn't even believe she was doing this and she knew it would floor Scarlett when she realized what was happening. Natalie was so excited. This was so bold and so crazy and so fucking naughty and so definitely not her. This wasn't how she usually acted. This wasn't something she had ever done. But that was what was so much fun about this. She wasn't only surprising Scarlett, she was stretching her own boundaries and doing things she would have been too afraid to try before.

It was always Scarlett who was giving her sexy surprises. It had been Scarlett who had gotten Kat Dennings to shock her with a kiss and have it lead to an amazing threesome between them, something that had been repeated and expanded upon many times after. It had been Scarlett who had gotten Mila Kunis to come over one night to allow for her and Natalie to finally make good on their wicked Black Swan fantasies for real after they had been both too focused on the challenges of their characters to actually go all the way when they had been shooting.

It had been Scarlett who had surprised Natalie with Daisy Ridley and created the kind of Star Wars fantasy play that would have caused nerds all over the world to explode in their pants. And it had most certainly been Scarlett who had pushed Natalie into making good on her most secret fantasy and indulging in the white hot and, in Natalie's view, shameful lust she'd had for Kim Kardashian.

Scarlett had always been pushing her to open up her sexuality and be bolder and let herself go and have more fun. That had never been easy for Natalie but it letting go of her fears and her inhibitions had always been her favorite thing about having sex with women. It had always been what she had loved most about going to the mansion and forgetting about everything else except how good it felt to fuck and be fucked. And when she was with Scarlett, Natalie especially loved to let go and be wild and kinky because Scarlett made her feel so safe, like she never had to be guarded around her and she could tell her anything.

The fact that it was Scarlett who was always trying to get Natalie to loosen up and push the envelope a bit more was the main reason Natalie was even doing this. She had wanted to turn the tables for once and show to Scarlett that she wasn't the only one who had a kinky imagination and that she wasn't the only one who could plan a sexy surprise.

Natalie didn't just want to surprise Scarlett. She wanted to shock her. She wanted Scarlett to see a side of her that she never had seen before. Natalie wanted Scarlett to see that she was capable of so much more than she had ever imagined her girlfriend could be and Natalie also wanted to prove that to herself. This wasn't just going to be something for Scarlett's benefit. Natalie also planned to get everything she wanted out of this and more.

"Right this way, come on," Natalie guided her lover, the two of them clad in their sexy lingerie as Natalie felt her heart beat in her own chest over how crazy this was and how she couldn't believe she was actually going to go through with this.

This was insane. It was completely fucking nuts. But she wanted that. She wanted to do the unexpected. She wanted to be bold. She wanted to be wild. She wanted to show off a side that Scarlett didn't know she had. Natalie wanted to go beyond all of their limits and have a crazy, wildly erotic night that defied all expectations. It was only going to be one night. She was sure of that. So this was no time to be hesitant or shy. Natalie reminded herself of that as she walked them both right into the guest bedroom.

And when she saw what was waiting for them, Natalie let out a little gasp of excitement. She couldn't believe it. She was actually doing this. This was actually going to happen. She'd known they were going to be here of course. She was the one who had arranged all of this after all. But it was still shocking to actually see this and Natalie's gasp was followed by a moan of anticipation, which only made Scarlett's curiosity grow.

"What? What's going on? Come on! You HAVE to tell me!" Scarlett insisted. "I'm going to take this off!"

Scarlett began reaching for the blindfold but before she could, Natalie stopped her.

"No! Don't you dare! Not yet!" Natalie insisted, playfully but purposefully smacking Scarlett's hands back into place. "Just sit on the bed! Let this happen! You might freak out a bit but I promise you're absolutely going to love it! I know this is what you want!"

Scarlett wasn't sure what Natalie was getting at. This was getting more and more mysterious and her curiosity was growing to an almost intolerable level. Still she didn't protest. She just let Natalie guide her to the bed and she sat herself down, the blindfold still covering her eyes. She was about to ask another question though before Natalie silenced her by kissing her.

The blindfold was a good one and Scarlett couldn't see very well out of it at all so in theory it could have been anyone kissing her but Scarlett certainly would have recognized Natalie's kiss anywhere at any time. Natalie kissed her so sensually and with such a tender heat that Scarlett immediately responded and began kissing her back while letting Natalie's soft hands roam all over her barely covered body in her lingerie.

Scarlett had begun to assume there was another woman waiting for them in the guest bedroom. Why else would Natalie have brought her here in her blindfold? But who could it be? Scarlett's mind whirled with possibilities but no clues had been offered and Scarlett couldn't even begin to offer an educated guess. All she knew was that it was Natalie who was kissing her and caressing her and making her feel more and more aroused by the moment.

And by the time Natalie pulled away from her lips, Scarlett felt like her pussy was going to soak right through her lingerie.

"Are you ready?" Natalie asked, more than a hint of nervousness in her voice.

"Oh yes!" Scarlett immediately replied. "More than ready! Please tell me Nat! I'm dying to know!"

"Okay, promise you won't freak out?" Natalie asked which drove Scarlett even more insane with curiosity. What could it possibly be that was making Natalie act this way? This wasn't how she usually was at all and Scarlett was filled with so many questions.

"Yes, I promise!" Scarlett said even though she internally reserved the right to change her mind. She had no idea what was happening here and the more she had to wait the more the curiosity was raging inside her.

"Okay, here we go..." Natalie said softly as she pulled off Scarlett's blindfold.

Scarlett blinked her eyes a few times to get used to the light of the guest bedroom but as soon as she saw who was there with them she gasped loudly. She suddenly saw why Natalie had been so coy about this and why she was nervous too. Of all of the possibilities that she had just entertained, this hadn't even been close to one she had considered and she couldn't believe her own eyes as she stared at what was waiting for her.

"Remember, you promised not to freak out," Natalie reminded her but Scarlett was too shocked to remember what she had just said seconds before.

"Natalie? What? How? Why?" Scarlett sputtered out, with the "why" being the key question before her.

Scarlett had assumed there would be a beautiful, sensual woman waiting for her here. But it very much was not a woman. Instead it was men. Not a man. Men. Multiple. Scarlett couldn't believe it and ended up blinking rapidly as if this was somehow a dream she was having. One man. Two men. Three men. Four! Four men in Natalie's guest bedroom and Scarlett was so shocked about this that she almost didn't even fully appreciate at first that all of the men were completely naked.

But soon that changed and Scarlett found herself staring in amazement at the four nude men she was suddenly seeing.

Scarlett found herself gawking at the four naked cocks and these were not normal size either. These men were hung like fucking horses and Scarlett was having trouble finding her words as her eyes went wide at the sight of those four enormous cocks and the fact that this was what Natalie was surprising her with.

"Natalie! What the hell?" Scarlett demanded, turning to Natalie and seeing the nervous, but visibly excited look on her girlfriend's face.

And again Scarlett asked the most pressing question.

"Why?" she asked.

For that Natalie had a simple answer.

"Because I know you wanted this," Natalie said, the look on her face showing just how much she was enjoying this look of utter shock and stupor that Scarlett was making. "I've seen you checking out guys lately and I wanted to do this for you. I wanted to give you what you want."

As surreal as it was that this was happening, Scarlett felt the reflexive need to defend herself and not let Natalie get the wrong idea about how she felt.

"No! I...I...I don't want men!" Scarlett insisted, barely believing she was in this situation. "I want you Nat! I like girls! I don't want to fuck men! Ummm no offense guys."

Scarlett felt the need to add that last part in. She didn't know any of these men but they were all standing before her like four nude Adonises. They were all so muscular and toned, not like in over the top body builder ways, but in ways that showed they worked out and cared about their physical appearances and did what they needed to do to keep themselves in good health and shape. These guys were definitely not accountants or celebrity news bloggers.

It seemed absolutely insane that they were here and that Scarlett was staring right at their exposed penises. She wanted them to know that this wasn't personal and she wanted Natalie not to doubt her love for her or her commitment to her. So Scarlett found herself apologizing to them while defending her lesbianism.

But she didn't need to do that and Natalie made that clear.

"It's okay. I'm not mad! Clearly I'm not mad!" Natalie said waving her hand toward their four naked, hung new friends. "I arranged all of this to surprise you! To make you happy! To give you what you want!"

"But...but...I want girls...I want you!" Scarlett insisted, sputtering out her words as she still couldn't fully wrap her mind around all of this and the fact that Natalie so clearly wanted this to happen.

Natalie then silenced Scarlett with a soft kiss right on her famous lips.

"It's okay, it really is!" Natalie said after pulling her mouth away. "I know you still think about guys and I'm giving you permission to do this. It's okay! I want this for you! I did this for you...and for me too! I want to do something crazy and wild and kinky! For tonight you can want guys again! They're here for us, for both of us! They'll fuck us and make us feel so good and tomorrow they'll be gone and we can get back to you just wanting to be with girls!"

Scarlett couldn't believe what she was hearing from Natalie and the look of absolute confusion and surprise on her face made Natalie giggle with delight. She had wanted to shock her lover. She had wanted to turn the tables on her and surprise her for once. She had wanted to do something absolutely insane with Scarlett and this certainly qualified.

Natalie was almost giddy with excitement, reveling in Scarlett's sincere shock and at her own disbelief that she was actually going through with this. This was going to be a wild experience for the both of them and Natalie couldn't wait for it to actually get started. She kissed Scarlett again, this time more sensually, making sure the boys could see how close they really were as she tongue kissed her girlfriend right in front of them.

"Don't they have such big cocks?" Natalie giggled, feeling so wicked as she ogled those big, hanging dicks while the men stood just enough away from her and Scarlett to give them space. "They have to do whatever we say too. We can make them do whatever we want to us. You can fulfill every dirty fantasy you have Scarlett. Mmmm and so can I!"

Natalie had been going back and forth in her mind about what she would actually do with these guys and how far she would go. Sometimes she thought she might only watch as Scarlett used these men for her pleasure and sucked and fucked to her heart's content. But other times Natalie thought she might indulge in forbidden pleasures too and let herself get good and fucked by men for the first time in years.

She didn't know what was going to happen. She didn't even fully know what she wanted. But Natalie liked this. She liked this a lot. She was glad she had actually gone through with this and she hoped she could lose herself in the passion of the moment and maybe really go a little cock crazy.

"Mmmm yeahhhhh such big cocks!" Scarlett moaned back lustfully as Natalie's soft little hands caressed her big tits through her teddy. "I can't believe you did this Natalie! I...you...what were you thinking?"