The first night
Tara and I had planned on meeting Kara and Brad at the beach house, Friday night late after everyone finished work and could make the drive over. When Tara and I got there, we saw Kara's Honda parked outside, not Brad's Subaru like usual. I didn't really think anything of it.
When we grabbed our backpacks and went in, Kara was on the couch watching TV. It was obvious she had been drinking for at least an hour. "Oh, its you." She says to Tara and I. Not sure who else it might be. "Fuck Brad, sonofabitch. Fuck." And she started crying.
Knowing my place, I grabbed the bag out of Tara's hands and went to the bedroom, while she sat down with her twin sister, on the couch. Turns out, Brad was dicking someone else, and Kara found out just before setting out for our couples beach weekend. Awkward, but I can't deny I immediately got a bit chubby thinking of banging Kara and Tara, expertly exacting her revenge on Brad that dumb motherfucker. But I knew, that ain't gonna happen. So I went to the kitchen, to grab a beer and see if I could give words of comfort to my girlfriends hot twin sister.
He's a cocksucker, I said. Not worth it. Bastard. How could he, just look at you, your hot. I said it all, grabbed another beer and went to the bedroom. Within an hour, Tara tucked her sister into bed and came to me to vent. She flopped, still dressed onto the bed after putting her beer on the end table.
"Fuck him. Why would he do that? I mean, she gave him everything and I mean, everything and he does this." She stood up and started taking off her clothes, very spiritedly.
"What do you mean?" I asked, unsure of what everything meant.
"OK, but please don't freak out." She said, looking pensive. Now in only her bra and panties, Tara sat down by me on the bed. Handed me my beer. "About three years ago, before we were dating and I was single, Kara and I gave Brad a birthday present." She looked up, scared. "Yeah, he got both of us, naked. I didn't fuck him, but I did suck his dick. We did it at the same time." She looked at me, one eyebrow raised appraising my reaction. And then finished, looking angry. "Plus, she gave him anal, alot."
I sat on the edge of the bed, stunned. "What the fuck?"
"Look, Brad was a good guy to her then. So, I know you're mad, but you weren't around and he is cute and has a nice big...anyway, it was kinda fun." She looked half nervous, half aggressive.
I stared, words pulsing in my ears. "I don't care about the fucking threesome." I said, indignant. "You never let me fuck your ass!" I said, hurt and shocked. And, thinking Kara was the hottest thing in the house at the time.
"Well, you never asked, did you?" She said, mockingly. Tara cocked her head at me, grin on her face.
"Yes I did!" Standing up, beer at risk of slopping out the bottle in my agitation. "Years ago, after we started dating."
Tara looked at me, like I was fucking special ed. "What is wrong with you? You brought it up, a month after we started sleeping together. And I said I was not interested."