Thanks to Cheer_Smartie526 for editing this story.
*****
The day finally arrived. It was her birthday. We had talked about doing this for some time now but never agreed on a time or when we actually wanted it to take place. It was put on the backburner several times. Then I came up with a suggestion, unknown to her. I decided to announce it on her special day.
Michelle is very beautiful. To me, she is one of the most beautiful woman I have ever laid eyes on. A gorgeous body, beautiful long hair, and legs to die for. Our first meeting was at a lecture while in college. I sat down next to her and she said hello to me for the first time. That beautiful soft voice attracted me to her instantly. I looked up at her and said hello in response and we locked eyes. We looked at each other for a moment but it seemed like an eternity. She smiled at me and I smiled back. When I looked down towards her hands, I noticed she was holding part of a newspaper, the Home Rental section. At the time, I was also looking for a new place to live so I introduced myself.
"My name is Shawn." I stammered.
She responded, "Michelle, nice to meet you."
I informed her that I was looking for a new place to live and if she needed a roommate, I would be more than happy to share a place with her. I gave her one of my cards and we returned our attention to the lecture. A few days later she called me and took me up on my offer. The house that she wanted to rent was a 3 bedroom home, already furnished. She asked me to help her look for a third person to occupy the third room in order to help keep costs down. We both screened applicants and if one of us didn't agree on a person, it was a "no go." After several days of applicants, we finally found someone. Keith. A very polite and, at the same time, funny gentleman. At his interview, he had brought a cup of coffee with him. The top wasn't on very tight so when he went to take drink, it poured down his shirt. We all laughed and he said, "If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have any luck at all." Of course more laughter followed after that. From that time forward, we became roommates.
Over the course of the next 2 years, the three of us became really close. We could talk about anything. We became very open with each other, especially when it came to sex. One evening while we were eating dinner, the topic of having sex with more than one person at a time came up. Just as a conversation piece, Michelle said, "Has any of you ever slept with more than one person at a time in the same night?" Now we always have interesting conversations when we're eating and this was definitely no acception.
Keith responded, "I came close one time. It would have been with two girls too but one got sick from the party that we were at so the other girl drove her home."
I never even came close so I blurted out "no, I haven't, although I wish that I have."
"Would u rather have two girls or another guy and girl?" Michelle asked with a smile.
I said, "It really doesn't matter to me but don't get me wrong. I'm not gay by any means but I wouldn't mind sharing either."
"What about u Keith? Are you strictly a two girl, one guy man?"
Keith paused for a moment and then said, "You know, I could go along with either myself. Although, if there was another guy involved, he would have to be trustworthy. No blabbermouth. Talk concerning the threesome would have to stay within the group."
There was a small pause after that and then I said, "So what about you Michelle? Have u ever had a threesome before?"
She laughed, "No, but have thought about it quite often. Never really ran across the right set of people though."
We continued on with dinner talking about different things throughout the meal that night. During the next year or so, the topic of a threesome would pop up more and more, pretty much on a regular basis. Both Keith and I are very attracted to Michelle and Michelle was also attracted to both of us which she stated to each of us on several different occasions. I knew her birthday was coming up soon, so I said to Keith, "Let's give Michelle a birthday that she has never had before."
"Ok. What do u have in mind?"
I said, "A threesome."
Keith's eyes just about popped out of his head. "A threesome?" He stammered.
"Yes", I responded. "She's attracted to the both of us and we to her. We know each other and we're very comfortable with each other. We talk about threesomes constantly. We know she wants to have one just as much as we do. She has stated that to us several times, together and separately. So what do you think? Want to sit down together and ask her if she's willing to do this with us?"