The One That Got Away

Chapter 7

Allison drove to Lake Simcoe. After finishing the summer semester, she thought that she needed a retreat. Midterm season was stressful without the added pressure of awaiting an accurate negative result on her pregnancy test. Zee retracted all credit card privileges upon finding out about her wild day. However, after she aced her final exam, he saw that she learned her lesson and lent her his old Camry to use as her own form of transportation. Today was a getaway. An activity day for Zee and his friends.

Allison kept her distance from Joe since that day because it was overwhelming to have taken such an impulsive risk. She drove to the lake on the regional roads to beat the traffic that would otherwise come with a highway. It was a smart move because she got there an hour before anyone else. She had nothing else to do except fidget with her phone. She sat on a giant rock on the grass and checked her Facebook.

Joe did accept her friend request after Allison confronted him about it that day, on the off chance that she got pregnant. He himself only used the platform in emergencies, which it would be if it turned out he was going to be a father.

Since the relief of finding out she wasn't pregnant, they haven't messaged much since. Therefore, Allison just killed that hour by looking at old messages. A bit of get-to-know-yous were all that occupied the chat thread.

'I sometimes go by Jay because I was too lazy to write out Joseph in elementary school.'

Allison smirked remembering how funny it was when she first read it. She looked up and hoped no one around noticed her. She got up and decided to check the rental shop. It was a slight walk from the parking lot as she approached a shed with all kinds of sports equipment behind it. She entered and decided to get a good look inside. It was run by a middle-aged man. Allison was curious about the cost for a paddleboard, to which he said $40 for four hours. That sounded a bit pricey. She decided to be seductive and removed her bra under green tank top. Then she pulled up her tank top to reveal the bottom half of her boobs and grasped them with her hands.

The man was not amused at her antics. However, it was far from the first time a customer tried that for a discount. They were likely strapped for cash, so he often showed them mercy. He let her rent one for half the cost. Because she was already without a bra, she had an idea to get changed into her white tee without a bra. She just wanted to be eye candy again for everyone else enjoying the lake. When the shirt got wet enough, she just rolled it up to reveal the bottom of her boobs and stood firmly on the paddleboard, paddle in her hands. It was just like with the rental shop owner only this time, it was for everyone to see. Many guys on the shore took photos with their phones, and a few went up to the shore to get their phones. Allison felt like a model. She knew Zee would get mad and take his Camry back if he knew she was being crazy again. After she knew the photo taking was finally done, she got to shore herself and got changed into less revealing clothes.

Zee and his friends arrived shortly after. She loved the adrenaline of being naughty behind his back. He wasn't her father but just having that mature friend gives her a rebellious attitude that makes letting loose so much fun. The gang enjoyed the rest of the afternoon in the lake either with equipment rentals or just having a good swim. That night they headed to Denny's for dinner.

At Denny's, they ordered and were waiting for their food when Zee was looking at his phone. Then he turned his face to Allison with an angry expression. 'Are you fucking kidding me?!!!' he snarked as he showed her his phone screen. He was on Snapchat, an app she never used. It was filled with local stories about her with various captions.

'Hottie on paddleboard'

'Tits and tricks on the lake'

Chapter 8

Zee was furious now. He came from a rich family but instead of spoiling him, they raised him to be very mature. And it really showed with how he watched over Allison after she got into these shenanigans. He forced her to return back to the Scarborough Campus of the University of Toronto for her final year. He was going to watch her closely and make sure she doesn't go out sexualizing herself any more before it sets her down a path that it makes getting her degree a complete waste. Imagine where she would be right now if she did get pregnant from Joe. He also knew he was partially responsible for this with his 'life of the party' persona that set off a fuse inside of her which was suppressed all these years. Allison stayed over at his place for much of the semester so he could keep his eyes on her.

She had no problem with her courses aside from still getting nervous from class presentations in groups. Despite discovering that loose side, public speaking still got to her. Thankfully, her group mates again carried her.

They were going to split ways but Zee knew that he kept her out of trouble until she finished her degree, so she was no longer his liability. She is an adult after all.

Allison also put on a bit of weight from that year of being indoors all the time studying. She decided just to work out at the Aquatics Center. She still got plenty of eyes and therefore, was motivated to train herself. She sported a workout bra for the gym and a two-piece swimsuit whenever she got in the water. Even though she didn't find any immediate results right away, she was still pretty confident from all the ogles. It's been a year since the pregnancy scare. Enough of the fear has already faded that she wouldn't mind going unprotected again. What would really turn her on is doing it with a college freshman. Someone who is just barely an adult.

She knew there was going to be an orientation that weekend which will conclude at the Aquatics Center. That would be the perfect time to strike. Just wait for the orientation to be over and pick up one of the guys.

'Hey' said a familiar voice.

Allison snapped out of planning her elaborate plot and turned her attention to Mirela talking to her. They haven't hung out since last year.

'It's been a while' replied Allison.

They got coffee at the Aquatic Center's Tim Hortons coffee shop and Allison told Mirela her plan, knowing that Mirela enjoyed being pretty alongside her.

Mirela was also aroused at the thought of fucking a barely legal aged freshman and decided that they should be in a threesome. Her plan was to recreate that moment where they walked together to the pool. This time however, they should be walking back to the changeroom from the pool as the boy is passing by. Therefore, they can get changed right away and pick up the young lad right after his orientation is over.

Allison knew she was in safe hands with Mirela being there as well. Mirela would be sure to not let a naïve boy carelessly cum in her and pose a pregnancy risk.

Chapter 9

Allison and Mirela were in the pool watching the volunteer orientation. The pool area was surrounded by glass walls so they could see the group in the hallway. After the leader gave the final talk, all the soon-to-be freshmen started to leave. That was the girls' cue to get out of the pool and head down the hallway towards the changeroom.

It worked out perfectly as only one guy was left in the hallway and he did give them quite the stare in shock. He wasn't expecting two girls in swimsuits to just walk by him. Mirela gave him the 'call me' gesture. That was enough for him to know to wait for them.

They got changed right away and brought the boy to Mirela's residence on campus and headed straight for the bedroom. He had nice, thick brown hair. Mirela knelt down and unbuckled his jeans. She pulled them down along with the underwear. Allison knelt as well to grab the cock and caressed it to get him aroused.

'What's your name?' asked Allison as she started stroking it.

'Jeremy' he answered.

'What major are you going to study here?' Mirela asked.

He told them he was going to study Computer Science. Engaging in small talk while getting jacked off just made him hornier. He couldn't take it and just fell backwards on Mirela's bed. Allison undressed and decided to sit on his belly and continue stroking him like that. He had quite the cock for an 18-year-old. Jeremy was really aroused by having the weight of a slightly chunky girl like Allison on top of him.

'This is my bed!' Mirela screamed, feeling left out.

She got undressed as well and got on the bed. Allison stopped stroking Jeremy so Mirela could ride him. Mirela had a giggle putting the cock in her pussy because of how big it was.

While Mirela was riding him, Allison leaned in to passionately kiss her on the lips a few times. This aroused Jeremy so much that he had to climax right there. He was squinting his face as it turned red and he came. Mirela laughed. She couldn't believe what just happened and she enjoyed every bit of it.

Knowing she just got creamed in, Allison sucked on Mirela's nipples to pleasure her a bit more. While Jeremy didn't last long enough for Allison to get a ride, she at least thought that Mirela should enjoy it as much as she can.

This couldn't have been the cream of the crop. There had to have been a freshman in the orientation group with way more stamina than Jeremy. Perhaps that was the one that got away.

Chapter 10

Joe lost count of how many times he ejaculated in the VIP lounge. But the only one that mattered to him was Allison. Mainly because she was the only one that he came inside without a condom and therefore, the only pregnancy scare. He was glad that it didn't come to be because he wouldn't have known how to explain it to Lance, owner of Zanzibar and now his current roommate.

Allen was unaware of his gig. But once April came, Joe needed help filing taxes for the first time without his parent's help. So, he relied on Allen to help. But there was no hiding how he was getting his income. Plea as he may, Joe couldn't downplay being a sex worker.

'You operate a ferry. Who knows how many people you've taken to Hanlan's Point.', Joe argued, referencing Toronto's lone clothing optional beach.

'I take them to Center Island. Hanlan's Point is just one small part of it. Plus, I don't go there dancing naked and fucking people like you!', an angry Allen responded.

Because Joe reaped in a lot of VIP room customers, Lance took pity and housed him in his apartment. The balcony had a good view of the giant Rogers Tower. But best of all, Lance didn't have a strict policy on bringing in girls. Someone like Lance could afford a mansion, in spite of Toronto's skyrocketing housing market. However, he knew that living humbling in an apartment and being wise with his money was the way to go because he didn't have to worry about keeping expensive property in good condition. If his roommate wanted to bring guests into his apartment and create a mess, fine by him. As long as they stay out of his bedroom, he doesn't care.

Joe did see it as a blessing that he was rid of being anchored by Allen's strict policies. He felt like he was on cloud nine now. This freedom made him enjoy going to work more. It was already enjoyable because he didn't have a client that he didn't find at least a little attractive. He felt like he could eventually find one that he could bring back to the apartment and fill that slight void in his heart that was Allison. Not many VIP patrons were the smart, college student. Many that studied at Ryerson were not able to afford the VIP lounge. He couldn't break policies unless he was willing to pay Lance the cost himself.

Therefore, he decided one day just to show up earlier in the afternoon before his shift when it was normally empty. Maybe a few Ryerson students would be there and he could treat them to a free VIP visit. That was how the fortunate circumstance came to be that fateful day when he fucked Allison. She was definitely a different person than the shy, timid girl he met a year ago. Joe liked her even more. Not only was she smart and hot, but she was also very rowdy.

However, the pregnancy scare prevented her from committing to a relationship with him. She was also studying a hectic final year. Joe understood and kept thinking of Allison every time he got another hand job or fucked a customer with a condom on. Suddenly, this freedom felt more like a curse because now he only wanted to bring Allison home and no one else, but knows that he can't.

By the following year, he knew she was done with school. He decided to hit her up on Facebook messenger. Perhaps she has gotten over the trauma of nearly getting pregnant to trust men again. He got a reply right away.

'Good to hear from you. I have an idea. Would you be interested in a threesome?'

Joe couldn't believe his luck. He invited them to his apartment. After thirteen long months, he was finally able to spend the night with Allison and maybe call her his girlfriend.

Chapter 11

Allison told Mirela that she found another guy. Someone that can maybe last long enough to give them both a good fuck. Mirela was glad to hear it. She felt bad that she hogged all the cum from that freshman. They realized that freshmen may not have been the way to go, as they are not sexually ready to take on two girls.

Allison was a bit concerned that she might have put on a little too much weight for Joe. Would he still like her like this? She took a nude selfie and sent it to him so he knew what he was getting into. Joe had no problem with it at all. He understood that studying would do that to a person. The important thing to him was that she was still the same smart, rowdy, cute girl. He was hungry to see her after another year, and hopefully it will be long-term.

Allison and Mirela enjoyed a good view on the apartment's balcony. Both in black mini dresses and leaning on the railing. After taking in the nice spring breeze, they went into Joe's bedroom and got things going.

Joe sat on the edge of his bed and waited for Allison to kneel down and unbuckle his belt and take his pants off. Then, she pulled down his underwear. Joe was already hard at that point. Mirela gave a happy gasp as she was delighted to see that this cock was much bigger than Jeremy's. Therefore, a good chance that he also has more stamina. Allison let Mirela, who was kneeling beside her, to enjoy his cock first by stroking it.

The cock was hard alright. Mirela could tell it belonged to a sex worker who was used to all this cock stimulation. She could stroke it all day. Joe decided to move down and lie flat on his bed. Allison and Mirela undressed and got on his bed beside him as they took turns stroking him. All those shifts gave Joe a lot of stamina and he just let them stroke him as much as they wanted to.

Mirela got on top of Joe and rode him. Allison got on Joe as well, sitting behind Mirela and grasped her tits, pinching her nipples. She kissed her neck as Mirela tilted her head upwards and orgasmed. This cock is what dreams were made of. She didn't want it to end. When she was done climaxing, she got off and put her clothes back on. It was time that she got going so she kissed Joe on the forehead and thanked him for such a good time. She left the bedroom, went out of the apartment and headed home.

Allison was excited now that she had Joe's cock all to herself now. She was also excited that this could be the start of many threesomes with Mirela and Joe. The fun will never end. Mirela got wet all over Joe's cock when she orgasmed. Allison sucked the sweet juices off the cock that she left behind. She licked the penis head to make sure it was all gone. Then, she got on and rode him.

'Do I feel heavier than last time?', asked Allison self-consciously.

'Not at all', answered Joe.

Allison wasn't as in shape as she used to. Eventually she got off of him, lied down on her side with one leg in the air, and asked Joe to fuck her. Joe realized she was getting physically tired. There were many clients he fucked before that were chubby but most didn't get tired that easily. Therefore, he was mindful to periodically ask if he was going too fast. Joe loved the way that Allison's fat folded on itself while she was in that position. Allison knew that she would really need to train to be fit again for these long sex sessions with Joe.

It was hard for her to get off with Joe needing to slow down constantly. Therefore, Joe decided just to set Allison on her back and fingered her to get it over with. He used his right hand.

'Fuck, fuck, fuck, fuck,' she jabbered, with Joe's middle and ring fingers jiggling inside of her.

Then, she screamed one last 'fuck' as she squirted. It wasn't the end that she envisioned but she was glad that she got the pleasure.

She spent the night with Joe, both of them cuddled in bed naked. She can't wait to try again when she wakes up to his morning wood.

Chapter 12

Allison never got the satisfaction of a good fuck, as her lack of fitness got in the way. Until she slimmed down, she relied on Mirela to finger her. Mirela was not as rough as Joe. It also made for awkward threesomes as Mirela had to go doggy style against Joe while Allison sat with her legs spread out in front of her to be fingered.

After a few, she decided just to stay out of their sex sessions until she could get fit again. Allison did consider getting fingered Jeremy in a threesome with Mirela, but the way things ended last time didn't leave a good impression on him. They awkwardly escorted him out in silence. Jeremy himself felt embarrassed because he knew he came prematurely and disappointed them. There was no way she'd try reaching out to him again.

Allison had an idea that they look for a lesbian freshman that can finger her along with Mirela. In hindsight, they should have kept an eye out for the females in the orientation group.

Allison took a breather and thought for a second. Why is she suddenly so horny and obsessed with getting off? Why is she dating a person who has become a sex worker since she fell in love him? Shouldn't she look for someone more monogamist? Has undergrad changed her this much? Or is she now at the age where she is at the peak of her sexual urges?

Joe had a few good sessions with Mirela. She was never let down by his cock and stamina. It was there that she asked him if any of his VIP lounge customers were bisexual and willing to try a threesome with her and Allison. Joe stayed on the lookout at work and asked each client after being jerked off or fucking them. One was very fit and kept her ginger hair knotted in a ponytail. She looked quite masculine and Joe thought that she would certainly arouse Allison. She was indeed masculine and very strong. Strong enough to get Joe to cum quite fast despite his stamina. So, he coordinated by telling her about his girlfriend and sending her off to Mirela's on-campus residence.

She gave Allison a very powerful fingering, aggressively licking her pussy periodically. Allison loved the fact that this strength was coming from a girl. She had her legs in the air while Mirela kept them held up. Allison was crying from how rough it was. However, she loved every bit of it. She squirted but the girl wasn't done with her just yet. She slung Allison up over her shoulders and continued fingering her, vagina beside her face. Allison struggled, swinging her legs in the air as she was in an even more uncomfortable position now. She screamed at the discomfort. When she squirted again, the girl set Allison back down on Mirela's bed. Allison was breathing heavily now. This was way rougher than anything Joe could have provided. She just hoped that this didn't cause any long-term damage to her pussy. Mirela kissed her vagina boo boo to make it better.

It was a rough few days. Allison was limping. She spent most of it recovering in Mirela's residence. This threw a wrench in her plans to exercise her weight off. But it was enough to steer her away from trying to get off for a while.