I met Cancace, in the fall of 1988. We were both members of a Christian dating service in Orange County, California.
Each week, the service held a "group" session which was, sort of, a psychotherapy, group where people discussed their "issues."
I was a passive member, who supported others, and didn't really go beyond the "I am still looking for love" statement.
One week, which Candace attended, another member, who sat next to me, tearfully blurted out details about an affair that she just ended, and how it was "great sex" but she couldn't get past the guilt of sleeping with a married co-worker. I held her hand, for support, and didn't make some of the, cruel, judgmental, comments that others made, instead offering that, "I doubt there are many virgins in the room. Most of us haven't waited until marriage."
Unknowingly, Candace remembered that statement, and, a month or two later, looked up my profile and sent a request for a date.
By that time, I was dating a woman and declined Candace's offer but said "maybe later."
During my months, with "Liz," a 26-year-old, Latina, Catholic virgin, we struggled with her chastity, and overly-sensitive hymen, but eventually crossed the "love line" when I retutrned from a business trip and she, boldly, surrendered her virginity and stated, "I wish I hadn't waited."
Though we had an active and enjoyable sex life, Liz insisted on condoms and struggled with guilt (Catholicism) in the hours after our pleasure.
Eventually, Liz broke things off, regretting our sex life, though she invited me over for one last encounter, even allowing me to leave the condoms in the nightstand as her period was starting the next day. We enjoyed ourselves and had numerous mutual orgasms - including a shower session that was our first.
Despite breaking things off, Liz invited me to her bedroom, later, which I declined as I wanted a long-term relationship.
A few weeks later, I was at the dating center office and discussing the "Liz situation" with one of the managers who was familiar with our relationship, sex life, guilt struggles, etc.
Midway through our conversation, Candace walked in and smiled when she heard I was "Available." Boldly, she asked me out on a date that afternoon. I cautioned, "Are you sure you want a 'rebound' guy? One that was sleeping with another woman a few weeks ago?" Candace replied, "I've been waiting for you for months. Her loss is my gain. I don't care if you slept with her, as long as you aren't sleeping with her anymore."
I explained that I'd turned down the opportunity, because I don't have "casual sex."
For visual purposes, Candace is a blonde, busty, 5-4, Meg Ryan look-alike, about 20 pounds overweight. I am 5-10, about 195, brown hair. Just an average guy.
We agreed to go to a late lunch, and a walk on the Huntington Beach pier. During our drive, I asked Candace, "Why me?" She responded, "Similar church beliefs, similar interests, music, photography, sports (Dodgers, Lakers and Rams), you're cute, neither of us are virgins."
My response was, "Do you have guilt issues?" Candace said, "No. However, I've only been with two guys. I lost my v-card on prom night, had sex with him a few times, only to have his family move away. The second guy had "guilts" a few minutes later and ran out. It was humiliating! We always used condoms and I never spent the night. No one has "gone down on me." I want to get a tongue orgasm, I want a long-term relationship, condom-free, and to wake up in my lover's arms. I want commitment. I like how you didn't judge the woman for having an affair. You were kind. I already sort ofg fell in love with you. Can you handle that?"
"Sure," I said. Let's see how things go. "Do you want to sleep with me?" I asked.
"Months ago," Candace responded. "You aren't like these Christian guys who have had sex but want to marry a virgin."