This story is based in fact mixed with fantasy. You can decide which is which. No names were changed to protect anyone,(JK).
I know it's a little long, but the payoff is good and I won't have to set the scene again for the continuation,(if I get good feedback).
Enjoy!
Shelby and Johnny, PT 1, The Beginning.
Originally titled: It All Happened Innocently Enough, Part 1
It was a dark and stormy night.
Oh hell! That beginnings been used.
I'll just start.
It DID all start innocently enough. My former wife, Shelby and my Daughter, Shannon, were coming out from the Midwest to the Coast to visit relatives. Since I had been in contact with Shannon and she had spent some time with me the previous years, they thought they would both visit with me.
I was currently separated from my current spouse and was staying at a motel until I could figure out what to do.
Shelby had remarried long ago and had another daughter she named Cheyenne who staying with the relatives Shelby and Shannon were going to visit.
I was expecting Shelby and Shannon on Saturday, my day off, but they came in two days early.
I was surprised when I got the call. We decided to meet at my soon to be ex's house since we were all friends.
Sarah, my soon to be ex, met me outside and we went into the house together. Shannon got up and gave me a big hug and a peck on the cheek. Then I saw Shelby. I continued my hug with Shannon but was looking straight into Shelby's eyes. I hadn't seen her in many years but she was still very stunning.
With few differences Shelby and Shannon could pass as sisters. Both had curves in just the right places. Both had silky honey-blonde hair. It was hot that day and both were wearing short- shorts and tube tops.
"OH, MY GOD," I thought to myself. "YUMMY!!"
I broke away from Shannon and gave Shelby a very tight hug. Needless to say my little pants friend decided to wake up and I was trying not to make my hard-on obvious. I sat down as quick as I could.
There was some small talk going on. I didn't hear a thing. I was looking at Shelby.
She looked great for a mom of 40. She could have easily passed for 25. Shoulder length honey-blonde hair, about 5'5" maybe 105lbs. I remember her boobs as 36Cs a nice tight tummy, she's been staying in shape. And those shorts, they showed me enough! They hugged her very nice ass and camel toe and then on to her shapely legs. It was a sight to behold. I could see the "green eyed monster in Sarah!
I was just starting to go back all those years ago to the night I popped her cherry, (I'll write about that later), when somewhere in the distance someone was calling me. I was brought back to the present when someone smacked my shoulder.
Sarah asked "Where did you GO? I've only called you like five times!"
Yeah, like she didn't know what I was thinking! I said "I'm sorry! It's just that it been A while since I've seen Shelby and can't believe she's actually here. Shannon is almost her twin"
Sara said "Whatever!"
I think Shelby saw where this might lead (BIG FIGHT) and spoke up.
"Hey Johnny we've been driving most of the day and wanted to know if you would join us for dinner?"
I said "Sure, why not. What about you Sarah?"
Sarah said "No, but thank you. I'm meeting friends in a little bit."
So I said "Let's go, see ya Sarah, have fun and be careful. Use a rubber!"
I can be such an ass sometimes.
Sarah just waved and mumbled something.
We walked out to my truck and I opened the door for my ladies and I was surprised that Shelby got in first, so as to be next to me. Then Shannon got in.
We made small talk, talked about their trip and how our town has changed.
We had a nice dinner and then we decided to go to a movie. We went in got our overpriced snacks and settled in for the movie.
At one point I was watching the screen and moved my arm to the arm rest not knowing that that space was occupied by Shelby's arm. When I touched her hand I pulled back quickly and muttered a very faint "sorry".
She turned to me and flashed a smile, then went back to watching the movie.
When I touched her hand I felt a jolt go through me and my dick went right to attention.
I was day dreaming and didn't notice that Shelby had moved and her hand was on my thigh. When I felt that, I looked over to Shannon who was engrossed in the movie. The hand moved up my leg so that Shelby's pinkie finger was rubbing my dick very lightly.
I guess the soda Shannon was drinking got to her bladder and she said she was going to the ladies room. I looked over and watched her go up the aisle. GOD she had a nice ass. (My big head screamed at me, Dude! That's your DAUGHTER!!!)
I turned back to look at Shelby and she at me. We were gazing into each others eyes.
The time/space continuum disappeared.
Like north and south poles, our lips were drawing closer. They met very tenderly, then, mashing harder together. Our tongues found each other and danced and twirled and fought in our mouths. Our embrace tightening.
Me thinking I'm going to cum in my jeans like some 14 year old teen getting to second base.
Just as I was starting to go to second myself we were awoken from our bliss by a VERY loud "MOMMM!!!!!
I think everyone in the 15 theatres of the building heard her.
We broke our embrace both turned beet red, yes you could tell in that dark theatre. Well the movie was over for us, so we left.
We drove back to my ex's place to get their car in total silence. I got out and opened the door for my ladies and Shannon bolted straight to their car.
Shelby said "Follow us back!"
So I did.
Driving behind them, I could see thru the back window of their car, there was an obvious argument going on.
During the drive I went back in my mind to all the times I had seen Shelby naked. How could I have let that angel go? I thought.
I knew it was my foolish pride.
I knew in my heart who I had always loved.
All those years, All my relationships. I was looking for Shelby.
She was my first, And all this time I had been trying to suppress what was deep, deep in my heart.
God how I wished we had never parted. How I wished she was mine again.
I knew it wouldn't happen.
What HAD happened back there at the movie? Was that just a one time thing? Had the stars just aligned themselves just right just for one last kiss?
GOD himself only knew.
We got to their hotel and to my surprise was only blocks from where I was staying. I walked up to their car and Shannon got out.
She gave me a hug and said "I'm sorry I embarrassed you two back at the movie. It just shocked me. And Mom and Jack really love each other. When I saw you two kissing I just kinda lost it."
I said "Don't worry sweetheart, we just got caught up in A moment. So I apologize to you and to your mom and Jack.
Can your Mom and me have a few minutes together before I go?" I asked.
She said, "Sure!" and gave me a hug and a peck on the cheek.
As Shannon walked away she said "I'll be WATCHING you two.