Joan and I continued to see the psychiatrist for about six months. We had individual counseling for several weeks followed by group therapy. Joan was in a woman's group and I was in a man's group, then ultimately we were put together in a couple's group.
Early on, I came up with an analogy which I thought explained my situation very well. Dr. Rogers had me repeat it as I entered each group. I was embarrassed to say it in front of Joan because it was insulting to her, but it was how I felt.
I've always liked analogies. A good one enables you to see a complex situation in simple terms. My analogy went like this: "I love steak. It's my absolutely favorite food. I also like chicken very much, almost as much as steak. Now if you tell me I can have steak every day, but that's all I get, no baked potato with sour cream, no salad, no wine with my steak; but on the other hand I can have chicken every day and with it I get potatoes and a vegetable, a salad if I want it, a nice wine with my meal, and even dessert if I so desire, then I would have to go for the chicken."
And that's what I did; I went for the chicken! When I told this analogy I got lambasted. Of course the therapist said nothing when I first told him, but the group members (both groups) thought it was terrible. For Joan it confirmed that if it had been a one-on-one contest I would have chosen Melissa. But I think she already sensed that. Isn't this reluctance to give up one's life style a primary reason why a spouse who has an affair (not just cheating, but a true affair like I felt I'd had) usually stays married?
Dr. Rogers had a profound effect on Joan. At our first meeting he asked each of us, separately, to describe a negative characteristic of our spouse in a single word. I said Joan was stoic, i.e.-very stiff, inflexible. Of course I don't know what word Joan used, but I suspect it was self-centered, since she felt every consultant in our company was conceited. She used to say that she could pick out the consultants in a group after a five minute conversation.
Under Dr. Rogers' guidance, she made a sincere effort to change. She bought the book, "The Joys of Sex" and later "More Joys of Sex". We went through them, trying many of the ideas. As for me, I did not enjoy eating messy food off her body but I did enjoy titty-fucking, especially since she would kiss and lick the head of my penis on each upstroke. We tried ass-fucking but neither one of us enjoyed it. We also tried a variety of positions but we could not do anything that required more that a minute or two of physical effort by Joan.
We also started going to a movie theater that showed soft core porn one night each week (there was no hard core theater anywhere near us and the VCR was not available yet). Joan would dress sexy, short skirts, though not minis, and fitted sweaters with no bra. We would sit there and play with one another. We never went any further in the theater, but one night we were so excited as we left we had sex in the parking lot in my Fiat, no small feat.
I bought her some sexy clothes too, and I took some pictures of her with our Polaroid camera for my eyes only. My favorite of the clothes I bought was an ankle length, body-hugging, bright red halter dress. It was bare to the waist in the back, so she couldn't wear a bra with it, and it was so fitted that any underwear she tried on made it look bad because you would see lines. It wasn't obscene, just classy-sexy. So she wore it with nothing underneath, something she had never done in her life. The first time she wore it, we went to a dinner theater which had a buffet meal before the play began. We had never attracted much attention on our previous times there but tonight everyone enjoyed looking at Joan. I was very proud of her, and during the play I couldn't keep my hands off her. Even the cast members complimented her as we went through their receiving line at the end of the night.
We also had some bad experiences. Some times, I felt so wracked with guilt I could not get an erection, the only times in my life I ever had that problem (Even today, at 74, I can will an erection any time I wish to).
I do not believe therapy had as much effect on me as on Joan. However, I did become a little more considerate and I took Joan out frequently, especially on weekends after I'd been out of town all week. Of course part of this was due to how attractive she looked. We even got into disco-dancing when it became popular. I was still a poor dancer but I enjoyed all the turns and spins I put Joan through, and the admiring glances she got as we danced.
I reached three conclusions about my life in the future. For one, Joan and I really would be together "until death do us part". Since I hadn't left her for Melissa, whom I truly loved, I could not imagine leaving under any circumstances. And I knew she would not leave me, no matter what I did, within reason. Secondly, I knew I would not remain faithful to her, but from now on I would be careful to not fall in love. Finally, I knew that if Joan died before I did, I would seek out Melissa and attempt to reconnect. This last one did not happen; we both are still in very good health.
Even before I started dating Melissa I decided to get in shape. There was a 10K race in Atlanta on July 4th each year known as the Peachtree Road Race. In 1974 there were over 6000 participants, several of whom were in my company (they now have over 25,000 runners each year). I decided that when the weather broke in late February or early March I would start jogging with the goal of running in the 1975 race. I also started doing some sit-ups and push-ups.
I had no doubt that I would be successful as I had the utmost confidence that I could accomplish anything that was totally within my control.
A specific event that occurred between my junior and senior years of high school caused me to stop using foul language immediately. Since then, I've used an occasional hell or damn for emphasis but nothing worse. Even writing some of the words in this story has been very uncomfortable for me but I felt they were necessary for the story.