Meg sat at a kitchen stool in Alex's house. She'd baked blueberry muffins for the boys, and she munched on one herself while they practiced. She'd chosen not to sit in the living room since the drum set was so loud, but she wasn't sure that the small distance between the living room and kitchen made much of a difference. She'd forgotten how loud instruments could be.
While they were not playing, talking about how to adjust a new song, a different chord here, a change in volume there, she flipped through a novel she was reading, but when they started playing again, she would mark her place and watch them. Alex would occasionally look up from his drum set and smile at her.
When they finished playing, Roy and Joel set their guitars on stands and unplugged the amps. Alex set down his drumsticks and went to Meg at the counter.
"Come on upstairs," he told her.
He snagged two blondies for himself and she followed him upstairs. He sat in his desk chair and ate the pastries, his eyes looking her over as he chewed.
"I think I like having my girlfriend at band practice," Alex told her.
"She likes being there, too," Meg said. Meg sat on his bed, leaning against the pillows.
Alex finished eating and wiped his fingers on his pants.
"I love you," he said simply.
Meg stared at him. She realized her mouth was hanging open slightly, and she closed it.
"Goddamn it," Alex said. "Again?"
"I'm sorry," Meg said. "You took me by surprise."
"Well, do you or don't you?"
"I don't know," Meg whispered.
Alex put his head in his hands and Meg knew they were remembering the same moment. They'd been together for a few months, and they had been making out on the couch on the porch. Earlier, he'd put a record on the record player and they'd danced. She was wrapped in his black sweatshirt, and his arms were around her, and he stopped kissing her to say "I love you."
Then Alex had pulled her into a tight hug, and she'd whispered "I love you, too."
It had been the only time she'd said it, because later she wondered if it was too soon, and she had wished she could take it back. For months, she'd thought he'd heard her that one time, thought he'd remember her saying those words even if she couldn't bring herself to say it again.
But then, when they'd broken up, and she'd handed him back his sweatshirt, he said, "All those times I said I loved you, and you never said it back. Did you ever really care about me?" And Meg realized he hadn't heard her that one time, and she wasn't sure if that was a good or bad thing.
Now, Alex picked his head back off his hands and looked at Meg again. "Look, it's okay if you're not ready to say it yet," he said. "And I'm fine if you're not the type of person to give long speeches about your feelings. But I wish that sometimes you would tell me how you feel, you know? It's always me saying those things. And it'd be nice to know you feel them too."
"I do," Meg whispered.
"Not now," Alex said. He got to his feet. "I'm going to go downstairs for a bit. I need some space."
Meg nodded miserably. He shut the door behind him as he left and then there was silence, heavy on Meg's body. She hugged one of his pillows to her chest.
After Alex, she had never told another guy that she loved them. After being cheated on, assaulted, and having watched other women get abused by men, both emotionally and physically, it was hard to say those words. They felt too binding.
She didn't know what it would take to say those words. She didn't know if she'd ever be able to.
She did know that the thought she'd hurt Alex hurt her as well, but she also wouldn't compromise who she was for him.