The next day I got up and looked at my phone and I got a text from bailey saying "I'm sorry, meet me at our spot." When I went downstairs my sister Colleen was sitting at the table.
"Hey nerd, how was your birthday sex yesterday?"
"What?"
"Don't play dumb I heard you I'm not deaf, plus our rooms are right next to each other."
"Okay so I did, but it's still none of your business."
"It sounded pretty hot; I masturbated to your guys fucking. You really have to fix that little hole I made in your door." When she said that I was so turned on.
Now Colleen was 5'7 and she was a year older than me she had a great figure, and she had 26D breasts. She also had blonde hair like my mom and electric blue eyes like mine. So in other words she was beautiful.
"You did what?"
"Don't act so surprised, I know you've watched me masturbate before." It was true. "I've been thinking about, your old offer and now that you're eighteen, you can take my virginity. If you want you can invite Bailey, but if I have to ill fuck your huge cock while you're sleeping."
"I'll ask bailey if it's okay, but are you sure?" I asked. She nodded, gave me a kiss, and walked away.
...
When I met up with Bailey at Herrick Lake, she looked so beautiful. I sat down on a huge rock and she jumped into my lap.
"What's happening in your life lover boy?"
"Oh I just made love to this beautiful girl who could be the one."
"Really? Is she amazing in bed?"
"Yes and Yes, plus im in love with her."
"I think she loves you too." With that we passionately kissed.
"I have to tell you something." I told her about my conversation with Colleen.
"Well I guess we could fuck her together because your my man and no one else's, but I kind of don't want you too."
"I did ask she when we were kids if she wanted to be my first and she said yes, but she told me to wait. But now the only girl I want is you and no one else."