The next day I called Jeff. He was surprised to hear from me and when he realized who it was he started thanking me all over again, going on and on about how he had enjoyed that evening. I thanked him in return and told him that Judy had really enjoyed it as well and that our sex life had taken a dramatic turn for the better.
I got to the purpose of my call. "Jeff, we've been requested for a repeat performance."
He was silent for a minute then asked, "Judy wants to do it again?"
"Not exactly," I replied, "although this is her idea, she wants us to give almost the same treatment to her best friend, Karen."
Once again silence. "Is this some kind of a joke?" he blurted out.
"No, no joke at all." "I have only just begun to get my head around this as well. Judy told me two days ago what she wanted and it has taken me this long to accept what she was asking us to do." I tried to explain.
" Her best friend, Karen went through a messy divorce over two years ago now, and because of that, she hasn't been with a man since. Judy told her about the birthday massage and they got to talking and Karen told her that she would love to have something like that herself. They talked more about it and when their evening was finished Judy knew all she needed to know to bring this up to me." I continued.
" I said 'almost' the same treatment." I said. "Well, the massage leading into the erotic massage will be the same. The part that is different is that, when she is ready, she wants to have full blown sex with the both of us all night!"
I heard the phone drop and he hurriedly picked it up and said, "Now, you are messing with me, right?"
"Not at all," I replied trying to remain calm, "I can't believe that we are being asked to do this, especially by my wife, but the fact is, we are!" "Judy described her evening in great detail, including you, and Karen told her that you sounded perfect and she would like me there as well since she already knows me."
"Jeff, would you like to help me in giving a beautiful lady a fantasy come true?" I asked.
He quickly said, "Yes, definitely yes! When? Where?"
I told him I wasn't sure yet but would get the details to him as soon as I had them. I asked him about his schedule, if there were times he just could not make it. He gave me the information and I promised that I would call him the minute it was all set with all the details.
When I got home I saw Karen's car in the driveway and I got nervous knowing she was inside. I walked in and the house was quiet. I went into the kitchen and through the windows I could see Karen and Judy sitting on the patio talking. Nervously, I went to the door and opened it and stepped out onto the patio saying, " Hello you two."
They both turned in my direction and Judy broke into a huge grin, Karen smiled, but was more reserved.
"Hey Handsome!" Judy squealed, getting up to rush to me, hugging me and kissing me. She whispered in my ear, "I just finished telling Karen that you said that you would do it and that you were going to call Jeff. I hope you brought some good news home."
Releasing me, she took my hand and led me to the table. Karen said "Hello Greg."
I leaned down and kissed her cheek as I had done many times when she visited and replied, "Hello Karen, you are really looking great today."
She beamed and smiled, then looked away. She looked back at me and said, "Greg, I am really embarrassed about this. After hearing Judy tell me in great detail of her evening I was so jealous I told her I wanted something like that. I never dreamed she would even consider it, much less actually ask you."
Both Judy and I reached out and we each took one of her hands. Judy said, "Karen, I love you more than anyone except my Greg, and I know that you two like each other because of our friendship. I was shocked at first, but the more I thought of it, the more I thought that I wanted you to have the same wonderful evening that I did. Greg has had a difficult time agreeing, not because he doesn't find you attractive, but because I told him I wanted both of them to make love to you all night long after your massage."
Karen's eyes went wide and she looked at both of us in shock. " Now, I really am embarrassed!" she said.
Judy continued, " Karen, don't be. We both know that you want that physical closeness with a man again, you're ready now but the idea of bar hopping is not a pleasant thought. You told me that yourself."