How is this possible? Kate is Katrina? No way. There's no way Katrina could possibly be this absolutely stunning woman in front of me. Katrina and I had never clicked on a personality and emotional level like Kate and I had all night. I stared at her dumbfounded, refusing to believe what she had just said, and yet, there was a familiar-ness to her eyes that told me she wasn't lying.
"I...how, uh...I'm not sure what to say." I stammered.
"This can't be happening. The second guy I sleep with is the first guy I slept with in disguise? Just my fucking luck." Kate protested.
"Wait...I was your last...partner?" I asked.
"Well yeah, I didn't really have any other prospects. Don't rub it in, I'm sure you've slept with ooooh so many since me. I'm not like that ok, I just wanted to wait to find the right guy, and then I wait only to find the same guy. I waited for nothing apparently." Kate said, sinking into a depression that I'd seen her revert to so many times before.
I put my hand on her leg only to have her pull away, not wanting to touch me even after our amazing night. "Kate, Katrina, whatever you want me to call you, you're not one of many...you're the only one. Seriously, I haven't been with anyone since you either. I only just got up the nerve to talk to people like a few months ago and I've been bumbling my way through that with all the grace of a drunk on rollerblades." I explained.
"Don't call me Katrina...I'm done with that part of my life. And you don't have to lie just to make me feel better. Look at you, you're hot now, you could get any girl you want."
"Me? Look at you! You're a 10! You're gorgeous. You're way out of my league now."
Kate blushed but still wouldn't look me in the eye. I tried reaching out to her again, resting my hand on her bare shoulder as she clutched the sheet to her naked body.
"So...wadaya think we should do? I'm terrible at normal social situations and this isn't even close to normal so I'm just totally lost." I mumbled softly as I scooted over next to her, putting my arm around her.
"I don't know. Why do I feel so stupid? I feel like such an idiot." Kate said, the frustration bubbling out.
"You aren't stupid. How were we supposed to know? Do you realize how many things had to happen for this to occur? We both had to lose weight, we both had to move to New York City, we both had to go to THAT bar, and we both had to have a good enough time to actually get to where we are. That's a lot of pretty major things that had to happen for us to be here."
"I know, I know, but I still feel like an idiot. I'm 25 and I've slept with one person. And not even consecutively like some sort of high school sweetheart thing. No, I decided to sleep with the same person 7 years apart without realizing it. God that's dumb."
"Why is that dumb?"
"I don't know, it just is. Most people in their 20s are living it up, meeting lots of people, having one night stands and everything and I'm just sitting in my apartment night after night doing nothing until I finally DO decide to go out, at which point I just end up talking to the ONE guy in the world I actually already know. That's just dumb."
"Well...I mean...who could blame you? I had Dominion. No one can resist Dominion." I teased with a slight smile, trying to cheer her up. The corners of Kate's mouth twitched, but I didn't get the smile I wanted. "No, but seriously, I really did have a lot of fun with you last night...and not just when we got here, although that was really good too."
"I had fun too. A lot of fun." Kate agreed softly.
"So...let's start new? Forget high school, I know we both want to do that anyway, but let's just pretend it never happened and this is our first time meeting. We went out, we had fun, we came back here, we...rolled around a little, and now I made you breakfast and you're being so rude as to let it get cold." I said smiling.
Finally Kate smiled, "Sorry...what'd you make?" she asked, finally starting to creep out of her sullen mood.
"Apple cinnamon pancakes and pesto eggs."
Kate sighed, "Ok we can pretend that we're starting new and everything, but you're not allowed to get me fat again. I worked too hard to get to this point and you making delicious breakfast would kill me."
"Well I wouldn't worry, cuz I don't want to be fat again either so whatever you eat, I eat, so if we get fat again, I'll take the blame for that."
"Good. Hand me that plate. I haven't had pancakes in like a year and those look amazing."
I handed Kate her plate and we both dug in, sitting side by side on her bed, both topless and only covered from the waist down by blankets. As we ate, I could feel my arousal start to build again as I snuck glances at Kate's naked chest. I hadn't even registered her nudity while we were working through the main issue of the morning, but now that things had settled, my eyes began to wander again. I tried to hide my erection as I knew this probably wasn't the moment to seduce her after she had just been so frustrated with the situation.
Kate finished her plate and set it on the nightstand before snuggling her head under my arm and onto my chest. Her fingertips traced patterns on my skin, tickling me softly, making my stomach clench and unclench at her soft teasing touch. I returned the favor by gently brushing her hair aside and tracing her collarbone and up her neck with my hand. A shiver ran down her body and she wriggled away from my touch, shrugging her shoulders up to protect her neck from my fingers. I chuckled and kissed the top of her head as she burrowed back in, her arm draped across my stomach and her breasts pressed against my side.
We sat there for what seemed like an hour, me playing with her beautiful long hair while she dozed off and on. Just when I was starting to doze off myself, the chirp of Kate's phone on the nightstand startled me awake. My quick jolt and the buzz of her phone woke Kate as well and she groggily rolled over to check who was texting her.
"Mmm...It's Alice." Kate groaned, "It's too early for that chipper bitch." she said as she rolled back over onto me and curled back into the covers.
"You do know it's like 11:00 right?"
"Shhhhh, don't tell me that, I'll feel like I need to get up."
Kate's phone chirped again.
"Ughh...she's not going to stop. FINE! I'm awake!" She protested to no one in particular as she rolled over to her phone again. "Well, looks like Wes didn't just walk Alice home last night."
"And you're surprised by that?" I asked. Clearly they hadn't been tired when they'd left the night before and I had had little doubt of where their night was leading.
"No, but she sent me a picture of the two of them lying in bed together. They look...energetic."
"Don't they always?"
"Yeah, I guess so. Should we send one back?"
"Haha, I don't know, how long of a phone conversation do you feel like having right now? Because I'd bet as soon as you send that, your phone is going to ring and she's going to be jabbering 10,000 questions in your ear."
"That's EXACTLY what would happen." Kate said emphatically. "How bout we just surprise them?"
"How so?"
"I'll ask if they want to go to brunch, make it seem like it's just me, and then we'll both show up."
"I like that idea. We can face the onslaught of questions together then. But didn't we just eat?"
"They don't know that. And I could go for a coffee and some fruit or something." Kate responded as she typed away on her phone. No sooner had she sent the text than a response chirped back. "Yup we're good for brunch. Wes is going to invite you too...if I'm ok with it." She smiled, looking over her shoulder at me.
"Haha, tell them I was a total asshole at the end of the night and you'd rather not see me right now."
"Hahaha! Oh man, the questions that will come from that!" She typed out the response and tossed her phone on the nightstand. "I need to shower. I'm a mess."
"You look fine by me." I commented
"Is that because I actually look fine or because I'm naked?"
"Both?" I said in my most convincing voice.
"Haha well I'm still showering and you have a half Mohawk thing going so you may want to fix that before the general public starts judging you."
"Oh...lovely" I said as I felt around my head and found half my hair sticking straight up. "Well you hop in the shower and I'll jump in when you're done if you don't mind."
"Actually...I kind of do mind. I mean, why would you make me pay for the water of 2 showers when I could just pay for one." she said enticingly, softly dragging her finger down my chest and looking up at me as she bit her lower lip.
"Well I didn't want to assume anything."
"You know what they say about assuming...a little you, a little me, and some ass is all you need." she replied as She grabbed my hand and dragged me out of bed towards her bathroom.
Kate was already completely naked and turned the water on while I stripped my boxer briefs off revealing my quickly growing erection. She turned around and pulled me to her with seduction in her eyes. We kissed and ran our hands up and down each other's bodies waiting on the old plumbing to finally deliver warm water.
Finally Kate began backpedaling towards the shower, never breaking our kiss. She opened the door and pulled me into the tiny 3 foot by 3 foot shower with her.
We spent our time between soaping each other down and teasing one another. Kate's hands took an inordinate amount of time soaping up my dick, while I took my sweet time running my hands over her breasts and down over her perfect ass. As she turned away from me to rinse herself off my hands ran down her sides to her hips, pulling them back into me where my now pulsing cock found a comfortable resting place between the cheeks of her ass.
"Mmm...Well hello there." Kate cooed.
"Sorry, it has a mind of its own and finds where it wants to go."
Kate smiled as the water cascaded over her face and her hands worked the soap out of her hair, "Oh, so it just wants to settle right in my ass huh?"
"Apparently that's the spot of choice this morning." I said, kissing her neck and reaching around to knead her tits and play with her nipples.
"Mmm, dirty boy. Never done that before but maybe later...my pussy is aching for you though." she moaned as She bent slightly at the waist and pushed her ass back into me. In the small confined space she had me pinned to the wall with nowhere to go as she began grinding her supple ass into my groin.
"Would you like to take this back to the bed?" I suggested, my hands on her hips moving with her grinding movements.
"Are you asking? Or telling? I took control last night, now it's your turn."
