Authors note: What follows is a work of fiction based on real life events. None of the characters depicted are real and any similarity to real people living or dead is purely coincidental.
Obviously enough this is Part 2 of my story A life unknown. Part 1 did not get as many reads as I would have liked partly I suspect because it was originally published under letters and transcripts. As always any editing errors are mine.
A Life Unknown (Part 2)
At the Cunard office in Boston I confirmed that a suite had been prepared for me at the Buckminster Hotel in the name of Lady Victoria Cameron and asked for my trunk to be sent on to the hotel in due course. I arrived at the hotel midmorning, deposited my valuables in the hotel safe, and after a bath and a soak I had a light lunch and then went for a walk.
I wanted to clear my head and I walked with no clear destination in mind but was happy to feel firm ground under my feet again. Eventually, after I had walked for about half an hour, I chanced across a huge, towered building. This was the Cathedral of The Holy Cross.
I entered on impulse and stood in the knave between the tall Gothic arches lining the interior. It was cool and peaceful inside and seemed so far away and unrelated to the events of the last years of my life.
Then I knelt and prayed for the souls of the dead. The souls of those that I knew. My Brothers, David and James; and Edward, the only man I had every loved. The souls of strangers, those who died on the Lusitania, and all those killed in the meatgrinder of war.
And for second time that day I cried.
When I left the church I was more resolved than ever over what needed to be done next and asked for directions to South Union Station which I was informed was just five minutes' walk away. There I booked a ticket on a train to New York leaving early the following morning.
That evening I arranged for a hairdresser to cut my hair in a Castle Bob hairstyle and dye it black and when she had finished I looked like a different person. This was precisely what I wanted.
Just a little after noon the following day, and after a five hour journey, the train pulled into Grand Central Station. I disembarked and made my way to the offices of the New York Times.
***
Once I reached the newspaper office I found the archives and asked if I could see old copies of the newspaper dated between the beginning of May to the beginning of June 1914. For a nominal fee, the custodian was happy to oblige, and a stack of back copies were fetched for me, and I sat at a desk and started to read.
After half an hour of reading I found what I what I was looking for. I had both expected and dreaded it. It was a story buried on page three of the 14
th
of May edition.
"BANKER SLAIN IN BRUTAL DOCKLAND KILLING.
The body of a thirty year old banker was found at New York Chelsea docks early yesterday morning. He has been identified as William Cosford. He was last seen alive the evening before when he attended a performance of Bizet's Carmen at The Metropolitan Opera House with a group of friends. He failed to return to his seat after the interval and was wearing his evening suit when he was found.
Mr Cosford had been badly beaten before he was shot and po[ice believe this may have been a revenge killing or a warning to persons or persons unknown. He had no gangland affiliation and no motive for this crime has been established."
My suspicions that George had had William killed had been growing since I had received the telegram threatening me with the same fate. The newspaper article simply confirmed what I had already come to accept as true. I knew that if George was ever to find me he would likely kill me. If he was willing to kill William because he slept with me he would not hesitate to do the same to me after I had stolen from him.
I was not willing to spend my life looking over my shoulder waiting for George or his agents to strike. That was why I had come back to America. I had two big advantages over George. He didn't know I had returned but I knew exactly where to find him and around my neck hanging on a gold chain was a key.
I had decided. I was going to kill George. My grounds were self-defence and justice although if I was caught I doubted the law would see it that way and I had no intention of going to the electric chair. I needed a plan, and a good one at that.
As I have said before, the simplest plans are often the best, and I planned to do it myself. I could enter the house at night with my key, and at night when he was sleeping, and shoot him. His butler and housekeeper who lived in their own cottage would be very unlikely to hear the shot. Then I would rob his safe
J continued to scan the newspapers dated the week following the 14
th
of May and then I found a follow up article dated a week later.
"NO LEADS IN DOCKLAND SLAYING.
One week after the unexplained killing of Mr William Cosford at New York Docks police are no longer close to finding the murderer(s). Captain Hans Baumgartner of the 44
th
Precinct in the Bronx has described this as an apparently motiveless crime.... "
I stopped reading. I realised that I knew the name Hans Baumgartner and I tried to remember where I had seen it. Then it came to me. A lieutenant of that name had been listed in the ledger I had seen in George's safe. I would never have remembered it if it hadn't been such an unusual name.
Hans Baumgartner was a dishonest cop and in the pay of George.
***
I was booked into the Waldorf Astoria and returned there in the mid afternoon and spent the rest of the day formulating my plans before retiring to bed early.
The following day was Wednesday and if George was behaving as he normally did he would be at home overnight. In the morning I visited a pawn shop and bought a derringer pistol and then bought a large leather carrying bag.
In the afternoon in order to appear "normal" and to distract myself from what I planned I visited Liberty Island and the Statue of Liberty. I was able to visit the halo but the stairs to the torch held in her right hand were shut following the damage done to the statue by the Black Tom explosion that had occurred the previous July.
On my return to the hotel I had an early supper and then slept until about eleven o'clock at night. I dressed put on my hat and gloves before slipping out of the hotel. It was a forty minute walk to George's House.
I passed the occasional person, but they took no notice of me and once a policeman walked by on the other side of the road. When I reached the house it was in darkness. Once I was sure that nobody was watching me I tried my key in the lock... and the door opened.
Once inside I stood still and listened. I could hear absolutely nothing. The house had electric lighting, but I did not want to wake George before I intended so I lit a candle I had brought with me and slowly and soundlessly ascended the stairs. I passed the door to my old bedroom and came to the door to George's bedroom.
The door was ajar, and I quickly snuffed the candle out and then stood and listened. I heard nothing and the house remained deathly still. By then I was convinced I had wasted my time. George was prone to snore when he had been drinking yet I could hear no sounds of breathing.
Nonetheless I had to be sure, so I took a deep breath opened the door, gun in hand, and switched on the light. On the far side of the room George lay motionless on his back in bed. I approached him cautiously and as I got closer I realised that he was not breathing because he was dead! In the middle of his forehead was a neat round bullet hole. Somebody had got to him before me.
My initial reaction was to turn and flee but then I regained my self-control. I removed a glove briefly and felt his skin. He was stone cold and must have been dead sometime and the killer long gone. I put my glove back, put my hand to his neck, and to my surprise discovered that his keys remained untouched.
I tore the keys from his neck, switched off the light, and by the light of a candle made my way to his study. Once there I opened the safe and retrieved the contents. This time I did not inspect what I was taking but quickly placed everything else into my carrying bag.
I left the safe and desk draw open, placed the keys on the desk, and left the house. It took me another forty minutes to walk back to the hotel and by one o'clock in the morning I was back in my bed.
***
The tension of the previous night must have exhausted me because I didn't wake until after nine o'clock. For a few moments I lay looking at the ceiling and wondered if it had all been a dream but then I looked across the room and my eyes focused on my bag. I had imagined none of it.
I was now in a quandary. My first instinct was to check out of the hotel straightaway and return to Boston on the next available train. I was almost certain that nobody had seen me enter or leave the house and my exit and return to the hotel had gone unnoticed. I had left nothing linked to me in the house. I had not killed George and technically what was in the safe belonged to me. I had been his wife after all. By now James or his wife would have discovered George's body and the open safe, and the police would have been called. They might be on the lookout at the station, and I had several items in my possession which would prompt questions to be asked if they were discovered, the house key and the contents of the bag.