A Case of Defamation
Romance Story

A Case of Defamation

by Sanitychec 18 min read 4.8 (4,100 views)
mystery gymnast olympian detective
🎧

Audio Narration

Audio not available
Audio narration not available for this story

NINETEEN

Shay had given up on trying to develop an excuse to get Dan's ex-partner, Neil, to talk to her. She couldn't fabricate a convincing story, and she had nothing to use as leverage. The fact was, she had nothing, not one damn thing, that would stand up in court. All she had were guesses and the testimony of an admitted liar. Given that Neil only owned the site someone used to contact Lindsey, there wasn't a shred of evidence connecting Neil to the rumors or Lindsey.

She decided she'd begin by trying to link Neil and Lindsey. If she could make that connection, that would give her something to use as a foundation in building evidence against Neil. The easiest way would be to go back to Lindsey and show her a picture of Neil, but by now Lindsey probably knew she'd been conned, and that bridge was almost certainly burned. She still had to try, and being unable to find a good picture of Neil online, Shay was using the time-honored technique of stalking him.

This morning, Dan had followed her to Hertz where she'd returned the rental and then taken her to the Toyota dealer. Now she was parked in her own car again, outside Squarepeg, well away from the door but where she had a clear line of sight while she waited for Neil to appear.

She picked up her phone and sent Dan a text, just to have something to do.

Bored

she typed and pressed send. She didn't expect an immediate answer, and didn't get one.

Dan's life was returning to normal. Mairead Cowan had taken him back as her trainer, though Greer Schoenmaker hadn't, at least not yet. Once she busted Neil for the rumors, maybe he'd even get Greer back. She thought it funny that the only two clients who had stood steadfast with Dan through his troubles was that nasty old coot, Greg Mills, and the former pornographer, Jason Orsini. She supposed she shouldn't be surprised, given their reputations, and she still didn't like Greg's attitude or Jason's profession, but she'd softened toward them considerably because of their support for Dan.

Squarepeg LLC was a small company operating out of a unit in a strip mall, and she sighed as she casually watched the door. Waiting for something to happen was the second worst part of her job, but at least it didn't make her want to cry.

To pass the time, she thought about the game she and Dan had played last night. She smiled in memory and began to moisten almost immediately. She'd read about the game in a magazine some time back, about how it was a good introduction to bondage because nobody was actually bound. She had no interest in bondage, but the article had popped into her mind when he was pulling his shirt over his head to join her in the tub. Seeing his muscular body pulled taunt, the sinews and muscles rippling under his skin as they were stretched tight, had instantly turned her on. She'd first noticed how him being stretched out excited her during their initial night together, during their second romp when he'd reached over his head to push against the headboard as she rode him, and she wanted to see more of it, to see him really straining at something as she fucked the shit out of him.

She hadn't been disappointed. She honestly thought he'd throw in the towel and let go before she could work herself up to a second orgasm, but the strength of his will had surprised her. Watching him strain against the hanger and his need, his muscles bulging and writhing, his face twisted in erotic pain as he fought his orgasm, had turned her on so much she'd come again even though she hadn't expected too. Her orgasm was a bonus, but having him break the hanger before giving up, along with his cries of defiance and pleasure, and then holding her tight while he bucked and jerked, muttering and whimpering into her shoulder, had been intoxicating. They'd snuggled a bit after that before he wrapped her warm and secure in his arms, and they'd tumbled into the darkness of sleep. They were fucking themselves to exhaustion, and it was wonderful.

As she dressed this morning, she'd taken another hanger like the one he'd broken the night before and tested its strength. She thought that if she put it on the floor and used her foot to hold it down while pulling up with all her strength, she might be able to break it, but it was a quality hanger, and she had no illusions of being able to break it with only her upper body strength. To do what he did, Dan had to be

incredibly

strong, but he was also gentle. Even when he was tossing her around in the bed, she never felt like she was in danger of being hurt. In fact, he manhandled her so easily, as if it wasn't any effort at all, she felt perfectly safe with him supporting her or throwing her around. Before that night, she hadn't realized she liked being gently dominated, but when she was in the mood for it, and Dan was the one dominating her, she did.

She leaned her head back against the seat. Thinking about him was getting her worked up, but they were going to have to take a break tonight. Even if she ended up spending the night with him, he was going to have to keep his cock out of her. Despite visiting a dojo once a week to keep her ju-jitsu skills sharp, she'd become out of shape in other ways, and now certain muscles and fleshy parts of her body that hadn't been getting regular workouts were sore. She smiled to herself. No matter. If she and Dan continued their relationship, she was certain he'd whip them into shape in no time... because this was an exercise regime she could get into.

She glanced at the clock on her phone. It was nearing five, and she'd been lying in wait for over six hours. Neil came in early, came in late, or didn't work in his office every day, because she hadn't seen him. It wasn't unusual for her to go two or three days without setting foot in her office, and maybe Neil was the same. She smiled slightly as she imagined someone stalking her like she was stalking Neil, sitting outside her office thinking,

Where the fuck is she?

or

Doesn't this bitch ever work?

She decided she was going to wait another thirty minutes, and if Neil hadn't appeared by then, she was going to give up for the day. She picked up her phone again and began to type a text to Dan.

Why don't you join me for dinner at my place tonight? 7:00? I'll cook. Bring clothes if you want to spend the night.

She pressed send. Another sixty seconds had passed as she typed. She tossed the phone back into the seat with a sigh.

She was almost praying for a junk email or a wrong number when her phone chimed. She picked it up and felt a little rush of excitement seeing a text was waiting. She opened the text and smiled.

How can you be bored? You're easily the most exciting woman I've ever met.

She started to reply, thrilled to have something to do and someone to talk to, when her phone chimed with the arrival of another text.

Love too. See you there.

She thought a moment and typed.

I'm only exciting because you make me that way.

Tosh! Last night wasn't my idea. I never knew a clothes hanger could be so damned sexy. See? You can make even clothes hangers exciting.

She giggled to herself in the empty car. Not only was Dan terrific in bed, a pleasure to look at, a masterful chef, and fun to talk to, he was also great for her ego. As she was thinking of a reply, the idea of cooking for Dan suddenly terrified her. She typically made easy to prepare dishes that made a lot, so there'd be leftovers, meaning she only had to cook two or three times a week. He'd likely turn his nose up at them as they were probably loaded with fat and calories. She glanced up to make sure Neil wasn't around before turning her attention back to her phone.

She didn't spend much time playing with her phone when surveilling someplace because it was a distraction that could cause her to miss the very thing she was looking for. She spent a couple of minutes looking for healthy recipes, but she was afraid she was spending too much time looking down, so she tossed the phone back into the passenger seat. She'd have to do it later, when she got home.

Shay was beginning to fidget, waffling between leaving and giving the surveillance another few minutes, when she saw a portly man stepping out of a BMW with a fast-food bag and a drink. He had the same general build as Neil, so she lifted her camera to use the long zoom lens for a better look. It was him. She snapped a couple pictures, but she really needed one that wasn't the side of his face, so she used the old standby. Using her elbow, she laid on the car horn while her hands were busy with the camera. Neil instinctively turned to look for the location of the sound. She snapped three nice ones of his face before pulling the camera down.

"Gotcha!" she muttered in victory.

Putting the camera aside, she pulled her computer from the backseat. The memory card came out of the camera, and three minutes later, she had Neil's face ready for Lindsey to see. Using her phone as a hotspot, she searched the internet and downloaded four pictures of random men who were similar in appearance to Neil. Task finished, she closed her computer and started the car. Now came the hard part.

Squarepeg and Lindsey's house were on opposites sides of the greater Los Angeles metroplex, and she spent over an hour driving from Burbank to Santa Ana. Shay didn't call Lindsey to tell her she was coming because she didn't want the woman dodging her. She'd start with Lindsey's work, and if she didn't find her there, she'd try her house.

It was just after six when Shay walked into the Lancer Inn, computer in hand, but instead of Lindsey, there was an older, massively overweight woman sitting behind the counter. "Welcome to the Lancer Inn, may I help you?" she asked with a welcoming, if false smile.

"I'm looking for Lindsey Rohmer. She here today?"

The woman's face pinched like she'd bitten into a lemon. "She no longer works here. You a reporter?"

"What happened?"

"You haven't heard? She tried to sue some guy for sexual assault, and it turned out to be a lie."

Shay shook her head. "I knew that, but why'd she lose her job?"

"Because there were news crews parked out front wanting to talk to her. It was scaring off the customers, so I fired her. You a reporter, a lawyer?" the woman asked again.

"No. Thank you for your time," Shay said before she turned to leave.

As Shay settled into her car she felt a little bad for Lindsey, but only a little. She'd brought this on herself.

Running late. Can we make dinner eight?

she typed before starting the car.

She drove to Lindsey's house, her phone dinging as she turned into the road that passed Lindsey's home. According to the DMV, Lindsey drove a 1999 bronze Toyota Corolla, and there was a battered little Corolla that some might call bronze sitting in the drive. Shay pulled to a stop in the street before picking up her phone.

Sure. Everything okay?

the message from Dan read.

Can't talk now, but all good. See you at eight,

she responded before stepping out of the car, her computer under her arm. She walked up the drive and rapped on the door. After a moment Lindsey opened it, her mouth dropping open in surprise.

"You!" she snarled. "You've got a lot of nerve coming here! Get lost before I call the cops!"

Lindsey started to shut the door, but Shay put her foot in the jamb. "Ms. Rohmer, I just need a minute of your time."

"Move your fucking foot or I'm calling the cops!"

"Don't you want to try to make this right?" Shay asked before removing her foot.

"Why the fuck do you care? You ruined my fucking life! I've lost my job because of you, and the television stations won't leave me alone. You lied to me!"

"Yes, I did," Shay admitted. "Don't you want to stick it to the man that started all this?" she asked, giving Lindsey a target for her wrath. "He's the one that put you in this situation," she suggested, even though it was total bullshit. Lindsey knew what she was doing when she agreed to try to set Dan up, but sometimes people couldn't admit they were wrong, so Shay was giving her someone to blame other than her.

"How?"

"May I come in?"

Lindsey glared at Shay for a moment, stepped back, and opened the door. Shay stepped in and handed her one of her business cards. She glanced at it and then stared at Shay.

"Daniel Beckette hired me to get to the bottom of the rumors. I've been working this case for almost two months, since before you came into the picture. I think the man that suckered you is the same man spreading the rumors."

"You mean the rumors aren't true, either?" Lindsey fell onto a chair with a sigh.

Shay shook her head. "I've talked to everyone I can find that works with, or knows, Mr. Beckette, and to a person, every one of them said he's an upstanding guy."

"Fuck," Lindsey muttered as she leaned her head against the back of the chair and closed her eyes. "I'm such a fuck-up."

"You want to try to make this right? Do the right thing and help me nail this bastard."

"I just want it all to end."

"This will help. If I can prove Neil Mitchell is behind all this, the media might go after him and forget about you. You'll become another victim in his scheme instead of the star." Shay was laying it on with a trowel, but she needed Lindsey's cooperation.

She looked at Shay with hopeful eyes. "What do you want me to do?"

"Look at some pictures."

"That's it?"

"That's it. After this I won't bother you anymore."

Lindsey heaved out a heavy sigh before she sat up. "Let me see."

Shay crouched before shoving aside some magazines and glasses to make a spot for her computer on the table in front of the chair, and opened it. When it was ready, she opened the photo viewer.

"Tell me if any of these men are the man that hired you."

"No," Lindsey said on the first guy. Shay changed the picture to the second. "No." The third picture appeared. "That's him."

"You sure?" Shay asked.

"Positive."

"Look at these last two to be sure."

"No," Lindsey said when the fourth photo appeared on the screen.

"Last one," Shay said as she clicked on the arrow for the next photo.

"No," Lindsey said. "The third guy, that was him, I'm sure of it."

Shay smiled as she straightened. Lindsey had nailed Neil the first time. "Will you testify to that in court?"

Lindsey shook her head. "No. I don't want any more trouble. I just want my life back. I've done what you asked. I looked at your pictures, now just go."

"Will you agree to a deposition, at least?"

Again, Lindsey shook her head. "I don't want any more trouble," she repeated.

Shay pursed her lips in annoyance. Lindsey had confirmed Shay was on the right track, and if Daniel sued, his legal team could compel her to testify, but that was dangerous. She could retract her statement and leave them twisting in the wind. Shay had to find another way, but at least Lindsey confirmed Shay was onto something.

"Fine. You have my card. If you change your mind, call me."

"I won't."

No, you probably won't,

Shay thought to herself as she snapped her laptop closed and picked the device up. "Thank you for your time, Ms. Rohmer. I can see myself out."

Shay drove home, thinking over her options. Assuming Lindsey didn't chicken out and change her story, they had enough to nail Neil for coercion. She didn't know what Neil was after, but he was clearly angling for something, and it started with ruining Dan's name. She didn't know the game, and she didn't know if Lindsey was the second move, or was simply an extension of the rumors. If the rumors weren't having the desired effect, maybe Neil was upping the pressure, but it could also be that the rumors had been to set up the playing field for Lindsey's move.

The sexual assault case brought by Lindsey didn't feel right as the end game, not if Neil told her she could keep whatever she won. If he'd wanted her to split the winnings with him, maybe, but not like this. There was more to the story than she knew, but she'd certainly screwed up Neil's plans by knocking Lindsey's story down so quickly. By the time she'd reached home, she'd convinced herself that Lindsey was the second act of a multiact play. She was going to recommend to Dan that she keep digging because she didn't believe this was over, and a payout to Lindsey wasn't the end goal.

After parking her car, she hurried into her house and quickly changed out of her suit into something more comfortable... jeans and a less formal blouse. It was already almost seven forty-five, and she was running out of time to prepare dinner. She dug in her fridge and came up with hamburger and a pork loin. She decided on pork because she was afraid Daniel would have a heart attack over a hamburger.

Ten minutes of flipping through recipes on the internet uncovered many delicious, low calorie, dishes, but the only one she had the ingredients on hand for was Orange-Teriyaki Pork Medallions. She was going to have to do a little substituting for ingredients, packaged orange juice instead of fresh squeezed, for example, but she could make it work.

She was putting two boil-in-the-bag brown rice packages into the water when her doorbell buzzed. She gave the pork one more quick stir, wiped her hands, and hurried to the door, her face breaking into an involuntary smile as she did.

.

.

.

TWENTY

Shay was standing there in jeans and a pastel green, short-sleeved, blouse as her door opened.

"Come in," she said, stepping back and opening the door wider.

The thing that caught Dan's eye were the leather laces across the wide gap in the shirt, from the middle of her breasts to the neck. The laces crisscrossed back and forth, like on boots, but appeared to be doing nothing to hold the gap closed... which was fine by him.

"Hey," he said as he stepped in. As she closed the door, she offered a kiss, and he placed his hand behind her back to gently pull her lips into a slow caress with his.

She sighed. "I needed that," she said as their lips slowly parted.

"So did I."

"Dinner will be ready in about ten minutes."

"Something smells wonderful. What is it?" he asked as he followed her into the kitchen.

"Orange and Teriyaki Pork." He tossed his clothes on her bed and then returned to her small kitchen. "You do eat pork, right?" she asked as he appeared.

He smiled at the slightly panicked look on her face as he hung back to stay out of the way. Her kitchen was barely big enough for one to work in, much less two.

"Sometimes. Find anything out?"

"Lindsey positively identified Neil."

"So we've got him?"

"For coercion, maybe. But I think there is more to this yet."

"Like what?"

"I don't know. But you heard Lindsey. He told her she could keep whatever she won. That means it wasn't about the money, not for Neil anyway. So, if he isn't after money, it has to be about something else. Something we don't know."

"Does it matter?"

"I think it does, for a couple of reasons. One, Lindsey isn't willing to testify if you sue him, so that really cripples any chance of that going anywhere. Second, even if you win, you still haven't addressed the rumors. There is nothing connecting him to those, and the Lindsey story is already dead. Reputation wise, you're simply beating a dead horse. So, even if the rumors end up withering and dying, and you sue him over Lindsey, what's to prevent him from coming at you again? Think about it, there is no limit to the number of things he can start rumors on. Drug and alcohol abuse, mental illness, AIDs, theft of intellectual property, you name it. We need to link him to the rumors and shut him down permanently. That way, if he tries this shit again, people will know it's more of the same."

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like