Note to the Reader: Not too long ago, after an unfortunate misunderstanding in a certain drinking establishment known as Eddie's Bar, I had reason to be detained at the Amherst, MA police department, which happens to be almost directly across the street from the Emily Dickinson Homestead and Museum. While gazing from the window of the police station toward the Homestead, a thought suddenly came to me: what if they got it all wrong about Emily Dickinson? Two things about her seem indisputable: she was a great American poet, and as a person she was extremely shy and reclusive. There's no doubting she was a great poet, but suppose her personality and lifestyle were not as portrayed? What might her life have really looked like? Here's my take on that. IMPORTANT: This is a work of fiction, in case you suddenly feel the need to begin making changes to her Wikipedia page. My apologies to the other famous authors referred to as well. (Subnote: All charges against me were subsequently dropped, though I've been ordered to steer clear of Eddie's watering hole in the future.)
-------
News item combining several wire service reports
A recent discovery has the literary world all a-flutter and nearly beside itself. What had long been rumored but thought to be so preposterous by most experts to ever be taken seriously, has now been shown to be true. Hearsay claimed for years that Emily Dickinson (1830-86), the highly-regarded, painfully shy and reclusive, and almost certainly virginal poet from Amherst, Massachusetts, was not as reclusive as thought -- and definitely not a virgin. A packet of letters has been found, all written by Dickinson to various acclaimed literary figures, that indicates the poet had not only travelled extensively, but was quite active sexually. These letters paint the poet in a completely different light than what everyone had assumed. It also alters significantly the perspectives people had of the famous authors she wrote to.
The packet was found buried in a wall in a house that was being demolished outside of Amherst, a house that was believed to belong to one of the several men who visited her at her home, affectionately referred to by her as her "tutors."
"Tutors, indeed," chortled one scholar upon hearing the news. "More like her boy toys."
It seems that Dickinson carried on a correspondence with many famous writers, from William Makepeace Thackeray and Charles Dickens among others in England to Herman Melville, Walt Whitman, Louisa May Alcott, and several others in America. What makes these letters such a revealing find is how openly sexual matters were discussed by Dickinson. No replies from these several authors have ever come to light; it is thought Dickinson or someone else destroyed them years ago.
"That, of course, is a real shame," commented another scholar. "It is fascinating, for instance, to see Emily lamenting the fact that only once had she been involved in a foursome with the Bronte sisters and how gratifying it was, but not to have the Brontes' take on that is truly a pity. Also, according to Dickinson, after engaging in a threesome with Mark Twain and Bret Harte, it was Harte who was better at eating pussy. Did Twain ever admit to that or even comment on it in a subsequent letter? We'll likely never know. It didn't change his opinion of Harte as a writer, however; 'he's still a hack,' insisted Twain several times in public statements."
Investigators also discovered tucked within some of the letters poems Dickinson had written, hitherto unknown. These too are quite different from her usual visionary and idiosyncratic poems, not so much in style but certainly in subject matter. Scholars will be examining these works deciding how, perhaps even whether, to include them in her oeuvre.
Experts are still trying to piece together how the packet was assembled and who managed it. Was Dickinson still alive when it occurred? Was she the one able to gather together these previously sent letters of hers? Also, why the letters were compiled into a single bundle which then ended up hidden in a wall remains a mystery, though some have already begun to speculate.
After seeing their contents, one avenue of speculation seems obvious: she was thinking about the future and how it would judge her. Fewer than a dozen of her poems were published during her lifetime, though over 1700 additional ones were found by her sister after her death. Did she imagine, hope even, that eventually her poems would come to light and be praised? Would she come to be seen as a brilliant poet? The scandalous contents of these letters would certainly have damaged her reputation, maybe irreparably so.
Which only leads to further questions: why didn't she destroy them herself? How did they end up in that wall?
Literary detectives will be pursuing these lines of inquiry for a long time to come. In the meantime, it's the sexual escapades, the secrets revealed, the shocking opinions expressed that will fascinate everyone else. Like the battle between the ironclads Monitor and Merrimack during the Civil War making every other navy in the world obsolete, these letters might make every biography of all the people involved, if not obsolete, at least seriously incomplete.
Following are samples and excerpts from these letters:
*
To William Makepeace Thackeray:
Dear Mr. Thackeray --
I am an 18-year-old girl living in Amherst, Mass. across the ocean from you and I just read your latest novel
Vanity Fair
and that Becky Sharp is just one unbelievably wonderful character, full of all kinds of fantastic schemes to get ahead in this cruel world. She takes my breath away, I must declare. You subtitle it "A Novel without a Hero," but, truly, sir, how could you be so blind as to not recognize Becky in that role? I hope to be just like her.
Of course you discreetly refrain from saying so, but I just know if Becky had given Jos Sedley even half as good a blowjob as I've been giving my brother Austin who lives next door, she would have won him over. I love the way she can get men to do just about anything and all the sexual encounters she must engage in. I hope someday I can get men to ogle me and get all hot until they don't know up from down, like Becky does at the card games so Rawdon can cheat and win. In addition to turning myself into someone just like Becky, I also am striving to become a poet. I wrote a poem about her that I'm including in this letter that I hope you like.
From a true "Lover" of your work,
Emily Dickinson
Poem:
Eyes so crystal clear --
Steady on the Prize --
What... I hear
Hope eternal flies!
A half-opened door --
To flare wide I know not when --
I deserve more!
Not be fucked o'er again.
*
To Henry David Thoreau:
My Dear Henry,
I see you finally came to your senses and quit living in that awful hovel at Walden Pond you insisted on calling home. All of Concord was laughing their rear ends off at you. Enough with that "Simplify, simplify" horseshit, someone should have slapped you a few times, if I was there I would have done it myself. Even that bean-field you had, I hear the girls you took in there to fuck were never keen about it -- too scraggily and filthy. Though I got it from my good friend Louisa Alcott that some of the girls rather liked all those beans and whatnot poking them in various places while you ravished them, including Louisa herself. Come visit me here at Amherst, I could show you a wonderful section of Atkin's Woods a few miles north that will have you rock hard and salivating in seconds. It is lovely, pristine, dark, mysterious, and the ideal place to rip our clothes off and cavort to our heart's content. Here is a little poem I wrote to whet your appetite.
Naturally yours,
Emily
Poem: