Our first attempt at anal was both painful to her and disappointing to me. We were both drunk and in a moment of passion, I suggested it and she said OK. Unenlightened and unprepared, I just tried to barge on in, even after she cried out in pain I kept going as I thought once I was in her it would be all right. The worst thing that happened was that it scared my girlfriend into thinking anal was something she didn't want to try again. I have to admit I wasn't happy about her decision but I understood her feelings and let it go.
Although I respected her wishes as we made love I kept noticing that when I touched her around her anus I could tell it turned her on. Finally, one time after making love as we nestled together I asked her if it felt good when I toyed with her backside. She told me it felt erotic when I touched her back there and I began to rub her ass cheeks slowly getting closer to her crack. When I put my fingers between her cheeks, she pushed out to allow me access to her anus. I just teased her as I lightly tapped her little rose bud. We were now fully aroused again and made passionate love as we normally did.
The next day I stopped by the drug store and purchased some grape seed massage oil. By the time my girl friend was home, I had candles burning in the bedroom and a bottle of wine opened and breathing. I told her I wanted to try anal again but I wanted to do it right this time. I made sure she understood we would only proceed at a speed she was comfortable with and only if it was painless. I assured her we would take as much time as she needed and that we were in no hurry. She was still apprehensive and only after I promised her that I would not even attempt it that night did she began to relax. She told me she was concerned about her hygiene 'Back there,' as she put it so I suggested we take a shower together to wash our backsides. The shower was fun and after she soaped up and rinsed her anus, I offered to stick my tongue in her for a test. Only after my assurance that it was something I wanted to do did she allow me to tongue her. Her response of my tongue fucking was extremely erotic and as I tongued her she played with her clit until she exploded in orgasm. We turned off the shower, dried each other and went back to the bedroom
I began by giving her bum a thorough massage with the grape seed oil. Each time I slid my hand between her cheeks she would sigh. I next began to play with her sphincter, at first just a rubbing motion as I applied pressure with my finger. I could tell this was turning her on so I introduced my fingertip inside her. Between her heightened awareness and my lubed finger, it slipped in easily to my first knuckle. At first, she froze as she realized I was now inside her so I stopped and with my fingertip still inside her I rubbed her bum and stroked hips with my free hand. I asked if she wanted me to stop but she told me no and that it felt sexy. As I began just to wiggle that first knuckle inside, she began to push back against me, clearly wanting more. As soon as I had my whole finger inside her, I rubbed the walls of her rectum gently. She screamed as she had her first anal orgasm. I was too excited to wait any longer so I turned her over and we had normal vaginal sex. She came once again with me inside her.