This short story is part of a longer story I hope to write someday. I just wrote it, and so it might have a few mistakes, but I hope you all can forgive me.
And yes, although the story is written from a first person male perspective, I was that girl once, but had never dared to ask.
To me this is the road not taken.
And oh, all fictional characters in this story are of course over 18...
E.L.
*****
"Dad?"
As I looked up from my football game, I knew something was wrong. Simply by the way Lina looked at me, the way she stood in her soft pink silk pajamas, one foot behind the other and her arms tightly clamped behind her back, she seemed almost hesitant to step forward.
"Yes honey? What is it?"
"I have... a problem... and I... kinda need your help."
The emphasis she put on the word need struck me most, as if desperation pushed her to do something she didn't really want to do.
"You know you only have to ask. What can I help you with?"
As her hands came into sight, I saw she held one of her slippers, and looking down I noted she was barefoot.
"I need you... to hit me with this."
"What?" I replied, really having been caught off guard, but apparently she misunderstood my intention as she quickly stepped in and kneeled before me feet. Holding out the slipper for me to take as if it was a holy relic, quite confused I took it.
"I need you to spank me, dad. I have been bad, and I don't know a way out anymore."
"Well first of all, stand up so we can sit down and talk about this."
She shook her head fervently.
"No. I need this, and I need it to be this way. It's... complicated."
Now when Lina used the word complicated I always knew the origin of the problem lay in her past, so I took a wild guess.
"It's your father, isn't it?"
She nodded silently, her head bowed as if she couldn't even look at me.
"Look. We discussed this. I know he used to beat you two, and I told you long ago that I would never do that, to either of you. I am not that kind of man."
"But I need it!"
Again this word need with such emphasis of desperate desire.
"Then first tell me why you need it."
"I... have been bad."
"So you told me. What is it that you think was bad, bad enough to ask me to punish you for it?"
"I have... been with boys."
"Well, you're nineteen, I would think it's only natural."
"No, you don't understand. I have been with boys."
"Oh."
"Several boys."
"Oh."
"A lot of boys."
"Oh. Right. Erm. I don't quite know what to say about that really. Have you... been safe? I mean, condoms and such?"
"Yes, always. I'm not a moron. But lately is has been getting out of hand and... I am scared."
"Alright, but I still don't see a need to be punished over it. You have a sexual appetite, apparently a large appetite, and you are just experimenting with... things."
"No. You don't understand. I am scared of what I long for. It might not... be safe."
"Right. Erm... such as?"
"Bondage," she breathed almost inaudibly.
"And pain... punishment..."
"But punishment for what?"
"For being bad. For being... broken."
"Oh. Right. Well maybe instead of doing... those things, you might just need to talk to someone. A psychologist maybe."
Again she shook her head as the words came flooding from her lips.
"The school has one, and I talked to her, or at least I tried to, but she doesn't get it. She doesn't get me as she cannot relate to who I am, where I came from. I cannot trust anyone with this, not with this. No one but you."
"Well, ehh... I..."
"Please dad," she now looked up at me as she was clearly close to crying.
"Please. I need this. Please."
"Well... alright then, if I can help. How do you suppose we do this?"
As she got up, she quickly moved over to the dining table and stretched out over it, gripping the other edge with her hands as a hand-hold, her toes now barely touching the ground. Either she had thought out things quite thoroughly, or she had secretly tried out the position when no one was around.
"Like this."
"Anddd where do you suggest I hit you with your slipper?"
"My ass, please. My... bare ass."
"Right. So. Erm."
Noticing my embarrassment, she looked back from her position on the table and gave me a little smile.
"It's OK dad. Really. I won't tell anyone about this."
"Well I won't either, so it will be our secret then."