Casey was having a quiet day off at his apartment. Content to just sit around and play strategy games all day, he sat staring at a map on his computer. Blackout curtains kept the sunlight at bay, while his room was dimly lit by a lava lamp and a scented candle.
He was enjoying his vampiric day off when he heard a knock at the door. This caught him off guard since he wasn't expecting company. Wondering if he had gotten a package, he went to answer the door and was surprised to find that it was his girlfriend along with Astrid. Ash sometimes stopped by his place after work, but she'd gotten increasingly bold and had started a habit of showing up unannounced. Astrid sometimes accompanied her since they worked at the same welding place, but this was the first time she'd tagged along without warning.
Although Casey was always happy to see her, he did feel a little embarrassed. Since it was a lazy day off for him, he was wearing little more than an oversized shirt, underwear, and thigh-highs.
"Oh, uh...hey." He said, squinting in the light of the setting sun. "Decided to swing by after work, huh?"
"Yep! I knew you had today off, so I figured why not? Astrid wanted to come too, so here she is."
"Sup."
"Okay, well, come in. You guys weren't interrupting anything, I was just playing that strategy game you don't care for."
"You mean the map game?" Ash asked, walking in with her friend. "How's that going?"
"It's going good, though I faced some setbacks today. France attacked me and now Japan and the Aztecs have decided to join in."
"Remind me again, what country were you playing as this time?" Ash asked, plopping down on the couch.
"Albania."
"Wack."
Just before he sat down, Casey thought of something. "You two want any drinks? I could make some coffee or tea or something."
"Coffee's good!" The two almost spoke simultaneously.
"Cool." Finger-gunning the surprise guests, he went to brew a pot.
Once all three of them had a cup, they sat together on the couch to talk some more as they sipped their fragrant beverages. Casey sat down next to Ash, then Astrid sat on his other side. He felt sandwiched between them since they were both taller and more muscular than he was. Ash rested her arm around him, absentmindedly brushing his shoulder and playing with his hair.
"So, Casey, haven't seen you since we went to the mall." Astrid said, taking another sip of the black coffee. "I guess you two went home together after that?"
"Yeah, we went back to my place and she wound up spending the night here." Casey answered. "It was nice, I'm always happy to have her here!"
She gave them a non-judgmental but knowing look. "Slept together, huh?"
He averted his eyes out of embarrassment. "Well, that's not..."
"Yeah, we did." Ash answered bluntly, before sipping her coffee.
"You didn't have to tell her!" He cried.
Astrid just let out a hearty laugh. "It's normal for couples to sleep together, nothing to be embarrassed about!"
He released a sigh. "Well...I guess we've done it several times by now so..."
"On our first date, I fucked him real good, and since then I've tied him up, pegged him, the works." She threw up a peace sign. "I think it's fair to say I've won in life."
"Ash, I swear to god." He rubbed his temple.
"Shit, did I go a little far with my teasing, babe? Sorry."
"No, it's fine. I just feel a little awkward bringing this stuff up with others, but if she's comfortable with it, it's okay to talk about." He let a heavy sigh. "I guess I'm just too easily flustered."
"I'll keep that in mind." She gave him a peck on the cheek.
"Sorry if it made you uncomfortable, just thought I'd ask. Because I'm going to be honest," she leaned back against the couch cushions. "I've been feeling bored and horny lately, so when I see you two together, it makes me feel weird. I don't want to overstep boundaries, but all I'll say is, if you two ever feel like bringing in another person to spice things up, I'd be down for it."
"The way you look at him sometimes, I was wondering." Ash said. "You did always enjoy a good threesome."
"So you two do that sort of thing together?" Casey asked, looking back and forth between the two women.
"Oh, I guess I never told you." Ash said. "Yeah, we've been friends with benefits for a while now. We've fucked, and tag-teamed some girls before, though she's never done that with a man. Oh, but don't worry, we haven't done anything like that since I started dating you." She scratched the back of her head sheepishly. "Wasn't sure if you'd be okay with it, y'know?"
Their being friends with benefits was a little surprising, but what threw him off more was the thought of two women, who as near as he could tell were both doms, fucking each other. In his mind, he imagined it was like two hyena matriarchs fighting for dominance.
While thoughts of dueling doms whirled in Casey's mind, Astrid drank some more of her coffee before continuing her proposal. "Anyway, I'm mostly just throwing the idea out there since Ash and I have done this kind of thing before. It's up to both of you really, I'd hate to butt in where I'm not welcome."
Ash looked at Casey. "Since you don't know her as well, I'll defer to you. I'd be okay with it, but I won't go through with it unless you feel comfortable."
"Uhm..." he was a little hesitant, but he couldn't deny being curious. He gave Astrid another look and the idea of both her and Ash ganging up on him in bed flashed in his mind. The thought made his heart beat faster. "That's fine. Though I'm not sure I feel like doing that tonight."
"That's cool, we'll have to set up a time. When's your next day off?"
"Friday."