On the Descent of the Catholic Church into Corruption, Degradation, and Sin: A Cautionary Tale
Fraulein Susanne von Rauschenberg was admitted as a novice to the Abbey of Saint Hildegard in the southeast corner of the duchy of Brandenburg in October of 1523. She had told her father that she had been called to the monastic life by God himself. The honorable Herr Christoph von Rauschenberg, a devout Christian who had been burdened with too many daughters, had been only too happy to offer her dowry money to church and be rid of the task of marrying his middle daughter off. On the eve of her 20th birthday, he took Susanne to the convent in a carriage, where he left her in the hands of the formidable Abbess, Mother Maria Anne.
In truth, what had called Susanne to the monastic life was not so ephemeral as the mystical whispering of God in her ear. She had been drawn to this particular abbey by the sensual pleasures of its music and architecture. The sisters of the abbey were famous for their choir, which performed the masterworks of composers the likes of Josquin, Ockegehm, and Palestrina. Susanne had the good fortune of attending services at the abbey on occasion. Sitting in the pews, the sounds of the choir subsuming and consuming her, Susanne had looked up at the vaulted ceilings of the Gothic chapel and resolved to give herself wholeheartedly to the ecstasy of this worship. It was an embodied piety. Susanne felt it course through her veins, tensing her muscles and quickening her breath.
The sisters of Saint Hildegard had long been criticized for their weakness for the beauty of material things. It was a comparatively wealthy abbey, and its members occupied themselves primarily with aesthetic tasks: singing, embroidering, and illustrating manuscripts. Martin Luther himself, the protestant fugitive with a growing army of discontents, had condemned the abbey. What blatant evidence of the decadence of the Catholic church, he had proclaimed, that its female devotees lust so after beauty, worshipping their embroidery as if it were God himself!
Susanne, however, had never read Luther's pamphlets, which these days circulated through the province of Brandenburg like wildfire. She had never been taught to read. In her world, God was the painted walls of the abbey chapel, the nuns with their fresh faces and graceful wimpled bodies, and the heavenly sounds of their worship. God was the paintings of fantastical scenes that adorned the chapel walls and the delightfully wretched plight of martyrs they depicted. It was to these things that Susanne resolved to dedicate herself. She was to be wedded to God, to submit herself to the ecstatic and excruciating pleasures of His embrace.
And so she now found herself in the entrance hall of the Saint Hildegard monastery, face to face with Abbess Maria Anne, her head bowed, awaiting instructions on how to begin to integrate herself into her new vocation as a sister of the monastery. The abbess was a tall woman of around forty with a pale, aristocratic face. Susanne thought she looked like she should be in a painting; every inch of her seemed positioned exactly where it should be. She smiled at Susanne, surveying her body with the possessiveness of a woman used to being in charge of her own world. And indeed, Susanne was to learn, Maria Anne was the undisputed ruler of the small world that flourished within the convent's grounds.
"Your father has written to me that you received a call to commit yourself to the life of the monastery," she said. "Did the Lord come to you in your bed at night and whisper sweet things in your ear?"
Susanne detected the unmistakable edge of sarcasm in the abbess's voice and was unsure how to respond. "I...I don't think so," she said.
"Tell me, why are you really here?" The Abbess directed a penetrating stare in Susanne's direction.
Susanne resolved to tell the truth. "Well, I've heard your singing, and I thought it was so beautiful, and the abbey was so beautiful..."
Maria Anne smiled. "Our life seems a pleasurable one to you, doesn't it?"
"Yes"
"For some, it certainly is. You will stay here for one month and accustom yourself to the life of the monastery, after which you will decide whether you really want to stay with us. Do you understand?"
"Yes"
"You will address me with 'yes, ma'am.' We live a disciplined life here, Susanne. It is not all singing and embroidery, as our critics might suggest."
"Yes, ma'am."
"You may follow me to the chapel. Evensong is about to begin."
"Yes, ma'am," Susanne repeated. Maria Anne walked from the entrance hall of the abbey through the cloisters and into the chapel. Susanne followed a few steps behind her, intimidated by the abbess's imposing command over her surroundings. She entered the chapel with the abbess through a side door at the front and walked silently toward the back pew. Her attempt to make herself go unnoticed failed spectacularly. The twelve nuns of the chapel sat in the front rows in identical black and white wimples. Susanne still wore the green brocade gown she had worn on the way to the abbey, her long hair tied in a bun, her jewelry glimmering ridiculously on her bosom. She took her seat behind the nuns and bowed her head in prayer, attempting to ignore the stares that were directed at her.
The sisters in the front row opened their books of sheet music and began to sing the evening prayers. The sound reverberated throughout the chapel, bouncing off of its stone walls and soothing Susanne's worries. Susanne looked up at the the curve of the chapel's gothic ceiling beams, guiding her eyes upward toward the infinite expanse of the heavens. Yes, she thought, this would be a good life. She would gladly live with the discipline the abbess required of her for the privilege of this view.
***
Maria Anne observed the convent's new recruit with interest. She seemed on all counts to be an excellent fit for the abbey-eager, obedient, hungry to learn. The obvious joys she took in the pleasures of the abbey's aesthetics were promising. She would be taught to read and sing like the sisters of the abbey, and her talents would surely blossom under their tutelage.
Susanne was young. Not as young as many girls were when they first entered convents as novices, certainly, but there was a freshness about her that made her seem younger than her years. Her wide eyes and doll's face were appealing in their innocence. The abbess enjoyed young ladies. She enjoyed the smoothness of their skin, their openness to new experiences, the malleability of their character. Yes, Susanne could be molded into a very pleasing devotee to the ways of the convent.
Had Susanne guessed, the abbess wondered, the convent's secret? Maria Anne knew that scandal travelled faster than lighting these days with the printing presses. Did this eager young recruit know what this particular abbey was infamous for? She decided to let Susanne discover for herself, if she had not already guessed, the unusual character of the nuns' worship.
***