Sheila and I had been secret lovers for several months, stealing glances at church and Bible study until we could be alone in her house a few times a week. No one suspected that the pastor's wife was getting off with a woman from the congregation. We knew what we were doing was wrong, but our relationship made us each feel whole, so we justified our affair as a way to for her to be happy in her marriage. And it made it more tolerable for me to be living at home with my parents again in my conservative hometown.
We were both caught up in the bliss of our newfound relationship that nothing seemed like it could go wrong. Until Mike came home unexpectedly one day and everything changed.
We didn't hear him come in the front door and he caught us completely off guard. I was naked and cuffed to the headboard, my legs spread wide open with Sheila's fingers buried in my pussy, her mouth on my clit. I was moaning in pleasure, feeling the warmth of her mouth on my most sensitive parts, when we were startled by a loud yell.
"Sheila! What the hell is this?" Mike roared.
My eyes flew open and I looked towards the doorway where Mike stood staring at us, his face contorted in rage. Sheila sat up quickly on her knees, but didn't look at Mike. She stared down at the covers of the bed and looked terrified. Her lips and chin glistened with my juices.
Mike looked at us for a moment, collecting his thoughts, then said quietly "Sheila, get the belt."
I saw Sheila's lip tremble and remembered her telling me about the time he hit her after catching her masturbating. I could only imagine how much worse this punishment would be. I didn't want to see her get hurt and I didn't want her to associate our time together with the pain that was to come. I watched her slide off the bed and disappear into the walk-in closet.
I looked back at Mike who was looking at me spread out on the bed. I must have had a look of panic on my face and my chest was heaving from my near climax and now my fear for Sheila. I couldn't get up due to the cuffs holding me to the bed. I looked down at my body and realized my legs were still wide open, my aroused, swollen labia clearly visible. I quickly brought my legs together in embarrassment. When I looked at Mike again, I noticed something else in his face beneath the rage. His mouth was set in a sinister grin. It was then that I noticed the bulge in his pants and realized he was aroused.
Sheila returned with a brown leather belt. It was wider than was fashionable and looked faded and worn. "Mike, please," I began to plead on Sheila's behalf, but he cut me off.
"You will call me Reverend! I am a man of God and you would do well to remember that before you commit obscenities in my house."
"Yes, Reverend. I'm sorry, Reverend. But please don't punish Sheila. It's my fault. I tempted her. Punish me instead."
Mike considered this for a moment. He looked at Sheila and asked "Is what Miss Ingram says true? Was this her doing?"
Sheila looked down at the ground and didn't answer. "Sheila," I said quietly. She looked at me. "Let me take the punishment. You don't deserve it." The look in my eyes told her that I wanted this. And she knew enough to realize then that I wasn't just doing this to protect her. She realized that I really wanted to be punished by her dominant husband.
"Yes, it was her idea, Reverend. She tempted me," Sheila said quietly to Mike.
He had a grim, determined look on his face, but I could he was just as aroused as ever. Sheila handed him the belt. He looked at me on the bed and instructed Sheila to unhook my right hand and attach it to the same bed post as my left. Once my hands were shackled to the same post, he told me to turn over. I complied, trying not to seem too eager. I could almost feel the leather slapping against my skin and my pussy started to throb in anticipation.
"Put the pillows under her," Mike commanded. Sheila took two bed pillows and placed them under my pelvis to position me for punishment. I was stretched out diagonally across the bed, my ass propped up in the air.
"You have defiled my wife, Miss Ingram and I will not stand for that. But worse, you have committed an abomination before God. You must be punished appropriately."
He rolled his sleeves up. "Now tell me what you are," he commanded.
"I'm a sinner, Reverend."
"You are worse than a common sinner. You are an adulterer and a whore! You are a harlot!"
"I am. I am a harlot," I repeated.
"I am going to punish you for your own good. Satan is working through you and needs to be driven out."
"Yes, Reverend. Drive the devil out. I want to be saved." I said these words, wishing he would get to the punishment already. I didn't believe any of it. I wasn't worried about eternal damnation. I knew deceiving Sheila's husband was unethical, but I didn't really think our actions were such an atrocity.