Author's Note:
This story is complete fantasy. Any resemblance to people, living or dead, companies or inventions is purely accidental.
The story will make more sense if chapters 1 to 6 are read first.
**********
Jenny was still drowsy and a little cold when she woke on Sunday morning. She realised she was alone in bed, lying on her back with her arms outstretched. Shifting weight on the mattress indicated to her that Peter had returned. She moved her right arm to make room for him but found it was stuck. Thinking the arm had gone to sleep, Jenny tried to rub it with her left hand; but that arm wouldn't move either. Now she was fully awake and on the edge of panic.
"Peter! Help me! I can't move my arms."
Peter put a hand on her shoulder to calm her:
"It's OK, Jenny, you're safe. I've tied you up..."
"Oh, no!" said Jenny, "Why?"
"Don't you remember? You are due a punishment from yesterday."
He spread her unresisting legs and fixed her ankles into their straps, holding her spread-eagle.
"Oh, God, Master. I hoped you were just teasing me."
Peter was adding tension to the restraints, though she felt the stretch as more sensuous than painful.
"No, I am completely serious. ... Slave, tell me how I normally punish you."
"Master, you tell me how I have erred and what my punishment will be. I apologise and you forgive me. Then you inflict the punishment as a reminder."
"Do the reminders work, Slave."
"... Not often, Master; except that they remind me how much I like you punishing me."
"Exactly! Well, one thing you did yesterday was so contrary to the essence of our relationship that I must find a new way of punishing you: one I hope you will abide by in the future."
Jenny was genuinely worried now and completely stumped as to what she had done. She thought she had been exceptionally good all day, even obeying Peter in something they agreed he would no longer demand from her.
"Master, I am sorry. Please forgive me."
"Not yet, Slave," said Peter, blindfolding her. "Your opportunity to apologise will come later. For now, I will explain how your punishment will work."
"This is a new game I have devised. I will not tell you its rules: you must discover them. I will use the cat-o-nine-tails on you. You may ask questions. The game ends when you have told me the rules of the punishment game, what you did wrong and you have apologised for it."
"If you put that brilliant brain of yours to good use, Slave, you can minimize the punishment and, I hope, remember the lesson. ... Do you have anything to say before we begin?"
"No, Master."
"Then we will start now."
Jenny forced herself to think clearly, saying to herself:
=== I suppose I can leave working out the rules of the game for now because I have no information to go on. Best discover what I did that was so serious. But if it was so serious, why did Peter not correct me immediately: why wait until the next day? Maybe it was because David and Sam were there; but then why not afterwards? What did he call it? Something like "contrary to the spirit of our relationship." What kind of thing did I do that was contr... ===
Whack. Peter whipped the 'cat' over Jenny's taut stomach.
"Ouch!" Jenny cried, more from shock than pain. The tips of the 'cat' stung only a little. She waited anxiously for another strike but there was no repeat blow, so she went back to trying to work out what she had done wrong, thinking:
=== It would help to know what I did wrong if I knew when I had done it. The hypothesis is that it occurred when David and Sam were here, so what happened during that time? They arrived, we chatted, had drinks, dinner, argument over the project and then the punishment session for Sam. I resisted when Peter told me to strip but that was before he had ordered me. I complied when he made it an order. Besides, I had a good reason to fear for my sore bottom. Maybe ... ===
Jenny was whacked on her right thigh.
"Ouch!"
=== I've really got to get better at this. I'm getting nowhere and Peter is whacking me. Maybe I should try to discover what the rules are. ===
"Master, why are you whacking me?"
Peter did not answer but he said "One."
=== Oh, God. What is he counting for? ===
"Do I have a limited number of questions I can ask?"
"No," Peter replied and whacked a stinging blow on her left thigh.
"Ouch!"
"Two."
=== Two? I'll ignore the numbers and get back to thinking about what I did wrong. I am sure it was to do with the bondage session but I need to eliminate the other times. It might be because I woke him up yesterday morning... ===
"Master, am I being punished for waking you up yesterday morning?"
"No."
Whack, "Ouch!"
"Three."
=== That's good, anyway. OK. I need to find out when it happened. ===
"Master, will you tell me when I committed the error?"
"No."
Whack, "Ouch!"
"Four."
=== I understand. That means I have to work it out for myself. ===
"I think it was something I did when Samantha and David were here, Master."
Peter did not respond.
"Five."
=== The counting goes on without the whipping but it seems that Peter does not reply unless I ask a yes-no question. ===
"Master, was it something I did when Samantha and David were here?"
"Yes ... Six." There was no stroke from the 'cat'.
"Master, was it before or after dinner?"
"Yes ... Seven." There was no stroke from the 'cat'.
=== What a stupid question! Logically the answer is "Yes" and I've learned nothing: so much for my brilliant mind. Come on, Jenny! get thinking. It's curious, for instance, that there was no whacking for the last two questions. ===
"Master, was it before dinner?"
"No."
Peter gave two swipes to her stomach. Whack, "Ouch!" Whack, "Ouch!"
"Eight."
=== Two whacks! Why? To make up for one of those he let me off earlier, perhaps? God! Jenny, stop speculating and get some data. These strikes are beginning to hurt. ===
Jenny's thighs and belly were now a bright pink, going red in places. Her cries were getting louder as the whipping stung more.
"Master, was it after dinner?"
"Yes ... Nine." There were no strokes from the 'cat'.
=== So what happened after dinner? Peter lent me to David and we had our session. I resisted him giving me to David: it might have been that. What else? I nearly lost to David. Would Peter punish me for that? Would that be a significant breach of our rules? What happened after the session? I went to comfort Sam, then David and Sam left. Oh, God! I called him a "stupid man." Oh, no! How could I have done that? How could I have been so stupid. It was the excitement, the bondage, the stimula...===
Whack, "Ouch!" Whack, "Ouch!"
Peter hit Jenny's upper arms.
=== I think I have learned a rule, at last, though I wish I didn't have to be beaten to learn it. I get whacked if I am silent too long. ===
"Master, was it because I called you a 'stupid man'?"
"No."
Whack, "Ouch!" Whack, "Ouch!"
Jenny's upper arms were going as red as her thighs and stomach.
"Ten."
=== I was sure that was it but I am glad it wasn't. I should narrow down the time some more... ===
"Master, was it when you lent me to David?"
"Yes. ... Eleven." No strokes of the 'cat'.
=== I can guess another rule: he whacks me only when he answers 'No'. Now what could I have done when I was lent to David? I did not follow him immediately; but Peter had not officially given me to him. Best eliminate that possibility, anyway. ===
"Master, was it because I did not go immediately with David?"
"No."
Peter delivered three whacks to her stomach and each thigh, receiving three loud yelps from Jenny.