"Wow, I can't believe that you would do something like that to me! Actions like that are going to require severe punishment to make sure you never even think of doing something like that again. The only question right now is what you deserve.
She cowered at his anger. She didn't dare look at his face. She kept her head down, eyes focused on the floor. She really regretted having looked at his computer files and especially getting caught. The information was so amazing that she just couldn't look away. She knew there would be hell to pay if he caught her but she didn't expect him to walk in on her like that. He thought for a few minutes. The silence was deafening. Finally he spoke.
"There's no doubt about it. You need to be disciplined for actions like that - severely. I'm going to make this a little more interesting though. Right now I'm thinking of a half dozen pretty severe punishments that fit the crime. I'm going to write them each down on a slip of paper and place them all in a box. You will determine what you will get by selecting one of those papers. Give me a couple minutes. I'll even put a relatively easy one in for you to give you a sporting chance. Go get me a box about this big."
Angela bit her lip as she watched him scratch out his ideas on the notepad. She searched the office and found a small cardboard box about six inches cubed on top of a waste basket. The locked computer's screen saver glared in her face. If only it had been timed out before. Angela brought the box to her Master.
"Just hold it for me," he told her as he continued writing.
She held the box with both hands as she waited. She was concerned about the volume of information that he wrote without needing much time to pause and think. He finished one, tore it from the pad, smiled and then crumpled up the slip and tossed it into the box. It took him nearly fifteen minutes to fill out seven sheets of punishments. She had no idea what kinds of things he was imagining but that same sinister grin came across his face several times. He had mentioned "severe" Angela's flight instinct suggested that she should run but she knew that it would not only be futile but result in more punishment. She nervously rubbed her intertwined fingers together as she fidgeted, shifting her weight from one foot to the other.
"Okay, we're ready to let you determine what I shall do with you. I have high expectations that you will make a fine slave. By punishing you right away I hope to ward off any future behavior of this kind. I'll hold the box while you select one of the slips of paper. I want you to take it and read it aloud to me. Choose your poison," he told her as he extended his arm toward her with the box held just above her eyes.
Angela's hand was shaking as she raised her arm to choose one of the slips of crumpled paper. Some were crumpled tighter than others and she wondered if that was any indication of the severity. She finally chose one that was lightly wadded and opened it. She was afraid to look.
"Read it to me. I want to know what one we're going to do, "he remarked coldly.
"It says...it says, um...that I must submit to...um...twenty-five lashes with the single tail whip." She shuddered as she spoke the words.
"Oh, that's a nasty one, Jack remarked in a shockingly casual manner. Leaves lots of scars and hurts like hell for a long time as well. You might pass out before I whip you that many times too. Well, you chose it. I will tell you that you could have done worse but then again there were others that maybe weren't as bad. Wad that piece of paper up again and toss t back in the box. We'll keep this box of punishments in case the need should arise again."
"Please Sir," she pleaded as she quickly crumpled the paper back into a ball and placed it back in the box.
I have another idea, he said with a sadistically excited expression on his face. Do you want to draw again? The risk would be drawing something even worse and there would be no going back...or you might get the easy one I put in the box...or you might draw the same one again. The gamble is up to you. Otherwise we'll go to the whipping post to get this over in a little while."
Visibly trembling and chewing on her nails, Angela thought about the offer. She wasn't feeling particularly lucky and she had no idea of the kinds of things that were written on the other slips of paper - But oh, the single tail whip!
"I am going to give you a few minutes more. I have something else that needs attention right now," Jack said. "I'll give you until I get back to make up your mind. It should be within about half an hour. You will tell be your choice then."
He abruptly walked away, taking the box with him. Angela was so anxious that she couldn't think. If only she had someone to help her with this decision. One thing was for sure, if she did nothing she was going to be whipped in a little while.
The sudden crack of a whip directly behind her in the room made Angela flinch. She turned around to see him standing in the doorway, grinning ear to ear. He tossed the whip onto the floor beside her. The tail was much longer than she imagined and it looked very frightening. He laughed as he walked away again. She didn't even want to touch it although the intricately woven leather handle fascinated her as she studied it for a while. Finally she picked up the tail to see what the end felt like in her hands. It was flexible yet hard.
"I see that you're interested in the whip, Angela. Do you think you'd like to feel it?"
"Um...No Sir" she replied.
"Then you've decided to draw again?
"I think so," she stammered having not reached that conclusion until being put on the spot.
"I'll need a yes or no on that question, dear."
"Yes Sir," she stated more firmly.
"Okay, I'll go get the box. You wait right here," he ordered as he left the room again and quickly returned with her options still in the box. "You understand that the whip punishment goes away unless you re-draw it and you get whatever you select next?
"Yes Sir," she said, nodding her head to reiterate her decision
"Geeze, I almost wish I hadn't put some of those horrible things in there, He said. "I feel kind of sorry for you but you did a very bad thing and need to be punished. So now is the moment of truth. Please choose your punishment."
He held the box out toward her again. She looked at it then back at him. His face was solemn and showed no emotion. She raised her trembling right hand into the box. She stirred the crumpled slips of paper, trying to identify the one she had just put back and stalling for time. At last she took hold of one that was more tightly wadded and pulled it out. Turning away from him she spread it out against the wall to read her fate. She placed her forehead against the wall and stood silently.
"Read it please," he demanded.
"It says that you will let me go free this one time, she replied.
He had to laugh. "We both know that wasn't a choice," he said calmly. "Nice try though."
"It says that you're going to cane me - twelve strokes," she read from the paper.
"Still pretty harsh but I'd say you got off a little better with that one," he assessed. "Congratulations. I think you'll recover better from that punishment. Twelve should be enough to leave some marks but not break your skin. I will even let you select the cane to be used from what we have here. Let's take a walk together."
She just stood with her head against the wall and crumpled the paper back into a tight ball. She was not very familiar with the concept of caning either. She knew that it was used in some Asian countries as punishment for common crimes but didn't know what that many stokes would do to her. She didn't want to think about it.
"Come on," he repeated as he headed for the door.
She reluctantly followed as he walked as a brisk pace out the door and toward a shed out in the yard. He opened the door to the shed and pulled out a 5-gallon bucket full of sticks that appeared to be about two and a half feet long. The diameters and lengths varied a bit. She noticed that the bucket contained water as well.