This chapter is part of a continuing story. Although some chapters may stand on their own, for proper character development and story line intensity, this series is a continuous story and should be read as such.
It was a snug fit, but that plug had to come out. I wanted to fuck that tight ass, and to do that, the plug had to come out. So, that was the next item on my agenda...remove the butt plug. And, because it was such a snug-fitting thing, I was going to need some help.
It's like when someone has on some tight boots and they need help getting them off. This was similar, but more care was needed. More care and maybe a good scream silencing gag. It wasn't easy getting that thing to go in, but James got it in. And, because of the way those tapered plugs are made, the large part would be the first part to come out. It was much easier to push in, because of the cone shape. Something told me James didn't think that far ahead.
Lucy and James were ready to help and then Rita snapped out of her after orgasm trance, so she could help, too. The slut was just standing there, still naked and tied. The gag was still in her mouth but James removed the purple dong. He said something about it being in the way, because of its size.
I had Lucy and Rita hold the two sides of the spreader bar to steady the slut. And, James grabbed hold of her waist, to be the resistance to my pulling. I got behind the slut, and did my best to grab hold of the butt plug. I wiggled it around, and that got the reaction I didn't want. It made the slut moan, and she tightened up her ass around the plug.
I needed her to relax, so I could pull the thing out. "OK, slut, relax your ass, or it's really gonna hurt coming out. You can trust me on that."
Lucy giggled when she heard me. "And, why are you warning her it's gonna hurt?"
"Why is it always a woman who thinks last about the other woman's pain? She's my fuck toy, and I want her asshole to be just as fuckable tomorrow as it was an hour ago. You don't feel it with that strap-on you wear, but my cock feels it. And the tighter the fit, the more I enjoy it. I don't think I need to say anything more, do I?"
Lucy stuck her tongue out at me, and put her hands on her hips. "OK, then, let's see you get it out of her. I'm betting it's gonna hurt."
I bet it's gonna hurt, too, but if she can relax her ass, it will hurt less."
"We've been hurting her all night. What's a little more pain gonna hurt?"
"I enjoy inflicting pain, Lucy, but not when it can harm the person. I don't want to rip her asshole. We need her to relax, so I can get this thing out."
Typical Lucy. Thinking of her own pleasure before someone else's. She just lowered her head and nearly whispered her answer. "OK."
Come to think of it, that's the typical Rita, too. And, there's nothing wrong with that, as long as I'm there to control 'em. Some of their self-serving tendencies can be fun. And, those self-serving ways really come out, when they're in Domme mode. I like that.
So, once Lucy had taken her place, everyone was ready to go. Lucy and Rita on the sides and James was holding the slut around the waist. I started stroking the slut's clit and pussy, to get her to relax. It really wasn't that easy. She'd been our pain slut all evening, in one way or another. I think she was just waiting for the other shoe to drop, because I'm always giving pleasure before dishing out the pain.
I had an idea. I told everyone to step aside, but to be ready to move back into position, quickly. I bent over her, and reached around so I could finger her clit with my left hand. The first time I touched it, her legs nearly gave out. It was very sensitive, but that didn't stop me. I hunched against her ass, pushing the butt plug in with my body. That, and my rubbing her clit, was getting her attention.
With my right hand, I started pinching her nipples, first one, then the other. She was responding in exactly the way I wanted. I could feel that she was breathing heavy. Her body twitched, as my fingers probed her pussy. I started grinding against her ass, hunching that dildo as much as I could. The slut loved the attention. She was getting close to cumming.
I wrapped both hands around her waist and pulled her back against me. I heard her whimper from behind the gag. I was starting to enjoy it, too. My cock was getting hard and I'm sure she could feel it against her ass cheeks.
The ever-impatient Rita just couldn't stand it. "So, are you just gonna make love to the bitch, or are we pulling the plug out of her ass?"
"I'm helping her relax. Just hang on for a second. Your fun time is coming."
Like a couple of kids, that Lucy and Rita. Always wanting to play and they don't want to share their toys. Well, this toy was mine, so I was making the rules. We would share, but because she was mine, I didn't want her harmed. If it's damaged, there's a period of down time when I'd be without. A tight submissive asshole is a thing of beauty, I tell ya'. It must be taken care of!
I continued my quest of helping the toy relax. What I was really doing was helping her focus her thoughts on another part of her female body, and maybe that would cause her asshole to relax. But, that was difficult because she was such an ass slut. And, the butt plug wasn't made to conceal.