I am standing on his doorstep in the rain, my clothes soaked through, my long chestnut hair matted against my face, trying to work up the courage to knock.
I had met James at a bar three nights earlier. I spotted him as soon as I walked in: tall, slim, intense brown eyes, mischievous smile. Wearing a dark suit, for some reason, in this otherwise very casual pub. He was standing alone, sipping his amber-colored drink, but he seemed utterly at home as he scoped out his surroundings. Maybe it was that comfort in his own skin that kept drawing my eye, even as I tried to focus on my friend Clara's voice.
"I mean, I think it's just time to call it a day and quit," Clara was saying. She knocked back the remainder of her whiskey and gestured to the waiter for another. "I've hated it there for a long time, but this was really the last strawβJenny, are you listening to me?"
I snapped back to attention. "I'm sorry, I just got distracted for a second there..."
"I can see that." Clara smirked, sucking an ice cube out of her empty glass and swirling it around her mouth as her eyes darted between me and him. "He's hot," she assessed, staring openly in his direction in a way that made my cheeks flush scarlet. "And he's on his way over here."
I stared as her wide-eyed, feeling the hot flush creep to my ears and my chest. Clara laughed playfully as she observed my reaction. "Relax, Jen. Take a drink."
Before I could follow her advice, he was there at our table, smiling widely β but somehow not quite warmly β at us both. "I saw you two staring at me and thought I should say hello," he said. From up close, I realized that he was likely older than me β around 40 or so to my 29.
At the same time, Clara and I both responded. "I hardly think we were staring at you," she said, and I couldn't quite tell if her voice is flirtatious or annoyed. Maybe a bit of both. I took another tack. "I'm sorry," I blurted out, feeling silly immediately. What was I apologizing for? I was often on the quieter side, granted, but cocky barflies were hardly my style, and this kind of forwardness had never worked on me in the past. Not that I'd had so much experience. Clara was always the beautiful one, with blond waves and blue eyes and soft golden skin. I am sweet-faced and plain β not unattractive, but not striking either. While we had been approached by men often in this bar during our weekly catch-ups, they tended to gravitate towards her, with me taking up the role of reluctant wing-woman. Clara would dispatch with them quickly, often getting their numbers before they left, and then we would confer about whether she should call them or not. I would write off the slick, over-confident ones immediately, and she would laugh at my predictability. Now, though, she was watching me closely. I was staring intently at the table, so I couldn't see her face, but I knew she was wondering what I saw in tonight's tableside wooer.
"You're forgiven," he said to me, ignoring Clara's remark altogether. I looked up, into his mysterious, dark eyes. "James," he said, holding out his hand.
"Jenny," I replied, taking it. His touch was electric.
"A pleasure." He paused to sip his drink, his eyes still boring into me. He seemed to consider whether to continue, then set down his glass, took out his wallet, and handed me a card. "I'd like to see more of you, Jenny. Tonight, if possible. My address is on here. I think each of us might be what the other needs." As I reached for the card, he grabbed my wrist with more force than I was expecting, enough to make me jump just a little. "Come after 10," he said.
Clara snorted, but neither of us turned to her. I opened my mouth, but I couldn't think of a single thing to say. James released my wrist, smiled and nodded in Clara's direction, and walked away.
"What is up with you?" Clara asked as soon as he was out of earshot. "Are you into him? THAT guy? He has creep written all over him."
I smiled at her weakly. "Yeah, right?" I said, but I surreptitiously slipped his card into my purse when the waiter brought her second whiskey.
I didn't go to James's house that night. But for the next three days I thought about him almost constantly β all day at my cubical, all night as I tossed and turned in bed, replaying the feeling of his fingers wrapped tightly around my wrist. That part in particular I couldn't get out of my head β the way he had controlled me for that split second. The way I had given myself over to it, kept my hand steady so that Clara wouldn't notice. The flicker of acknowledgment in his eyes that told me he knew exactly what I was doing, maybe even better than I did. The growl of his voice when he ordered "Come after 10."
That's how I kept thinking of that last part: as an order. Something that I had disobeyed, and that I was somehow perpetually disobeying with every passing moment. That should have seemed strange, like an impertinent demand made by a stranger and rightfully ignored by me. That's how Clara saw it β she had forgotten about him seconds after he left the table, and was back onto her story about quitting her job as if nothing had happened. But I couldn't conceal from myself, no matter how uncomfortable it made me, that I wanted to obey.
That night, when I'd gotten home, I had dug out his card and Googled him immediately. James Spencer. Defense attorney. The most recent articles were about his work with the Innocence Project, retrying cases for wrongly convicted death row inmates. There were pictures of him standing next to grateful clients, and candid shots of him at charity events. "At least he's not a psychopath," I told myself, though my own argument didn't sound particularly convincing to my ears. And there was something striking about those photos. His smile in them was amiable, personable, and his eyes were intelligent and determined. But the intensity of that night at the bar β that was missing. Or maybe it was hiding.
On the third day after our meeting, I broke. I was sitting at my desk, inputting details about equipment orders, and I suddenly felt like if I didn't call him, I would burn up. Just spontaneously combust in my seat. Or scream. Or both, simultaneously. I grabbed my purse and rushed to the rarely-used supply closet for a bit of privacy. Before I could wonder whether I was making the right decision, I heard his voice on the other end.
"Hello?"
"Hi....J-james?"
"Yes? Who is this?" Like his photos, his voice was a little softer than I remembered. But my breath still caught in my throat.
"This is Jenny. From the bar?"
"Jenny." I could tell he was pleased, and it thrilled me so much that I actually steadied myself against the racks of printer paper and envelopes. Then, in a tone closer to the one I remembered from the bar: "You didn't follow my instructions on Friday."
"No. I-I'm sorry." Apologizing again.
"You're forgiven." Again, I felt like an electric pulse travels through me. What was happening to me? "You can make it up to me by joining me for dinner tonight. 7:00." He paused for me to answer, but I couldn't. I was afraid of what seemed to be happening to me, and I couldn't bring myself to agree to it, whatever "it" was. And yet, I also couldn't hang up the phone. Seconds passed, but they felt like hours. Finally, he simply said, "Don't be late," and hung up. I was left panting in the utility closet, realizing to my utter humiliation that I could feel a new, unmistakable slickness between my legs as I made my way back to my desk.