Her Choice

The stranger stayed the night. The next morning, all three of us were in the shower room together. I enjoyed watching the stranger's petite body next to Adele's bigger, more shapely frame. The stranger's almost flat chest really made Adele's lovely, cone-shaped small breasts stand out. I could see countless interesting details in both of their bodies, details that were best visible in a comparison like this. Their bodies really complemented each other. It was time to bring the two closer again, in a humiliating yet arousing way.

"Get on the floor, legs spread, ass up," I commanded Adele, who then got down obediently. I took my hands to her buttocks, spread them forcefully and continued, looking at the stranger,

"Just look at this sweet asshole Adele has. It's like a small star, now all clean and shaven. And it feels wonderful around my cock, too. Now, tell me, have you ever licked anyone's ass or had yours licked?"

The stranger looked baffled, bit her lip and mumbled "What? No."

"Now's a good time to try something new, then. Get your face between Adele's buttocks and give her some tongue."

"But, I don't... I'm not sure I can," the stranger stuttered.

"Get over here now, or get out. It's not that hard. You're only going to get punished by hesitating like that."

The stranger looked puzzled and didn't seem to have the willpower to make a choice quick enough, so I decided to help her out. I lightly grabbed her by the hair, led her behind Adele and shoved her face between Adele's buttocks. That was actually the first time I had touched her.

"Now lick, with proper enthusiasm, or we'll go on from were we left off yesterday. That is, were going to tie you up and try a number of sharp, stinging instruments on your pussy, covering every centimeter from your clit, all the way down to your asshole, with deep red welts," I threatened.

This did the trick. Hesitantly, the stranger closed her eyes, pushed out her tongue and slowly brought it on Adele's beautiful anus. To make sure she really understood what I meant, I removed my belt from my pants and reminded,

"Lick her properly, show Adele how you love her hole, or else we'll start your punishment with this belt, right now."

The stranger seemed to get over her initial disgust pretty well. She tongued Adele's asshole much like she had licked her pussy the previous day, working it intensely. Adele seemed to be enjoying this and shortly she asked, panting, "May I touch myself?"

"Yes, go ahead," I answered. "The both of you should have your fingers work your clit while doing something like this."

The stranger, too, took her hand between her legs, still licking moaning Adele's anus obediently. I let her go on for a good while, making sure her tongue got a decent workout. I then fetched a small bottle of lube, handed it to the stranger, and said:

"That's enough licking for now, but I'm sure you'll get the opportunity to bury your tongue in Adele's ass again. Her ass can really take a lot and I want you to try it out for yourself. Lube her nice and well and see, how many fingers you can get inside her."

The stranger started by coating her index finger with a bit of lube and slowly inserting it. Adele didn't react openly, but she soon started masturbating again, obviously not very opposed to all this - yet.

"Stop playing around! Put some more lube and push more fingers in. Her ass can easily fit your whole hand. You can, actually, try that too. Use force if you need to, she's used to that," I insisted.

Adele gave me a nasty look, but soon turned her head back down. The stranger had three fingers in, and it seemed her movements already caused Adele occasional discomfort. Adele yelped loudly when a fourth finger was added.

"That's it. Push them in, don't be too gentle," I commented.

The stranger seemed to get excited over this. She was now pushing with all her five fingers, trying different angles and finger positions, adding more lube to get past Adele's tight sphincter. Adele yelped and even shouted, whenever the stranger added more force to her endeavor.

"Aaagh, please, not so rough! Oww."

I went to the pile of clothes on the adjacent bench and pulled out a pair of the stranger's panties. They were small and white, showing a good dried up patch of her juices in the center. I handed them to the stranger and said: "Gag Adele with these, she's making unwanted noise."

Adele looked disgusted but obediently opened her mouth when the stranger proceeded to shove her dirty panties inside.

"Now, go on stretching her ass."

The stranger brought her fingers back to Adele's much-dilated hole and was soon trying to fit all five of them in her, showing very little hesitation or concern over Adele's muffled shouts. This anal abuse went on for some time, and at best she managed to get just about past her knuckles, to which Adele responded by screaming really loudly. It was time to change the roles again.

"Great, that's enough for now," I commented to the stranger. "It's time to give your ass something, too. Tell me, have you ever been assfucked?"

The stranger suddenly looked scared and answered, "No... For me, it's, you know, very sensitive. Even a finger's bad." She must have realized the irony of the situation.

"Would you let us punish your ass, or teach you to love getting your sensitive hole pounded?"

"I, well... . Please, be gentle, if you have to... do that," she answered pleadingly.

"Good. Get down on the floor, just like Adele is. Adele, get up and go get the enema bag - and take those panties from your mouth."

Adele, looking somewhat hurt and angry from the previous abuse, left to get the equipment. The stranger got down on her knees, bent over and now her beautiful, wrinkly anus was nicely displayed above her white-haired, perfect pussy. Adele soon came back with the enema gear and I filled the bag with warmish water.

"Adele, give her the enema. Just put the nozzle in, hang up the bag and let the water out with full pressure."

Adele, still looking angry, quickly hung the bag and shoved the small, plastic nozzle in forcefully, which made the stranger yelp. Adele opened the nozzle and soon the stranger was squirming and moaning, apparently not enjoying the sensation. I waited until the bag was empty and then said:

"Stand up, facing us, and don't even think of letting a single drop escape. If you do, you'll get another enema, twice the size, and we'll cane your asshole the whole time you're holding it in."

I then continued: "Let's get to know you better. Now, you've never been fucked in the ass. Have you ever had sex with multiple partners at the same time, or sex with a woman?"

"No, not before this."

"Have you ever been sexually punished before?"

"No."

"Have you ever been pissed on?"

"What? No, never."

She looked a bit distressed upon hearing this question, but I couldn't tell whether it was just caused by the enema she was clearly having trouble holding in.

"Have you ever been sexually controlled or humiliated?"

She was silent for a moment, pondering the question and then answered "Well, not like this."

"What do you mean by that? Tell us."

"Well, I was once forced to show myself and to let myself be, well, touched."

"Tell me more, in detail, and then you can go out to relieve yourself."

"I had left a room door partially open and, uhm, a certain person walked by, seeing me masturbating on the bed. He managed to get a picture and blackmailed me. I was really scared he'd show the picture to certain other people, and I believed he'd delete the image if I did what he asked me to," the stranger recounted, blankly, looking past us.

"What did he ask you to do?"

"Well, he let me choose between giving him a blowjob, letting him, uhm, penetrate me or allowing him to touch me and to look at my body, while he masturbated."

She was obviously having a hard time holding the water in, and she squirmed continuously while answering me.

"And you chose the last one? Tell me what he did and, if I'm satisified with your answer, you can go let that water out."

"He fondled my breasts roughly, constantly pinching my nipples, and made me spread my legs really wide, right in front of his face. He pulled on my nether lips to get an unblocked view and kept poking me there. He even fingered my butt hole, all the while masturbating. He also made me take different positions, like getting on all fours to see me from behind, making dirty comments throughout. In the end he had me kneel in front of him, while he came on my face."

I was surprised by the amount of detail she chose to include, and I couldn't really make out how she had perceived the situation, since she told all this rather bluntly. The story, or her interpretation of the situation, didn't, however, feel worth pursuing further at that moment, since I wanted to go on with her punishment.

"That's good enough. You may go out now."

The stranger rushed out like a flash after I had finished the sentence. I walked behind Adele, took my fingers on her pussy and started to rub her clit. I then took my other hand between her buttocks, lightly rubbed her anus, and asked: "Does your ass hurt?"

"Yes, it hurts," she answered.

"What do you think we should do to her? Should we hurt her ass?"

"Yes. I want it to hurt, too. And I want her to lick me when her ass gets fucked. I want you to give it to her. Rough and hard."

I was more than surprised to hear this from Adele.

"You want me to fuck her ass when she gets back?"

"Yes," she answered, assertively, "I want you to do it rough, without foreplay or any extra touching. A bit of lube, maybe, and straight in. And I want to have her lick me while you do it."

Even though having Adele tell me what to do felt a bit strange, I had asked for her opinion - and I couldn't have agreed more with her proposition. I kept fingering her while we waited for the stranger. After a number of minutes she entered the room, and stood by the door, looking both humiliated and expectant.

"It's time to give you a new experience," I started. "Your ass is going to be fucked, and since it's your first time, I'm going to give it to you properly. Would you like me to fuck your ass?"

She sounded nervous, and stuttered "Well, if you want to... I, I can take it."

"You'll have to ask for it more nicely," I stated.

"Uhm, please. Please... fuck my ass," the stranger blurted.

"Good enough, for now. Don't worry, you don't have to take it all alone, since you'll have Adele's pussy on your face the whole time. And you're going to lick it, and any other place she decides to offer you."

A low table next to the wall seemed like a suitable place, so I told Adele to lie on the table on her back, legs spread. I then picked up the bottle of lube, looked at the stranger and said,

"You can probably guess what to do next. Bend down, ass up and legs spread wide. Put your face between Adele's legs and don't stop licking. You may moan and shout if it hurts, we have no problem in listening to it, but don't make it too loud."

The stranger hesitated for a moment but soon crept slowly into position, raising her slim, beautiful butt and spreading her legs to reveal her soon-to-be abused hole. Adele took her head between her hands, mumbled something I couldn't really make out and pulled her face to her pussy. I took some lube on my thumb and smeared it on and around her pretty anus. I then put some lube on my rock hard cock, positioned it on her hole and without saying a word gave it a hard, straight push.

"Ooowwaaggh, goddammit it's hard oww!"

My dick slid into her surprisingly quickly, past her tight, resisting muscles. I just held it in her warm, tight ass for a moment, while she squirmed and instinctively tried to pull herself further from me. I then grabbed her by her small hips and started to fuck her, slowly and deeply. She was making noise on each thrust.

"Oww, it hurts, aagh..."

Her moaning in pain was pretty much constant, although it was effectively muffled by Adele pushing her face toward her crotch. I kept penetrating her slowly to make sure I wouldn't come too soon; her ass gripped me magnificently and I was, of course, enormously turned on by all this. I didn't want it getting too monotonous either, so I pulled out a couple of times, letting her muscles contract, holding her cheeks open to see her ass pulse. Her small, wrinkly anus looked a lot nastier now, all dilated.

"Since it's your first time, you're gonna get it good. It will hurt, but try to enjoy the pain you're submitted to," I commented, right before pushing my cock back in.

I picked up more pace and really started to pound her, hard and mercilessly. She screamed and squirmed for a while, but soon calmed down, and I could hear her sobbing between Adele's legs. Adele, on the other hand, seemed to be really enjoying this. She had already come at least once, but that had not stopped her from keeping the stranger's mouth in place just as vigorously.

I was really on the verge of coming, and felt I couldn't prolong this much longer so I asked,

"Should I come in her ass or on her face?"

Adele, panting heavily, commented "On her face, come right on her face!"

I gave her a few hard thrusts, pulled out and said: "Turn around, kneel in front of me."

She turned, and now the stranger's sweaty, cunt-juiced face and her tear-filled eyes were in front of my cock. Adele also got up to see this, working her hand between her legs. I didn't have to stroke my dick for more than a few seconds before I exploded right on her face.

"You may now masturbate, provided you clean the cum off your face. Scoop it up with your fingers, right into your mouth," I suggested, after catching my breath.

The stranger kept her eyes closed, sat down on the edge of the low table she had previously bent on, and started to finger her clit furiously. She then started running her finger on her face, gathering sperm, and then licking that finger clean.

Adele, smiling serenely after her orgasm, crept behind the stranger, took her hand away from her clit and replaced it with her own. She even kissed her neck a couple of times, while she fingered her to a much-awaited climax.