Pete knew he was in trouble. Though he really did not know Samantha all that well, what he did know of her left no doubt being caught jerking off in her panties would entail some kind of punishment. His past indiscretion against her brought on a stormy night visit filled with humiliation, spanking, and a thrashing hand job. He knew enough of her to know she was capable of just about anything.
"I - I - I'm so sorry Samantha. I thought you were..."
"Rebecca?" Samantha interrupted him. "Looking at you now I can only assume you two have made up and made out, am I right?" she asked with a cheshire grin as she watched Pete fumble taking off her underwear.
"Um, y-yes, please, I really am sorry for this," Pete replied blushing heavily, covering himself, and unsure whether to hand Samantha back her underwear or return it to the drawer he snatched it from.
Samantha grabbed her panties and returned them to the drawer herself. Pete just stood there anxious and naked wondering what she was going to do to him. There was a sudden coolness to her demeanor and yet that grin lie beneath the surface leading Pete to imagine some wicked concoction brewing in her head. She asked him to dress if he liked, but to have a seat in the small lounge area of the dorm room. Pete scrambled to put on his blue boxer briefs, sat on the love seat sweating in anticipation, and stared blankly at the saturday morning cartoons on the television.
Samantha sauntered over joining Pete, as ever the curvaceous sexy beast he thought her to be. He still marvelled at how much she resembled Tiffany Amber Thiesen. "Uncanny!" he thought to himself. Her black bob style haircut had grown a little longer and now had a few red streaks in it. Otherwise, she hadn't changed much since he saw her last. He thought her dress very cosmopolitan consisting of a black blouse, red scarf, wool skirt, and knee high black leather boots. Her baby powder and roses smelling perfume helped settle Pete's nerves a little, but not nearly as much as her hand gently stroking his thigh, her head propped up on her elbow, and a sudden warmness to her demeanor.
"Aren't situations best when they're win - win, Pete?" Samantha asked in a soft voice. Pete hesitated a nod, still ill at ease, feeling like he was in some kind of lion's den. "I want to proposition you," Samantha continued, her hand crawling further up his thigh. "You see, ever since that day you walked in on Rebecca and myself and we had our little exchange we've been talking about you. Rebecca felt like she needed to have a personal one-on-one confessional with you and, believe it or not, I was the one who suggested she ask you to make her the woman she felt she needed to be. She no doubt told you we're both bisexual. We also both find you terribly cute, not to mention well endowed," she said with a mischievous giggle bringing her hand up to within inches of Pete's hard on.
"I know you have a girlfriend, Katrina, and from what I've heard of her I think you ought to feel very lucky to be with her. However," Samantha interposed herself, shifting in her seat, and coquettishly staring up towards the ceiling, "here's the always sticky - ethical part of the deal, if you'd like to be our little boy toy, you know, a little swingin' something on the side for kicks, a secret tryst maybe, hmmm? Rebecca and I have just been talking about adding a little spice to the bedroom and your name always seems to surface. At first as a joke, but then ever more seriously," Samantha continued staring Pete in the eye, her hand now firmly grasping his cock. Pete started to form an answer, but Samantha cut him short. "You needn't worry about saying no. There will be no hard feelings. The option is yours," she reassured him.
"A boy toy?" Pete asked not ready to say yes, unsure about what he might be getting himself into, and removing Samantha's hand from his penis.
"Hold the phone! Didn't you put my step-mom's panties on my head and make sure the picture of my girlfriend was staring back at me that night to teach me a lesson about taking responsibility for my actions. A responsibility that I have towards others that care for me and that I care for, showing me that my actions are never really wholly my own and have unforeseen consequences that can never be predicted?" Pete asked now confused.
Samantha did not respond right away. "Oh gosh no, I was just fucking with your head. Though I must say that's a very mature conclusion, I'm impressed. Like I said, there's always an ethical side to these sorts of affairs. Remember, this is a proposition for physical love and not romantic love. I'm sure you understand the difference between the two. So do you wanna be our little boy toy or what?" she asked with her eyebrows raised and her nose in the air.
Pete thought he understood the difference between physical and romantic love. He understood what he and his step-sister experienced the night before extended beyond mere physical love. He had undoubtedly found himself in a sticky situation. His brain told him to decline, but his hormones screamed to go for it. He knew he would never have another opportunity like the one being offered. He knew it was doing wrong by Katrina, but right by Rebecca.
"Well? I'm waiting," Samantha reminded him. "Are you in?"
"Fuck yes!" growled Pete lunging in at her ample bosom, but Samantha pushed him away.
"Oh no, don't think I've forgotten about your punishment," chided Samantha. "Mens rea, that's Latin for criminal intent and is meant to measure blame. Actus reus is Latin for the physical component of the crime. Together they form the indictable offence I'm charging you with."
"Mea culpa," Pete replied with a smirk and shrug of his shoulders.
"Clever boy, now get down on your hands and knees and crawl over to my bed. I will be acting as your judge, jury, and executioner."
Pete did as ordered more than willing to play along. As he crawled over to her side of the dorm room Samantha followed behind him, digging her heels in the crack of his ass, pushing him forward. She demanded he stand, remove his underwear, and not move an inch. She removed her own clothing revealing a sheer black mesh bustier with gartered black stockings and black silk bikini style panties. She kept her black leather boots on, but removed the panties by detaching the hip straps. Pete peered at the sublime figure before him. His cock throbbed and ached as his eyes traced Samantha's curves. There again were the large conical breasts, the flaring feminine hips, and the bubble butt he remembered so well. And all of it on the creamiest skin he'd ever seen. There too was the "V" of pubic hair pointing down to pouty pussy lips and a pierced clitoris. He had forgotten about the phoenix tattoo below her navel and the rose on the small of her back. He licked his lips watching her fetch something from a drawer. She took out a pair of black satin gloves that made there way up to her elbows.
Pete began stroking himself and told Samantha she looked delicious. Samantha turned on her heels, furious.
"How dare you speak without permission!" she chastised him.
"We'll fix that right away," she continued and made her way to the bathroom. She returned holding a pair of white cotton panties in her hands. Sniffing the panties she confirmed they were Rebecca's.