"True but just telling me one thing might make my mood slightly better, Eleanor. I might not feel the need to punish you quite so much!" he murmured, smirking at me annoyingly before adding, "Although maybe I just enjoy playing with the forbidden flesh of a nun!"
I glared at him and clamped my lips tightly shut and he just laughed then walked away, returning after a few moments with a long wooden stick with loops dangling from either end. For a moment, I thought he was going to beat me with it but instead he slid one of the loops up my leg then made it tight before he did the same to my other leg, pushing my thighs wide apart as he inched the stick further and further up until it reached my knees. My thigh muscles groaned in protest at the unnaturally wide position my legs were in and I blushed as I realised that my pussy was exposed totally to his interested gaze.
"So pink and delicate...as you found out yesterday when I whipped it, Eleanor. I wonder how much more pain you can take there before you crack and tell me all that I wish to know?"
I had no idea myself so I just stared back at him, trying not to show the fear that was cascading through my veins. I gritted my teeth as his fingers explored the soft flesh, slithering between the still puffy folds and finding the swollen nub of my clit. I fought against the touch of his fingers, trying to deny the arousal that flowed through my body as he gently teased the bud out from under its protective hood of flesh then rolled it under the pad of his thumb.
"To think that all this sweetness has been wasting away for so many years...unless you have been sharing it with your novices and nuns? You did seem quite keen when your tongue was deep in Edith's arse, didn't you?"
He chuckled at my silence, reading the outrage and despair in my eyes as his hand slid up my body, through the unruly curls of my bush and onto my erect nipples.
"And these too; standing to attention like a pair of soldiers on guard duty!" the sheriff commented, stroking the stiff peaks with his fingers before he started to pinch one. I gasped as sweet pain shot into my body and then squealed as he kept applying more and more pressure with his fingernails until I forced my body up off the bench against the restrictive tightness of the ropes that held me.
"Remember, my dear lady, you can avoid all this if you just tell me what I want!"
His fingers gripped my other nipple and then he started to squeeze that too and again I yelped as the fresh pain tore into my flesh and up into my mind in an instant. I felt as if my nipple was being sliced off my body as his nails dug into the rubbery bud and my breath rushed out of my mouth and I tried to heave in fresh oxygen as he released the tortured flesh.
"Perhaps you are thinking that you can gain sainthood, my lady, from holding out for your faith? I don't wish to depress you but nobody is going to be told about your courage. Your friend, the Pope, isn't going to find any witnesses to beatify you. I could slice these pretty little nipples off and feed them to the dogs, do the same with your lips...both those up here and these down here," he murmured, touching my mouth then my pussy. "Remove your ears and scoop out your eyes and leave you on a street corner to beg for alms and still the Pope would learn nothing. You are completely in my power and will remain so until you decide to tell me what I wish to know!"
Horror filled my mind as I envisaged suffering what he was suggesting. Surely, that would drive me insane and I would be reduced to a babbling, blind crone, bereft of everything that made me human. Yet if I surrendered, I knew that he would probably still do all the same things and then murder me so that his secret was safe. All I could do was to endure for as long as possible and pray that someone would come to my rescue. Perhaps one of the other nuns would manage to get word to one of my friends at court? Unless they were all too busy flat on their backs entertaining customers in the sheriff's brothel? Despair gripped me then like a vice as I realised that it was no good depending on others to come to my aid like the proverbial knight in shining armour. Somehow, I would have to get both myself and Edith out of the sheriff's clutches before it was too late!
As for now though, I had to make sure that I survived whatever new evil the sheriff had planned for me, I thought to myself as he brought up one of the wooden chairs and sat down comfortably by my side.
"I suppose that you think that I am going straight down to hell when I die?" he commented as he resumed stroking my naked flesh idly with one hand. I stayed silent, not wishing to state the obvious and he laughed once again as he read my thoughts in my eyes. "Naturally you do, my dear abbess, though, just for your information, I don't believe either in heaven or hell! That shocks you, doesn't it?"
Not really, I thought to myself as I stared up into his bright blue eyes which were twinkling with amusement and devilry. My own faith had ebbed away like the tide over the years and my present predicament certainly wasn't doing anything to restore it. Where was God when you needed Him? Absent without leave so it appeared that I was going to have to find a way out of the situation or die in the attempt. A faint inkling of a plan did stir somewhere deep down in the back of my mind but it drifted away as the sheriff spoke to me once more.
"The fires of hell await me according to you so I think that I will give you a little foretaste just in case I meet you there!" the sheriff added and I went rigid with fear as his other hand came into view holding a thick candle set into a brass holder. My breathing quickened dramatically as he slowly moved the holder closer and closer to my breasts until it hovered just above while his mouth grinned with amusement at my terror. He tilted the candle holder slightly and I watched in horrified fascination as the wax started to move, slithering ever closer to falling. He moved his hand further and the first droplet of liquid fire kissed my breast and I screamed at the shocking sharpness of the pain that shot into my senses in a flash. I bucked upwards, trying to tear myself free from the ropes that bound me but it was to no avail as they held me securely. A grim chuckle at my distress came from the sheriff and he tilted the candle again and a stream of wax poured out and splashed down onto my skin, coating my softness with heat and pain. The next drops struck the rubbery bud of my nipple and my squeals reached a new higher pitch of intensity as did the pain. My flesh throbbed with agony as he splashed more fiery fluid down onto my body, raining it down like hellfire as I squirmed and screamed helplessly.
A brief hiatus came after a minute or so as he leaned over and studied my white-stained flesh before he asked, "Are you ready to talk to me yet?"
I glared at him, putting all the feeling that I could into my expression but it just amused him and he laughed as he switched positions, getting out of his chair and moving round to sit on the bench between my spread thighs. Was he going to take me, ripping through my thin hymen? The thought sent shivers running through my body but then I was back to screaming once more as he began to dribble hot spheres of wax down into my dark curls, gradually nearing the softness of my pussy lips. His cock pressed wetly against my thigh, stiffening slowly and lengthening until its thick knob teased the tight entrance to my quim. I felt it part my wet folds as the first drop of wax fell through the air and landed on my pussy and I nearly tore the lining of my throat out as the fresh rawness of the pain seethed through my body. I found myself hyperventilating as I waited for the next flood of wax and I screwed up my eyes tightly then opened them in agony as more fiery kisses rained down on my delicate flesh. His cock pushed deeper into me, aroused by my pain and more wax fell, caressing the top of my pussy with agony just as he pushed forward further and took my virginity away. The piercing pain made me scream even louder and then I was lost in agony and arousal as he surged in and out of my wetness, wax dribbling down over my body, splashing haphazardly from the candle onto my stomach and breasts then my thighs. I could feel my traitorous body respond to the surging thrusts of his thick shaft even as my maiden blood trickled out of my pussy and glistened on his cock. He blew the candle out and leant forward, gripping my hips and pulling my body into his length, shafting me harder and faster, eyes screwed up almost in pain as my tight innards squeezed and pulsed around his prick. The soft squelchy sound of our bodies meeting in the age-old dance of lust filled the room and then I was lost in a world of red mist as I came, gasping out my pleasure as a great flood of semen shot out of his cock and bathed my quim. Shamed at my arousal, I still could not deny it as it exploded in my brain and made me cry out whilst my body juddered against his as he thrust in and out dementedly, expelling all of his hot spunk deep into my tight tube.