Author's note: Though the events depicted in the story are entirely fictitious, they are based on real discussions with a real-life person. The omission of all names is thus entirely intentional for privacy protection reasons, but also to enable some self-insertion for the reader should you wish to do so. I hope that you enjoy the scene!
*~*~*~*
This is it. Just over two years of knowing each other, countless words exchanged, including in some very inappropriate places at very inappropriate times, thousands of miles later, and we are finally going to meet.
It's not possible for me to put into words how many times I thought about this moment or the various scenarios that my mind conjured of how this would go. I actually shake these thoughts off as I make my way to the café. These thoughts aren't helpful. Stay in the moment, don't set yourself up for anything except what's happening right now, remember that you're not obliged to do anything. I remind myself of these things like a mantra that scares away anxiety and nerves.
The odd thing is that I'd never be this nervous on a first date with anyone I met on a dating app. Having learnt to take first dates very much at face value, no expectations except to see if we get along, I was always the one who was very relaxed and confident, watching with slightly amused bafflement how my dates were the exact opposite of that.
But this isn't quite a first date. There's already some intimate and vulnerable history between us, he knows parts of me that not many people have ever gotten to experience. This may be the first time we meet, but it comes with expectations far exceeding those of a first date.
It almost happened that this would be just a first meeting of two people who connected online. However steamy the circumstances of that connection may be. But through various factors, neither of us is currently attached. Whilst I can't speak for him, I certainly need to get some things out of my system. At the very least satisfy a curiosity. Fantasising about the unknown is easy, reliving what you've only ever imagined is infinitely exciting - reality doesn't always hold up in the same way. This meeting will either close a lid on that or open a completely new door that I hadn't expected. That I didn't allow myself to expect.
That is why I've checked and rechecked myself in the mirror probably fifty times before stepping out of the hotel room. For some reason lost to history now, I've always envisioned wearing this pink dress to our first meeting: it's cute, it's feminine, it flatters my body in all the right ways, and floats elegantly with the lift of a petticoat in the breeze. But are the cottagecore stays too much? Yes, they give my tits the most amazing lift, the crescent moons above the dress' neckline getting even me excited, but the doubtful voices in my head say that I just look like a wannabe Instagram influencer. Are the heels too much? They're comfy for me, but this is supposed to be chill, do they read across as too dressy? And gods only know how many times I've faffed with my hair, trying to give it the windswept volume that looks effortless and is anything but. I know that by most people's standards I am overdressed anywhere I go, on any given day of the week - but this one guy's opinion somehow matters and I want him to see the real me, whilst also thinking me attractive.
At least the denim jacket is undeniably casual. Thrown on without fastening, it shields me from the still chilly March breeze, whilst taking some of the edge of the extra frilly, girly personification of spring that's currently marching down the street. I catch a glimpse of myself, brown hair now actually windswept, flowing in sync with the dress, green eyes shining a little bit because the sunshine and the anticipation make me happy, the chill sending a natural blush to my face as if I wasn't pink enough already, and it gives me the confidence boost that I needed. I look good. I look like myself. I feel like that too. If that is too much for him... Well, I guess one other thing I had in mind when getting dressed today was also how easy it'd be to undress me.
The café was only a short walk from my hotel. A deliberate choice to minimise commuting time, whether for a need of an escape or retreat. But also because these big American cities intimidate me so much. I've lived in cities all my life, I've been to even bigger cities, but as a European I find the American need to make everything so goddamn tall excessive. No wonder they're calling this The Windy City, the drafts caught in the tunnels these buildings are creating are amplifying whatever bit of wind may wander past into a gale. The less I deal with that by keeping my commute short, the better.
Once inside, I realise that I'm the first to arrive, so I order a tea and find two cushy armchairs that create their own private booth. Not that privacy is that needed - it's that awkward time in the afternoon where lunchtime people are long gone, the three people who came here to work are all solo and spread out, and the mothers catching up with each other on the way back from school run are now rushing to pick their kids back up.
From where I'm sat by the window I have a view of one side of the street (not very exciting, just the road and slate grey of the buildings mirroring those on my side), as well as the door and the people coming in and out. The few that do at this time. Still, it's peaceful. There's something immensely enjoyable about people watching, trying to guess their life stories whilst warming my chilly fingers around a large cup of tea. I wonder if any of them are trying to guess my story right now. And if any of them came even close to the truth.
It doesn't take long before he arrives. He's a little shorter than I thought (but then I am terrible at visualising people's heights even with an actual measurement) and it's been a while since we've exchanged a photo, but there's no mistaking him for anyone else. The casual 90s inspired jacket and jeans suit him a lot and I immediately notice that he's shaved. As much as I liked the moustache, this cleaner look suits the clothes more. My heart jumps, suddenly all nervous, but I ignore it and stand up smiling wide.
"Hi!" I say, hoping that it wasn't too loud for the other people in the café whilst simultaneously not caring about that one single bit.
"Hi!" His voice, which I'm only hearing for the first time, is warm and friendly, and it instantly makes me feel reassured because he sounds just as excited to see me. "It's so good to finally meet you!"
We close the distance between each other, both spreading our arms wide, then fall into a tight hug. Almost despite myself I notice how soft the fabric of his jumper is. And that he has been working out, like he's been saying he has.
"Lemme get a drink and I'll be right back with you."
I try not to stare too much whilst he's at the counter, but with how many glances I am sneaking in and with my refusing to occupy myself in the usual way of looking down at my phone, I may as well have done. So instead I focus on replaying his words in my head, listening to this voice and, more importantly, the accent. Two years of trying to guess are finally over and if I'm honest, I'm relieved that whilst the American influence is undeniably there, it's still broken up with the echoes from his home country. It's a lot more pleasant and somehow even a bit more familiar to my ears that way.
Soon enough he's back with a steaming mug of coffee, if the aroma is anything to go by.
"I still can't believe you're here," he says, big smile plastered on his face, as he sits down in the chair opposite me.
"Me neither. And I'm not sure which is more surreal, this," I gesture to the street outside, "or this," my hand flicks between the two of us.
"Definitely this!" His hand mirrors the latter gesture and we both laugh knowingly.
And just like that, the atmosphere of nervous anticipation relaxes. This isn't the first time I've met online friends IRL and this isn't the first time I've met with a guy whom I met online. There's an odd sense of familiarity that helps me ease into the conversation - though not as much as the good natured chat that he's driving forward.
Soon enough the remains of both of our drink are starting to dry up at the bottoms of the cups and we are still talking and laughing. Time stopped being something my body perceived, like every other time I've enjoyed myself to the fullest.
"You know," he says, leaning an elbow on the armrest and propping his chin up on his hand, "we should've used voice chat sooner."
"It was hard to coordinate with how busy you constantly are."
"And with the time difference."
"And with how inevitably one of us says something not safe for work or public spaces."
"We haven't now!"
"It's a new record."
We laugh the comment off and then he leans closer to me with a smile. However, it's the glint in his eye that signals the shift in tone, even before he opens his mouth.
"But how much more delicious these inappropriate things must sound with that cute British accent of yours."
It's at times like these that I desperately wish that I possessed the ability of lifting just one eyebrow. I still make an attempt; if I believe that I am the heroine of the story of my life who arches a brow in situations like this, then it has to become the reality, right?
"Oh? Is that so?" My voice lowers just a little, rounding those o's even more. I'm rewarded with that smirk growing on his face.
"It is indeed." He tries to copy my way of speaking and manages a good enough British accent. Except that his voice, also appropriately lowered, does things to my stomach that I haven't experienced in a long while.
"Why don't we go for dessert then? Seeing as we're done with our drinks?"
The cafe's counter is still pretty full with pastries and muffins left over from lunch. He catches my drift and with an approving smile, stands up whilst throwing his jacket on in what has to be just one motion, then gestures gallantly towards the door: