I sat in the coffee shop with Tasha, half zoned out as she talked away about her boyfriend problems. I was still a little preoccupied, and I knew she didn't care if I was listening or not.
It had been a few weeks since I had told Aaron about my indiscretion. It was a rough night. I had told him that I had slept with my ex boyfriend, and he had slapped me across the face and left me. Thinking about it still stung, but I had been trying to move forward and keep myself busy. That's why I had agreed to go out with Tasha. She was a good time sink.
But I still found myself thinking about him. I really did love him. He treated me well, he was fun, he was attractive... and I still regretted my night with my ex. It was a moment of weakness. After all, what girl can turn down a guy who tucks her hair behind her ear, lifts her chin, and kisses her... It was entrapment, really. But I really did feel remorse. Aaron had meant the world to me. And I deserved to be left.
"...then he didn't text me back ALL night, what am I supposed to..." she continued chattering as I looked around the room. Lots of people, not feeling the guilt that I felt. Not feeling the sting in their faces and hearts from a bad memory.
The bell on the coffeeshop door rang as somebody entered, and I casually glanced over. It was Aaron. I felt a panic in my stomach and I let my hair fall like a curtain to hide my face. I stared at the table and held my breath as he walked past me. I heard a chair scrape the floor, and I felt him sitting behind me. I did my best to ignore it. Maybe he hadn't seen me.
"...so THEN I walked to the store because he was.." Tasha still chattered on, not noticing that I had turned white as a sheet. I felt my phone buzz.
You still thinking about me? --Aaron
I ignored the text and stirred my coffee. I could feel his hand print on my cheek, and I could feel the guilt rising up again like a pot of boiling water.
I was last night... I thought about all the things I wanted to do to punish you. -- Aaron
I crossed my legs and felt a twinge from between my legs... I hadn't taken care of my needs since he left me. Much to my dismay, I could feel myself getting wet. Memories of his huge pulsing cock flashed across my mind, and I tried to push them away. The way he stretched and filled me so effortlessly... The thought of him punishing me both terrified and excited me. Trembling, I texted back
What kind of punishment..?
I heard him laugh a little behind me and I flinched. I must have been white as a sheet, because Tasha stopped her blue streak to ask if I was okay. I nodded and tried to smile. She shrugged and continued. After a few agonizing moments, buzz.
Do you still love me? --Aaron
Yes. Undeniably. But how could I ever forgive myself. How could he ever forgive me...? Yes. But I don't deserve you.
He laughed again and shifted his weight. The next text came quickly.
Follow me. Do not talk. Just follow. --Aaron
I packed up my stuff. "Tasha, something came up, see you for movie night next Friday, I promise." He walked out the door and trailed behind him, watching my feet and trying to suppress the nauseating fear. The walk to his apartment went all too quickly. When we got there, he locked the door and turned to look at me. There was a darkness in his eyes I had only seen once before. My cheek burned.
"You betrayed me. You made me hurt. Do you still love me, Demi?"
I nodded, remembering not to speak.